Contents: Our Vision Letter from the Chairman & President/CEO About Us Investment Strategy Development/ Value-Added Multi-Family Retail Office Hospitality Restaurants Land Construction Asset Management Financial Advisors Encore Equities Discipline. Research. Experience. Integrity Research our vision Contents: Our Vision Letter from the Chairman & President/CEO About Us Investment Strategy Development/ Value-Added Multi-Family Retail Office Hospitality Restaurants Land Construction Asset Management Financial Advisors Encore Equities Research Experience Contents: Our Vision Letter from the Chairman & President/CEO About Us Investment Strategy Development/ Value-Added Multi-Family Retail Office Hospitality Restaurants land Construction Asset Management Financial Advisors Encore Equities Research 3 About Us Encore is a privately owned, vertically integrated, actively managed real estate investment company that invests in value-added and opportunistic strategies. We are an entrepreneurial company operating on the principles of integrity, discipline and commitment and a solid foundation of a dedicated and experienced management team, driven by the vision and perseverance of the founders. We develop, acquire and manage: Hospitality-Limited & Full-Service Hotels Retail-Grocery Anchored Shopping Centers & Single Tenant Centers Multi-Family Residential Projects Office Buildings Residential Land Developments Restaurants Encore is a research-driven firm. Research is critical in all phases of real estate, which at Encore include value-added acquisitions, development, asset management, recapitalization, and dispositions. Anticipating change in global capital and local property markets through the use of rigorous analytical tools and proprietary databases help us assess relative value, manage and mitigate risk, and determine the price at which we are a buyer or a seller. Our goal is to be best in class in each sector, to create a sustainable organization, and to build wealth for our investors and team members. About US • • • • • • The Encore Evolution 1999 Encore founded with Hotel and Retail Groups 2001 Acquisition of Pineapple Management 2003 Acquisition of hotel portfolio 2005 Encore, following three hurricanes including Hurricane Katrina, successfully orchestrates disaster recovery on behalf of its employees, their families, and the Company 2007 Encore sells $400 million portfolio 2008 Encore launches Multi-Family Group 2009 Encore launches High Net Worth Wealth Management Group 2011 Encore launches Office and EB-5 Capital Groups 2013 Encore launches Land Group 2014 Encore sells $174 Million Multi-family Portfolio and launches Restaurant and Financial Advisors Groups 2015 Encore sells Sterling Resorts in excess of $10 million NCREIF total annualized U.S. property return, % Encore Recapitalizes $175 Million Multi-family Portfolio 30% Encore Founded with Hotel and Retail Groups Encore Launches High Net Worth Wealth Management Group 20% Acquisition of Hotel Portfolios Encore Sells $400 Million Portfolio 10% 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 -10% Acquisition of Pineapple Management Encore launches successful disaster recovery following Hurricane Katrina Encore Launches Land Group -20% Encore Launches Multi-Family Group Encore Launches Restaurants and Financial Advisors Groups -30% EB-5 Immigration Capital Program and Office Groups Launched Encore sells Sterling Resorts in excess of $10 Million About US Encore Milestones Contents: Our Vision Letter from the Chairman & President/CEO Investment Strategy Development/ Value-Added Multi-Family Retail Office Hospitality Restaurants Land Construction Asset Management Teamwork Financial Advisors Encore Equities Research Investment Streategy About Us Investment Strategy Encore is a real estate investment company which focuses on several property types including multi-family, office, retail, hospitality, restaurants, emergency medical centers and land. Exhibit 1. Encore focuses on value-added and opportunistic property strategies. Stock Equity Fixed Income Alternative Assets Real Estate Encore Strategy Public Private Debt Equity CMBS REITs/ REOCs Mortgages Property Value-Added Multi-Family Office Retail Hotel Restaurants Land Vacant Space Deferred CAPEX Recapitalization Opportunity Land Entitlement Development Encore’s investment style is either value-added or opportunistic. The former includes the acquisition of existing properties with substantial vacant space, aggressively leasing or releasing space, providing for necessary capital expenditures, and recapitalizing the asset. Opportunistic strategies include land entitlement and development. Depending on whether portfolios sell at a discount or premium to net asset value and the temporary expansion of spreads between development costs and exit cap rates, the firm will acquire portfolios of existing properties or developable land. Encore co-invests substantial equity in all of its transactions. Investment Strategy D’Iberville Courtyard Hotel D’Iberville, MS The life cycle of an investment differs depending on whether the investment style is opportunistic or value-added. Development can provide alternative exit strategies, including sale at the end of the entitlement period. Encore only develops when conditions are favorable; otherwise we sell assets, pursue value-added transactions, or just remain on the sidelines, as we have in the past. Rather than operating superficially across myriad markets (like a skipping stone across a placid pool), our teams focus on fewer markets (as dictated by our research), which enables them to dive deeply into the ownership structure of a market and identify more off-market opportunities, including distressed assets. Each property group is functionally self-contained, but works synergistically with other groups and draws upon the full resources of the company, including capital, research, performance reporting, technology, banking, and accounting. Property groups, each of which has impressive experience in value-added and development transactions, are able to toggle between these two investment styles depending on market conditions and which style provides the best risk-adjusted returns. If the market rests at a point of inflection in the property cycle and we believe price changes are imminent, the property team, under the guidance of the Investment Committee, determines whether it makes sense to remain on the sidelines or sell. Research, which is distributed across all functions of the