Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. Semester*: One Unit Code*: ETP425 Unit Name*: Teaching and Learning 3 (Assessment and Reporting) Assignment Title*: Assignment 1 Date Due*: 26 April 2013 Submission Date*: 25 April 2013 Lecturer’s Name*: Dr. Robyn Gregson Student’s Full Name*: Jo-Anne Lee Bailey Student No*: s251212 Student’s Email: * [email protected] Student’s Phone No: 0249508799 I declare that all material in this assessment is my own work except where there is a clear acknowledgement and reference to the work of others. I have read the University’s Academic and Scientific Misconduct Policy and understand its implications.* http://www.cdu.edu.au/governance/documents/3.3academicandscientificmisconduct.pdf I agree I do not agree Double click on the square check box to mark as checked. CHECKLIST* Task Checked 1 I have completed the form above*: 2 My CDU email address is activated*. 3 I have read and understood the important information on this form*. 4 I have kept a copy of my assignment*. 5 I have acknowledged and referenced the work of others* 6 I have filled in the footer page and identified my file correctly* 7 I have saved the assignment in a compatible format e.g. .Microsoft word doc or txt* 8 My assignment file size does not exceed 2MB* 9 I have reread and checked all the assessment requirements.* Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 1 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. Preface I have assessed and provided feedback on the Year 11 Historical Diary because I hope to teach both secondary HSIE and English in New South Wales. The text on which the sample is based, Rabbit Proof Fence, has crosscurricular application. My assignment is comprised of three sections. Part A analyses and evaluates the sample against NAPLAN, ACARA and the NSW Board of Studies syllabus for Stage 6 English as a Second Language. Part A also outlines the student's strengths and nominates recommended areas of, and strategies for, improvement, as requested in the marking rubric for the assignment. Part B reflects on my learning journey within ETP425 to date, with a summary of key learnings accompanying two questions to further my understanding of issues relating to assessment in the 21st century. Part C contains Appendices which expand on the ideas presented within Part A. The Appendices include detailed teacher's marking notes and analyses of the work sample based on NAPLAN, ACARA and Syllabus marking criterion. Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 2 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. Part A 1. ASSESSMENT OF WORK SAMPLE Strengths Under NAPLAN Under ACARA National Under NSW ESL Syllabus (Year 11) Curriculum for the course Senior English as an Additional Language or Dialect (Unit 3) Intended audience is clear Student has selected and sustained the register and Student has clearly tone for an historical diary portrayed the writer's entry (ACEEA060) sentiments Evidence of emerging Characterisation is understanding of cultural developing. beliefs and assumptions (“...that lying man.”) Spelling is generally (ACEEA064) sound. However, the author uses mostly simple Student uses language words. that influences the audience or that privileges certain ideas or perspectives over others “...that lying man', “I admire you”, “a good hunter” and “You took good care of me and Daisy”: (ACEEA076) ESL Year 11 Syllabus Outcome 3: demonstrate understanding of cultural reference in texts - has clearly identified and used direct cultural references, plus a range of culturally based values and perspectives in texts .“...bush tucker”,”..that lying man” and “a good hunter” Areas for improvement Under NAPLAN Under ACARA National Under NSW ESL Curriculum for the Syllabus (Year 11) course Senior English as an Additional Language or Dialect (Unit 3) Vocabulary is relatively simple. As we can only make assumptions as to what the assessment task actually called for, we should bear in mind that perhaps this was the author's intention; the use of only simple words to create a more 'authentic' voice for Gracie. Use of literary techniques (ACEEA069) ESL Year 11 Syllabus Outcome 4: develop language relevant to study of English – Sentence structure revision required on (ACEEA077) language used to make connections and the Planning, synthesising, conventions of language rehearsing, editing and refining, including spelling, ESL Year 11 Syllabus punctuation and grammar Outcome 5: demonstrate understanding of how (ACEEA081) Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 3 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. audience and purpose affect the language and structure of texts – more work required to improve structure, composition and manipulation of texts ESL Year 11 Syllabus Outcome 8: use variety of textual forms – student could benefit from a focus on how to structure texts to shape meaning ESL Year 11 Syllabus Outcome 13: student reflects on own processes for responding and composing – focus on style editing could be beneficial While the sample follows a narrative structure, the paragraphing is simplistic and it would benefit from the use of more cohesive devices. Sentence structure and punctuation need work. Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 4 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. 