Conventional vs Insurgent War

PS114. International Security in a Changing World1
Introduction to Asymmetric Warfare
1
Regular vs Irregular Wars
Comparison of Interstate War with Insurgent Wars
Regular Wars
Irregular Wars
AKA:
interstate war, conventional war
Participants:
Motivation for War:
State Actor vs State Actor
Territory, policy change,
change, status quo
Goal:
War of ...
Relative Power between Participants:
Overall Strategy:
Military, economic, or political change
Blitzkrieg
Symmetric
regime
Tactics:
Direct: orchestrate military o↵ensives
to eliminate the enemy
Military battles, coercion, fire power,
troops, tactics to eliminate the enemy,
convince civilians to resist
Casualties:
How is War Changing
in the 21st Century?
High
Drones, WMDs, field medicine, mechanization
Outcome:
Stronger power wins
Examples:
World War I, World War II, Gulf War,
War in Iraq (early)
insurgency, asymmetric conflict, civil
war, guerrilla warfare, intrastate war,
extrastate war, revolution*
State Actor vs Non-State Actor
Ideology, religious extremism, ethnic
separatism, colonialism, culture, regime
change, possibly territory
Political change
Attrition
Asymmetric
Indirect: undermine the incumbent or
insurgency’s will to fight
guerrilla tactics, terror, propaganda,
convince civilians to collaborate with
insurgency, use local knowledge, fight
on own turf
Low to Moderate
Internet, cell phones, “twi-plomacy,”
new techniques to finance insurgency
(oil, minerals)
Stronger power or weaker power wins
conditional on other factors
Vietnam War, War in Iraq (late), Tuareg Rebellion in Mali, ISIL
Reference Definitions:
• State: Members of the international system who are able to exert the independence, possess territory,
and have a central government (COW)
• Non-State Actor: An organization, group, or collection who live within the borders of another state,
but are not integrated into the metropole, e.g. insurgency, guerrillas, terrorists (COW)
• Insurgency: An organization fighting for political change whose movement is marked by the support
and mobilization of a significant proportion of the population both domestically and external (Kiras)
1
2015. Iris Malone. Please do not cite or share without author’s permission
1