firm, is a systematic, evidenced-based way of thinking about problems and turning these problems into investment opportunities. Research at Encore is the backbone of investing. The firm invests substantial resources in its research function, which spans the granular details of a single deal and the complexities of global capital markets. We are information sponges; we translate data into information and information into knowledge; we are independent thinkers. Our success reflects the following principles: • Remain true to your investment style. • Invest when markets are in disarray, market liquidity is low, price discovery is impaired, and fear rules the day. • Buy below replacement cost and seek out great assets in weak financial hands. • Wait indefinitely rather than make a bad investment out of compulsion. • Eschew herd mentality; wisdom of the crowd is inherently fraught with danger for investors. Investment Strategy Vision Exhibit 2. Value-added and opportunistic investment timelines compared. Sell Development Value-Added Raw Land Entitle Land Develop Lease Acquire Lease and Rehab Stabilize and Sell Stabilize and Sell Contents: About Us Investment Strategy Development/ Value-Added Multi-Family Retail Office Hospitality Restaurants Land Construction Asset Management Financial Advisors Encore Equities Research Development/Value Added Our Vision Letter from the Chairman & President/CEO Encore 6162 Dallas, TX Encore Memorial Tulsa, OK Encore Alsbury Burleson, TX Encore Multi-Family Encore Multi-Family, LLC, founded in 2008, is a full-scale multi-family developer with a concentration in the southern regions of the United States. The company’s capabilities include multi-family developments and acquisitions, including ground-up developments, value-added acquisitions, joint ventures, mixed use, and urban infill communities. The Multi-Family team delivers quality work on time and on budget. The Multi-Family team combines the personal attention of a small firm with the resources of a large firm. Members of this team have trained with the nation’s top multi-family developers and amassed an impressive transaction and performance resume. Rather than superficially operate across many markets, it focuses on fewer markets in which its knowledge of off-market, distressed situations is superior. Encore Landing Temple , TX The choice of renting or owning is one that is very sensitive to demographics and lifestyle issues, relative prices, macroeconomic conditions, personal income and household wealth. The team has experience acquiring, repositioning, or developing single family, condominiums, as well as multi-family properties. All of these property types are, to varying degrees, near substitutes; knowing how to recognize and exploit short-term market imbalances is a signature skill. Encore 281 San Antonio, TX Development/Value-Added Encore Multi-Family has one of the most seasoned management teams in the industry. Encore Retail Encore Retail, LLC specializes in the value-added acquisition and development of neighborhood and community shopping centers. The single tenant division provides complete in-house real estate services from site selection to store openings. The team acquires, owns, repositions, asset-manages and develops highgrade properties from the ground-up in primary and growing secondary markets. Value-added components include leasing, remerchandising, renovation, and redevelopment, specifically adding density, changing use or building out vacant pads. Encore Retail also offers NNN solutions tailored to the client’s needs on a national scale with local focus, including national roll-outs, corporate, and franchise driven expansion programs. The management team consists of proven leaders in acquiring, developing, financing, negotiating, leasing and managing retail assets. The group has strong relationships with tenants, especially with all of the major grocers and local and national brokers. Identifying at an early stage a grocer anchor is critical in attracting high quality, in-line tenants and securing third-party capital. Encore Retail has had considerable success investing in secondary and tertiary markets. Retail is less concentrated than office in the larger, gateway cities, and offers a greater variety of investment opportunities in smaller cities. Governor’s Pointe Cincinnati, Ohio Encore pursues large multi-use projects that include retail, multifamily, single-family land, office and other synergistic uses. Strong retail performance depends on many of the same economic drivers as those which support office and multi-family performance, such as employment, household wealth and disposable income. For example, an urban grocery store, its complementary in-line shops and adjoining office space can help support the demand for urban apartments. Development/Value-Added Pelham Towne Center Pelham, AL The Towers at Frisco Square Frisco, TX Encore Corporate Office Occidental Tower Dallas, TX Two Forest Plaza Dallas, TX Encore Office Encore Office, LLC acquires, develops, redevelops and repositions A-quality office properties to achieve consistent risk-adjusted returns. Members of the Encore Office team have acquired or developed over $1.8 billion of office investments. The ability to switch between value-added and development strategies is a prized skill which enables the firm to actively participate in a broad set of cities over most of the real estate cycle. The emphasis is pursuing off-market opportunities and identifying value-enhancing opportunities which may not be readily apparent to the market. The success of an office investment depends critically upon how market conditions determine the initial rent and the rate of rental growth. Financial structuring alters the distribution of net operating income, but the underlying fundamentals are critical for long-term success. Even when pursuing value-added strategies with existing properties, the team considers the development pipeline, the size distribution of projects on line, the lagged arrival of new space, the likely impact on investment performance, and the total demand for space by all users, including corporate owners and governments. In addition to acquiring assets below replacement cost, aggressively managing tenant quality and lease terms are important risk reduction tools. Leases are often to the tenant a substitute for corporate bonds. As such, using extensive databases, the team is better able than most investors to assess the nuances of tenant credit and default probability. The team views an office building as a portfolio of leases which can be an important source of flexibility; much of this flexibility pertains to the ability to improve the credit quality, increase the diversity of the tenant mix, and lease vacant space. Value-added strategies may involve acquiring an office building with substantial vacant space and aggressively releasing the space to expanding or newly arrived office tenants, or even converting the occupancy of a portion of the building to nonoffice uses, such as apartments. Development/Value-Added The team, while self-contained, relies upon the capital and other shared resources of the parent company. Encore’s senior leadership brings essential knowledge to negotiating, properly underwriting and closing transactions. The team has developed impressive research and underwriting capabilities, which facilitates a better assessment of urban and regional economics. Commitment Encore Hospitality Encore Hospitality, LLC is a private real estate acquisition, development, and asset management company focusing on the upper mid-priced, branded select-service and full-service hotel sector. Encore Hospitality has one of the most seasoned management teams in the industry. The team has extensive experience in value-added and development strategies; it is equally proficient in stand-alone and mixed-use hotel strategies. Hotel investing is consistent with the firm’s active management investment strategy. Hotels require the continual active management of capital expenditures, marketing, and room sales. The team has impressive management experience in these areas and knows how to create incremental value. For example, a significant portion of the net proceeds of Encore’s August 2007 portfolio sale reflected the team’s timely purchase and professional management of the firm’s hotel portfolio. Hotels are a synergistic complement to office, public-private development, and even retail. Since Encore has embedded many self-contained but centrally managed property groups, Encore and its investors can capture the unique synergies and beneficial spillovers derived from the joint development or redevelopment of various property types, including hotel. Development/Value-Added Starting in 1999, Encore significantly increased the Company’s hospitality portfolio from seven hotel assets to as many as forty-one. The firm gained a skilled hotel management team and a number of Marriott hotels when it acquired Pineapple Management Services, Inc. and Sterling Resorts. 22 Encore Restaurants Encore Restaurants, LLC develops, owns and manages specific territories of various Full Dining and Fast Casual concepts. Five Guys Burger and Fries. We currently own 8 and have 12 in development for 2015 in the Central corridor of California. Our plan also includes 33 more in this territory by 2018. Our Mississippi IHOP territory is still expanding. The 2 established locations will be accompanied by 2 new locations summer of 2015. Established in 2014, Encore Restaurants, LLC, is a new division for Encore Enterprises Inc., and will put Encore center stage as one of the leaders in restaurant operations and growth. Encore Restaurants’ capabilities include: • Brand selection criteria lending to the most desirable risk to reward ratios. • Tenured, national experience providing precise execution of national concepts and operations. • A strong team of leaders with the unique ability to reach higher in levels of sales and profitability. • Operating fast casual and full dining brands with national advertising funds. This enables strong marketing, and increased leverage with suppliers nationwide. • Treating guest to great tasting food, in a clean environment, with top shelf service. Five Guys Burger and Fries Fresno, CA Encore Restaurants is now exploring newer concepts that can strengthen our current portfolio. 23 IHOP Pascagoula, MS Encore Land Encore Land, LLC is a land investment company focusing on the identification and acquisition of strategic land parcels in unique locations for the master planning and entitlement of commercial and residential developments. The team focuses on markets and submarkets with the strong prospects of long-term secular growth. The land developer essentially manages a portfolio of options, retaining those options which are cheap and selling those options which are dear. The more volatile the market, the more valuable is the option and the stronger is the incentive for the owner to defer development and warehouse the land. Jordan Run Estates II Midlothian, TX The entitlement and re-entitlement phases of development can account for a large share of the total value created by the development process. In some cases, the best execution is selling just-entitled land and letting others take the risk of development. In other cases, by acquiring land at a low price, Encore Land can hold the land in its inventory and either sell or develop at a later time. Villages of Park Hill Mansfield, TX Development/Value-Added Land development is replete with significant optionality: the option to entitle, the option to develop, the option to sell, the option to delay, the option to switch uses (through re-entitlement). Knowing how to value these real options is not just an art form; it is amenable to rigorous analysis. Our research team is skilled in pricing these embedded real options. Encore Construction Encore Construction, LLC provides turn-key commercial construction services, which include cost estimation, quality assurance and scheduling, subcontract negotiation, field engineering, financing and document control, negotiating the permit process, foundation work, masonry, steel and wood framing, drywall and interior finishes, HVAC, electrical and communication and data systems. The team has completed over 17 million square feet or $200 million of commercial retail space and over 7,700 hotel rooms and multi-family units across 18 states. Our group has experience working through the toughest regulatory and developmental obstacles. The team works with sophisticated, institutional grade clients, such as Goldman Sachs Group, Inc., Bank of America/Merrill Lynch, Wells Fargo/Wachovia, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., Lowe’s Home Centers, Inc., Marriott International, Inc., and Hilton Worldwide. International House of Pancakes Pascagoula, MS All the Encore property groups benefit from the insights and experience that only a well-seasoned construction management firm provides. 25 Villages of Park Hill Mansfield, TX Development/Value-Added Encore 6162 Construction Dallas, TX Contents: About Us Investment Strategy Development/ Value-Added Multi-Family Retail Office Hospitality Restaurants Land Construction Asset Management Financial Advisors Driven Encore Equities Research Asset/Financial Management Our Vision Letter from the Chairman & President/CEO Asset Management Asset management is a critical function because once the firm commits to an investment, be it a value-added or development strategy, asset management must oversee and manage the investment’s performance. Encore has adopted a distributed asset management function wherein each property group manages its own asset management strategy. Encore has a matrix organizational structure; the property group manages the day-today operations of asset management and the holding company, through its executive management team, oversees all corporate governance and monitors financial performance. We embrace technology because, when used well, it increases efficiency and promotes the diffusion of information, which is the life blood of our business. Encore has invested a great deal of capital in systems, performance reporting, information technology, and risk management tools because we are first and foremost investors and not fee-based asset managers. We are grateful nevertheless that institutional and high net worth investors alike applaud our commitment to state-of-the art technology. Encore has been an industry leader in its quest for paperless management systems. Over the last three years the firm has completely transferred its applications to the cloud, enabling the company to use best-in-class applications to maximize productivity and to enhance its internal control and reporting systems. Diligence Asset Management Trust Contents: Our Vision Letter from the Chairman & President/CEO Investment Strategy Development/ Value-Added Multi-Family Retail Office Hospitality Restaurants Land Construction Asset Management Financial Advisors Encore Capital Research Encore Capital About Us Financial Advisors Encore Financial Advisors, LLC is a full-service wealth management firm serving family office, high-net worth, and institutional investors. As an independent fiduciary for clients, we seek to empower clients with institutional-level access to intelligence and solutions sourced from across Wall Street’s major firms as well as the broader market. Whether clients engage with our banking and lending services, investment management, trust & estate planning, insurance solutions, or sophisticated capital markets projects, we work to fully understand the needs and goals of our clients to guide development of custom solutions. We believe that true wealth management brings together all the elements of your financial life—including investments, tax planning, estate planning, risk management, and more— into a long-term strategy, informed by your uniquely personal priorities, that is designed to bring about continued success across generations. Our mission at Encore Financial Advisors is to make that happen. Our advisors are fully independent of Wall Street, but have access to all of its resources. As a result, we are free to put your needs front and center—we do not push products, while seeking to provide access to unique investment opportunities. Our advisors will consult with your family attorney, accountant and other advisors, or we can recommend highly qualified experts. Coordinating all your advisors will ensure that all your financial activities work in concert to realize your vision of the future. Most important, we listen. We seek to understand where your issues lie, what keeps you up at night. Then, we draw from the full range of wealth management solutions to deliver a customized approach to addressing what concerns you. Encore Financial Advisors…driven by our passion to help investors realize their life and organizational vision. Our Financial Planning Process: Financial Advisors Our Scope of Services: Leadership Contents: Our Vision Letter from the Chairman & President/CEO Investment Strategy Development/ Value-Added Multi-Family Retail Office Hospitality Restaurants Land Construction Asset Management Financial Advisors Encore Equities Research Encore Capital About Us Integrity Encore Equities Encore Equities Management, LLC manages the funding of offerings for the various real estate value-added and opportunistic (development) opportunities and works closely with the investors. Encore creates efficient capital structures in order to reduce the weighted average cost of capital and minimize loss. The capital stack may involve a layering of claims which may include the equity (GP and LP), mezzanine debt or equity, and senior debt. In the case of development, the capital needs may include guarantees, predevelopment funding, bridge loans, construction loans, and acquisition lines. Encore believes that institutional and high net worth capital can and should be complementary; hence, Encore always looks for innovative and prudent ways to combine institutional and high net worth capital. Exhibit 3. Encore minimizes the overall cost of capital to any project. Value of Financial Interests Capital Stack GP Equity The owner has a call option on the property with an exercise price equal to the face amounts of the senior and subordinated debt. The creditors are long the firm and short the call option held by the owner. LP Equity Subordinated Debt Senior Debt Property Value F1F1+F2 F1+F2+F3 Encore Capital Encore Capital consists of two capital raising platforms: (1) Encore Wealth Management, LLC sources equity capital from high net worth individuals and family offices and (2) Encore Global, LLC raises capital through foreign nationals focused on EB-5 investment. Our Global team’s mission is to help foreign investors achieve their immigration and investment goals while revitalizing local and regional real estate markets, which will promote the growth of U.S. jobs and the local economy. Encore additionally raises institutional equity through outside placement firms. Collaboration Contents: Our Vision Letter from the Chairman & President/CEO About Us Development/ Value-Added Multi-Family Retail Office Hospitality Public/Private Construction Land Asset Management Financial Advisors Encore Equities Research Research Investment Strategy Encore Research What is the purpose of research? Research is systematic, evidencebased inquiry; at Encore it forms the backbone of every investment decision. The purpose of research is to provide a competitive edge to all facets of the investment process, to enhance value, and to manage and price risk. Research has a dual focus: the broad economic and capital market forces that drive value and local and regional economic drivers. Research at Encore consists of (1) property market research to estimate the levels and rates of growth of rents and other deal parameters; (2) portfolio research to explore ways to incorporate real estate within a multi-asset portfolio; (3) capital markets, which includes the study of capital flows, capitalization rates, and capital market strategies; and (4) risk management, which analyzes and manages potential losses. Property market research. Markets are always in disequilibrium, and they slowly reestablish balance. This adjustment process is a complex dynamic incorporating subtle simultaneity, feedback loops, leads and lags. Since property development, especially large office development, involves long lags, the careful study of market dynamics and rental growth paths is essential. We generate metropolitan as well as submarket supply and demand market gap forecasts to help guide our investment decisions. Property markets are cyclical; they are rarely synchronized. Encore periodically reviews for each property market and property type the best investment strategy. Sometimes it makes sense to develop; at other times, value-added acquisitions are more desirable given the cost to build. Property market scenario analysis. Encore models the supply and demand dynamics of metropolitan property markets using sophisticated econometric methods tempered by experience and market knowledge. Property performance reflects these dynamics. Our approach book-ends a strong bottom-up analysis with a series of macro, or top down, scenario forecasts to test the validity and internal consistency of deal assumptions, including exit capitalization rates. Portfolio research. Encore is a leader in real estate portfolio research. Investors always ask Encore: What is the appropriate portfolio allocation for property? Since real estate can be public or private, equity or debt, the answer to this question is not straightforward, especially when we consider investor liabilities and aversion to loss. Optimizing the performance of the portfolio’s surplus—assets minus liabilities—introduces new, even counter-intuitive complexities: safer assets may be risky and higher risk assets may be safer in the context of liabilities. We focus on a number of sources of risk, which include lease default, the likelihood and associated cost of development delay, the choice of floating versus fixed rated debt, optimal portfolio mix, hedging, valuation of guarantees as a function of LTV, valuation of real options (including the option to expand, the option to postpone, and the option to sell a development project), lease renewal and extension options, and optimal working capital and other reserves. We occasionally use sophisticated risk simulation techniques, such as Monte Carlo analysis, to evaluate complex transactions. Static analysis, which is the industry standard, usually fails to convey the true extent or implications of risk; in fact, it often masks risk. Research Risk assessment. The English dramatist, William Gilbert, of Gilbert and Sullivan, once wrote, “Things are seldom what they seem; Skim milk masquerades as cream.” Investment risk is no exception. Investors frequently ask, what is the likelihood of a capital loss or negative return? Encore embraces the explicit and rigorous assessment (and pricing) of risk using Monte Carlo and other simulation techniques. We actually analyze riskadjusted returns; we do not just talk about it. Exhibits 4 and 5 illustrate this point. These exhibits compare the expected performance of two complex, highly structured deals, each with the same projected average returns, 13.5%. Investors who conclude that the projected performances of Investments A and B are identical would be wrong. Investment A, as Exhibit 4 indicates, has less downside risk than Investment B because the probability of loss, 3.6%, is less than the likelihood of loss associated with Investment B, 13.2%. However, Investment B has more upside beyond a 20% return. Unlike traditional or static analysis, which collapses performance into one number—the average—Monte Carlo treats risk explicitly and correctly evaluates the shape of risk or the distribution of returns. Investors, both general and limited partners, especially those who seek to mitigate potential loss, value and understand this intuitive approach to risk. Encore continually studies capital market flows and non-real estate asset performance in order to price real estate property risk more effectively. Investors have choices; they can acquire property or publicly traded equity or debt. They can buy mortgages. In place of real estate, they can buy stocks and bonds. Capital markets and financial innovation. The capital markets price real estate risk in relation to other asset classes. Lease valuation is a good example since leasing is a corporate alternative to issuing corporate debt. Encore’s mission is to introduce real estate investors to the richness of the real estate capital markets through prudent transactions and published research. Encore is a financial innovator. Professionals in our research and capital markets teams have trained at leading investment banks and have participated in billions of dollars of complex financial transactions. To us, real estate is a hybrid asset with equity- and debt-like characteristics and a bundle of embedded options. We believe that just about any financial instrument or financial strategy which currently exists can be adapted to real estate. Exhibit 5. The return distribution of Investment B 0.02 0.010 0.000 -30 50 40 30 0.005 20 10 0 -10 -30 0.00 -20 0.01 13.533 12.613 -1.1395 5.4000 50 0.025 Mean - 13.533 0.03 33.8% 40 0.030 Mean Kurtosis Skewness Std Dev 52.9% 30 0.035 13.533 7.500 0.0000 3.0000 13.2% 20.0 Mean - 13.533 0.010 0 0.04 Mean Kurtosis Skewness Std Dev 19.4% 77.0% -10 0.05 3.6% -20 0.06 0.0 20.0 10 0.0 20 Exhibit 4. The return distribution of Investment A Whinvat es em d th rd to e r e nee ega lay ors ulti with r est M inv t : a I n I o rty Wh io wh ors gret. ood llocat prope w est g inv and re d Da sset a s and n sa ars T a CIO ut te on ty REI n to itho utio ons w b i i r i t s con iver equ wa kno d to t bou What ... out . . The M Z D the e of issu n risk, o only hed s is ard rew n not s c, risk ca rati . need to kno w abo of Co ystery l wel to in a % with a 10 Escaping Plato’s Cave: RealTarticles ital markse—tsthat th, oeryidiosync n allocatyio) nreceivinrtfgolios oler .) e ea tel rtic cap ble l po risk serv (separa ationa this a iple, w ate The ematic ersifia le. c t n in Estate is a Poor Inflation Hedge b y de iv syst tain d the ta ropert , both t inter ssets, in prin real es ll ut . . . nfusio of Ca The E tr of anim uscan 1 prie mony, als back an sts passed th im unwas penetrab d forth in a e entrails s le priests hed minions and myste ecret cereThis e for answers . People lo rious to the o a the futu rly, pre-scie to the impo ked to the misch re misled b ntific, attem nderables. ief tha e p lie t to a v ers alread n y entre good, and , created mugur em nched o priesth powered a re “More n ood. say. B incense and more ut wait! Th less sense subjec ”, you e mod might dom th ern ag t to so assum an you mig rcery and re e may be h lack o ed an aura t think. Ca ceived wisp rate f opinio of mys s have unders tery. T ns, de directi tanding, reg spite wides here is no on of c p a ap rate rding the d read misri s. vers a Let’s c nd drive thlear the smo and th e priests fr ke, open th e o row th e spotl m the temp windows, le ight on This is cap ra steps, sue o tes. and ds t ere to a lay d ty ulti- emble varie t, m a ss ite igh h is s, a infin on, s the ti wic filling and in a d sn in d Sa ty of size imag inate Depre od ie us wo a var endo n the d, orig reat ag G u o m A D with a tre to st agwo g the eal. arh wic such ts as The D durin ed m his e t hare ive ”, siz tain onten ach. die uperof f sum e s c lon con Pleas nd. ries of tom , “B new s o s t ie ip a se ers ites. ed fr and ic str day’s d in a b v re tful nd tar com , is to h u te a -s n seco ast thoug s, ide ks — . sio the : u our , n g ris s s is ite urely curio min sificatio eavinv a is iew k Serie V l We in le with r assu l ita d Ris for h dive lent to p s ticle article a r sto hroug quiva r C gwoo e e l this v s dii t a e in his in needves to knowto ab rs Temp le nal e d aso edibl r r se Ou rch fo a se What investorsneed needtotoknow know about What investors about . . .. . . estors n: p Rat Priests augur 2 50 ary; it is wrong. The IDEA Factory: Big ideas for practical investors 5005 LBJ Freeway, Suite 1200 Dallas, TX 75244 Phone: 214-259-7000 Issue No. 5 59-7 14-2 W Wha h e: 2 t in a D n Pho t inv ed toes knowto ab r vest ors ne Inflation hurts real estate performance in over-supplied leasing markets since in-place leases are worth less as nominal interest rates rise with little, if any, offsetting increase in rental growth. Co. r7 e dit When real estate is leveraged with debt, the change in equity value with respect to interest rates will depend on how closely the cash co st o flow payments of the debt match the anticipated lease cash flows. Borrowers, who rely on debt of shorter duration, especially variable f Why rate debt, are betting on interest rates, a dangerous game. is out Phone : s ne ... ed t o kn ow a eN Issu bou Issue No . 3 X 7524 4 214-25 9- t.. . rat ion i n g ca p cred to e q ital and th tory uate s it ration u e c p o d p . So, if real estate is not a good inflation hedge, then why should inves? B form urse ly a e e n s Par mati ation, w may g d dem ginning tors embrace real estate? Should investors care about real estate? an on is here loss s t1 ov d. P tuden in h We say, “Absolutely, and now more than ever!”. Cre dit ra idden. players er critic rofessio ts are ta s T a 00 7000 inant ci ie e gods vilizati by ob sts made sa Times have ch serving the liv crifices to th on on the Ita e go lian an er The au gur was ged; animal s of sacrifice ds and prac peninsula fr avoid ira deor a high prie sacrifice has d animals, th ticed harusp om the 8 th 3 thro st (b icy, lost e patter um Excess ns of lig or the art of ugh the 5 th cap ra , the anger roker) whose its appeal. ce tes ha htning ve varie of the gods (t main role , and th divining the ntury was to he clie w d from e fligh in nt t of bird ill of 127 to terpre s) t the w 493 ba . s. ill of th sis poin e gods ts over (client the lastabout . . . What investors need to know s) and What investors need to know about . . . decade . 2 1 Scylla and Charybdis: Au g u s t 30, 2 010 Navigating a Liquidity Trap R2 500 5 LB JF Dall reewa y as, TX , Suite 752 44 1200 e: 2 14-2 59-7 000 Pho n Issu e No. 1. rn lend er ns ge. R1 A RE R*, op Inte timum rest rate B C the reso emand “rati e rt o ratio to non xceeds ned” in su tere -p n excl ing incl rice ra pply a st ra n udin ti te o ude s lim oning. d banks g un f d it Non mu e in sirab Inte g rest le are the size -price st rate as a D nd b of loan, orro wers . Recession Macroeconomics for Curious Real Estate Investors Greek Mythology is replete with pithy metaphors and exciting stories. The great poet, Homer, wrote about Scylla and Charybdis1, two sea monsters domiciled on opposite sides of the Strait of Messina, between Sicily and the mainland of what is now southern Italy. (See Exhibits 1 and 2.) In close proximity to each other, they posed an inescapable threat to passing sailors; avoiding Charybdis meant passing too closely to Scylla and vice versa. Today, investors must maneuver betwixt and between the Scylla and Charybdis of deflation and inflation. Investors are fearful and anxious. The Fed has recently signaled increased concern regarding possible deflation. The received wisdom is a weak guide; but act they must and inaction is itself a decision. This paper discusses the implications of a spiraling asset price deflation (or liquidity trap) for real estate investors normally accustomed to worrying about inflation. Exhibit 1. Charybdis The IDEA Factory: Big ideas for practical investors S R* S1 SE D S2 July Loan s 5005 LBJ Freeway, Suite 1200 Dallas, TX 75244 Phone: 214-259-7000 25, 201 0 . 0 120 uite y, S ewa 244 J Fre X 75 5 LB allas, T 0 0 500 0 D -7 -259 214 ne: Pho 1 n inys win enn v rwsinian ill the rd T e Dae to . W d Lo th ctionrs ne Alfre coring sele ed t ers flect re o und wars ding Dag woo 1 Issue No. 4 kno w abo ut ... d I: on r Multila y eal Our esta ered th sea seaso te r rch nal isk emes c for edib ontrib u .2 e No le d A D iver tion to wic agwo sion CIO o h tain with d San s sw a v d suc itho and in arie wich of h c a ty o ut t is and ontents treme f fill a mu ears vestor com stoma as to ndous ings, lti-lay and s who ere as c size stu sion ic strip h. T reg n an semb d san he , , is ret. Dag the im d infin led to dtod “Blon ite wo die ay’s atag We new ”, du od, o inatio varie in rigin ty n, ticle vite sup ring s a ig o th e te u rh t, d size e Gre this in leis r astu dm at D in the ure artic te eal. epre le w ly, th read e sith a cu oughtf rs to c ul on riou s, id bites. sume This ea-s Plea this a ta is s rrv e s ed on ri sue of hare fr ie sk, th Zisle n d. e r D C agw a T The ood pital V he iew Risk IDE Serie s launc AF esta Dagwoo B te hes s: a se prac ig idea actory: Real risk ma d Risk S ries s fo e e n tica s r a ta ie pr of fiv te eq geme l inv r nt s add R operty u e ar esto ticle etur ) and ity com tools. resses th rs n p s es in e lam ub co enta rom rrelatio licly tra two fl ble la ck o f rea . o pert a p n te l o stan sitiv (RE te real e the u y retu t e o I , Ts). state whic ver ti ward nadjuste rns are s m (or h e; in chall eriall d, or . Th f e w ac 500 nges e y co a mea 5 LB W rd; the Sharp stati t, they f JF e Ra sured, s rrelated y un c ass lu ith Dall reewa y et all ctuas, alloc out app derestim tio and tandard or smo TX , Suite oca752 ate to ropri devia othed Pho ate r beta r 44 1200 a ne: a s . is te is 214 k me tion is As a k. adju W sets ca o high -259 a r s bias esult sure -700 e sta tegori a perc tment e 0 s d e a e fo re bia dow , ntag stan tistica s. ne to r smoo d ll sed th prop way ard dev y remo dow Issu erty ing, fin ve th iatio eN nbetw o ty a a n . e e n 1 o e s d no ncial and The hydra-headed Scylla (full recourse debt) was rooted to one spot in the ocean, and regularly ate sail- 6 mod the tr n the m f betwe moothin t eno ors (over-leveraged investors) who passed by too closely. Charybdis (asset price deflation) was a single en ea els g ugh ue s tand sured o 9% an and de to oth gaping mouth that sucked in huge quantities of water, and belched them out three times a day, creating d r a r iv rd d er whirlpools (an economic black hole of downward spiraling asset prices). Odysseus (Fed Chairman evia biased s 11%, w e an ad tion h ta ju Bernanke) was forced to choose which monster to confront while passing through the strait; he opted to of eq ndard ich is ab sted pass by Scylla and lose only a few sailors (banks), rather than risk the loss of his entire ship (the economy) de uity o REI viation ut half into the whirlpool. The shipwrecked Odysseus saved himself by clinging to a tree (quantitative easing T of p s. and regulatory accommodation) on the shore until his raft floated to the surface. Jason and the Argorope rnauts (investors with very low leverage) were able to navigate through without incident due to Hera's ate f tio ns avors d n P n mod egative are no ed real els esta : Priv tc ro to S 1 Exhibit 2. Scylla . ut . y a e, av lue pert valu With vestors d va al pro sume ssumed you in on . can optim your as lead ducti ra e n u e o th y ft Intro y. How t se w lo er a s tha belo id, lo und y wil overp state amount not bid pert igh b much. e h ro r p rs e o do you th s cu stantial to u f g r’ o o s e in y y e y sub at if winn valu after pa idder pa The mb ing a idea is th actual u, e nu bidd hest h yo the he of th tails out nts d hig whic . T ence articipa g an erty ty ab ies on u p in q in r n e a ro p np pert the win ons avio cert o c h n ti ro t e c u p c Au s, ire n; b d . o rd your bids for ti o a ty ti e is er w rtain compe in e rs w th c u o n to In sc of eu ner’ ree ey. valu deg mon e win asset the Do in o, of th and rs. gy to nce If s ders erro trate cide id s in b g ed? atic e Th tem rpris vigate ction ir biddin s u u y s a s a ly e of ake prober ated pt th pid n to m ada repe intre rse —the stors idders the u fail to ptimal. inve b ould r’s c bo uses rs? Are How sh e winne a is su c sion erro tional? ing th l. e illu m their ra pita avoid gnitiv fro h ca d be hile fres A co s learn dee ay? fit, w r’ with ets in nd pro verp to o rs rk s e a e to a y v m rs bu cess can idde ice to then ding pro ssful b nd l adv e le. h” a bid ctica in succ amp cras the the e pra phal ex Red y for it m s o n s ithin he firm, pe and ffer le w pocry o T w b a t b e th. y lo ha “bu u r, w w w b e e is ro p y o : m li y ple al” g sistentl is pa ith a so ortfo ctor exam erpetu n In th w rap “p this n co A Fa for id fo hoenix. start f of d of it ca IDE We P ing b moti nix, lan ves The ig ideas estors ximiz amb”) in 1 belie e e leit a o h , h m T : B yP w”) ”, rofit- rties (“L inv mple is sunn claw (“Cla e the p id pe and Exa tical e LC in t. B oth b Pro in to g even venu Claw, L determ prac Lam , red the nin to ent and ature erd -thin rey? ts c n ’ n o th o p a h h e Inn Too it w te “T turn is a they b r, ; e ro h ll w ill n 0) se hig or w dow (185 sell y the . H. al estate redators 010 A. H ed b re ep 0, 2 own oriam life. The estors b ust 1 Wha Mem inv of Au g ning t on's In ature Issu na pec tion he re sha la ug ing al w re the ssump ls often ht that Real estate, public or private, debt or equity, is a potent diversifier othe tive in ti orld p fo s rs d borrow applies if th dep ame in ons, su rget th rices a o no ers to c a multi-asset portfolio. Diversification increases portfolio efficiency. e arts form ch a at in djus borr y offere t, and who ap ircums fr s t a tr om th By efficient, we mean increasing returns without incurring greater this tion an symme oducto o owers in d to pa e reje pear to tances d tr sim btain Thereth cte in y b risk, or, equivalently, reducing risk without sacrificingcre returns. plifie no info ic inloan e pop a highe d appli e identi which dit, rd m e u c r s c ithe thehedge. al s latio ode ants inte at a is a role for real estate in your portfolio, but not as anRinflation ati y r o l. re n nom oning in would. ny intere who, w st rate would me rec (a) amo e n ic R ; (S n evie Markets ee Jo st rate, ith a giv or (b) thot rece ive a lo g proHidd ive an a sep w, 7 eve en s e w re it e a h nd n h 1 up lo a E ,3J tion n info th Im s, 11, 2010 une perfe . Stiglitz ough ply of re iden an eve rm tifi wOctober c n w c 198 he espec ation 1: 3 t Inform and A ith a la redit, a able mea n credit ially wh poses re n rg 9 a d 3-41 ti e re u 0.) on”, Th w We r supply nable are ns. Ba is more en tran critical c n e Am iss, “C of rate ot willi nks cull plentifusaction halleng eric n s an E redit are may s g to pa loan ap l, lend volume es to th The coe in the experi ignal hig y high plicants rs still is low. e analy IDE ra le the nder ju enced, her ris tes, b and re ration lo Even sis of tr Big A Fac dev u tory elop st doe poorly k. Thu t beca ject ma ans throin norm ansacprac idea s cap use : ny, men s no s ugh al tim tica ita , ban n t th t or l inv for Exhib leas feel com lized, o ks reje e willin ot beca non -pri es, it 1 c esto u ing g c risk fortabler possib t applic ness to se the e rs hhigighher tha.nBanks prefe , or ants ly pay y w R*, d er ra it th r no b e pro h the ishon the thos profi te t es ecau p table loans optim to lend e pert incr u y ty roject, t. Som se they ease . Even are so ri m rate at rate pe. the s , si s, R* sk if loca etimes doe the sup y as to nce Exhib Expe tion s no b cted t cha ply of lo e less , R*, it 2. At retu a To d n abo w: cla d n th a rse nd uy a too u to b n i ’s c comes the urge d r e e n R et ? win recoveringemwainrkner’s curse g strategy eenin ly for th The bidd oid th slow n orts. . . vtoeknsowtabou need aesttorsin h t inv tureW Wha . w kno (Zisler Capital Associates, LLC) assistance, while Aeneas (investors who effectively shorted CMBS, FNMA and AIG in 2007) was able to bypass the deadly strait altogether. Who says mythology is not fun and relevant? September 23, 2010 No v emb er 1 6, 2 0 10 Research o a a e ra p , n To r alue o Ts and portfoli ot look l estate ication erefore Tr ’shoeve v if ing ity REI mestic e do n er rea divers ee. Th investo vel. IDyEA F acto le r th f o zation f W f e u o ( r d o rn bid There is no correlation between deficits and inflation. rates, Zisler Capit tuig ry: Eq rsified ation. erty, or ntages n is not % of th granula e reB eas fo ry: NOI, to al or e 10 acto pas ve alloc prop va tio r price. cap rates. Views exp e ad rsifica ss than n to th ly incre ractictiavle A F for % th h i lore 0 t E We ca A cap 2 l inhovesto c ID eas tors on dow Ts w xto e le rate is s the use ll our dive e, a Real estate has traditionally been a back-water, cave located rs What are s id persp REI le we e d that ompris rsified rs can Thea dark anc nager w ne n i v ig f ective the ratio o and misuse to o i e d the sty in h a in ma ent fr thems h c e div inves l somewhere on the periphery of the global capital B markets. fn c , h W to a e i o The N c liz h n n b e e r tiv e ci w a. ctic ew Vie et operating f capitali(Sophisticated players still intone that real estate Treas lves are no d facts an hast folios, eed not frontie her bet t free lu g an ac the effi ng! prisa all local.) w of C in d u t ti t s ap Ra come, rates ries, or exc very volati received w port folio, n fficien or hig the be Findin above od hun tes. s le e is k 0 t . e s h s Now is the time to think of real estate as a hybrid asset with multiple 01 por g the ore ris ation i game return ck. Go growth runk from ss cap rate , the sprea dom? Eve 7, 2 2006 d of c s, can n thou . lon ing m rsific o sum a, or aysta risk dimensions, sensitivity to unexpected inflation and interest rate er 1 A b a th gh va p rough h e h rr em er shocks just being two of these dimensions. 2007, ry substan rates over th cap rates Nov incu reas div t is a z liver alp in the tia 3 the ye e le n ars of lly. Exce e 10 -year Wh ageme ntly de a need ss robus 200 an nsiste ding Two articles of faith still prevail in real estate: (1) Real estate is e1 t m it p u 1 ropert cap 5005 S co fin The Et LBJ F y renta a reliable inflation hedge; and (2) record high deficits naturallyeway, 5244 ru can is like re l BC. Et scans were Fre X 7 Dallas, eway, Suite ruscan beget inflation. This thinking is not just outmoded and5 reactionthe do LBJ llas, T tier, 000 12 m pr T 0 th a es the fu to eed The heights by great men reached and kept were not attained by sudden flight, but they, while their companions slept, were toiling upward in the night. – Henry Wadsworth Longfellow A Vertically Integrated Commercial Real Estate Operating Company 5005 LBJ Freeway, Suite 1200 Dallas, TX 75244 214-259-7000 535 Fifth Avenue, 4th Floor New York, NY 10017 646-362-1628 2 Greenwich Office Park, Suite 300 Greenwich, CT 06831 203-347-0360 To learn more about Encore visit: www.encore.bz All information available or referenced in this corporate brochure and all related products and services (collectively, the “Services”) offered by Encore Enterprises, Inc. or its affiliates (“Encore”) are intended to provide general information about Encore only and are not intended as, and should not be taken as, financial, investment, legal or any other type of advice. You should review any planned financial transactions or arrangements that may have tax, accounting or legal implications with your tax and legal professionals. There are important differences in the Services provided by Encore, including the type of assistance provided, the fees charged and the rights and obligations of the parties. It is important to understand these differences, particularly when determining whether to select a Service. While Encore makes commercially reasonable efforts to present accurate and reliable information herein, Encore does not endorse, approve or certify such information, nor does it guarantee the accuracy, completeness, efficacy, timeliness or correct sequencing of such information. Such information may not be current and Encore has no duty to update and maintain such information or any statements about the Services, which may change periodically without prior notice. Some or all alternative investments may not be suitable for certain investors. Certain alternative investments carry significant risk and are not subject to the same regulatory oversight as mutual funds and other traditional investments. For these reasons, access to alternative investments may be limited to investors who are designated as sophisticated, high-net-worth investors. Investments in foreign securities involve special risks, including foreign currency risk and the possibility of substantial volatility due to adverse political, economic or other developments. These risks are magnified for investments made in emerging markets. All content provided herein is provided “as is”, without warranty of any kind. Use of the information provided herein is voluntary, and reliance on it should only be undertaken after an independent review of its accuracy, completeness, accuracy, timeliness and any other factors important to you. This brochure is not intended to, and does not, make any recommendations regarding particular financial instruments, investments or products. The use of any Services offered by Encore should be based entirely on your and your advisers’ own due diligence and should not be based, in whole or in part, on the information provided in this brochure. © 2013 Encore Enterprises, Inc.
© Copyright 2024