2. REMEDIATION PLAN (based on the ACARA National Curriculum Senior English as an Additional Language or Dialect course (Unit 3) Relevant learning outcomes which require remediation* Indicators (from table above) Suggested Strategies 1. Use communication skills to evaluate how texts present ideas and opinions 2. Understand the relationships between information, ideas, language and values in texts 3. Investigate and compare personal, social and cultural attitudes and perspectives in a range of texts from different contexts Use of literary techniques, e.g. figurative language, require development (ACEEA069) Incorporate some lessons on how figurative language can be used to create meaning, convey attitudes and create mood, especially in texts like historical diary writing. The class could construct a class display on which they pin self-penned examples of different devices, e.g. similes, metaphors, alliteration etc. Focus required on how different sentence structures and forms can be suited to various purposes, audiences and subjects (ACEEA077) This student requires help with past/present tense, cohesion and paragraphing. Some personal autobiographical work might help to the learners to practice these concepts, e.g. they each have to write their own life story, but also include what they will do, as well as what they have done. Revision required on strategies for planning, synthesising, rehearsing, editing and refining, including spelling, punctuation and grammar (ACEEA081) Some simple in-class worksheets (students could perhaps work in groups) featuring punctuation and capitalisation drills for revision. 4. Plan, create and refine extended oral, written and multimodal texts appropriate to different contexts, purposes and audiences * Presumably, this task would form only part of a unit of work. Therefore, it's possible that not all the unit's learning outcomes could reasonably be assessed through just this one task. This is, at its heart, an interpretation and writing task, so I've identified the fourth of the four outcomes as being the most relevant. Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 5 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. 3. DISCUSSION I believe the student has made a reasonable effort to produce a narrative. It appears that the student has understood the requirements of the task (i.e. to produce an historical diary entry) and has positioned the narrative appropriately. The piece of writing accurately portrays the girls' separation and expresses Gracie's feelings towards the event and towards her friend, Molly. The assessment against the NAPLAN Narrative Marking Guide, the APARA Curriculum for English as an Additional Language and the NSW English as a Second Language Syllabus revealed some common strengths and areas for improvement. While his/her spelling is generally sound, this student could benefit from revision of punctuation and paragraphing. In addition, I'd recommend some work for the class on the use of figurative language, past/present/future tense and cohesive devices to help refine their writing. It's worth reiterating that I don't really know the context in which this assessment task was set. However, my research has indicated that it's likely the task was drawn from an Australian ESL syllabus or curriculum. This means that the student who produced the work is probably not a native English speaker. Factors which can affect some ESL learners' acquisition of Standard Australian English (SAE) may include little or disrupted schooling, the attendance of multiple schools and their experience of traumatic life events. The acquisition of a second language can take many years and is often described in terms of Cummins’ construct of two types of proficiency. The first, ‘Basic Interpersonal Communicative Skills’ (BICS), is the language proficiency used for social everyday communication and is often highly contextualised, used for real life events, sharing personal information and for achieving routine social functions (Education Queensland, 2013). While most second language learners who are immersed in an SAE-speaking context will be proficient in BICS after approximately two years of learning and exposure to the target language, students who are not, or have no bilingual or ESL support, may take relatively longer to acquire proficiency. Significantly for us as teachers, BICS proficiency does not necessarily translate into the proficiency in the academic and more abstract language of Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 6 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. school learning. Cummins' second construct, Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency (CALP), is required for academic tasks which require a greater degree of cognitive engagement and are accompanied by less contextual support. These tasks require distinct technical vocabularies and are more grammatically complex. The acquisition of academic English can take up to seven years, or more for those with interrupted or no schooling in their first language (Collier, 1995). The remediation strategies for this student have been developed with this (assumed) learning profile in mind. Assuming the student does come from a non-English speaking background and is in the process of learning, and refining, their SAE skills, the student will require extra scaffolding and support to assist them to get meaning from classroom learning while their SAE is still developing. I would recommend future lessons incorporate some learning about how figurative language is used in SAE to create meaning, convey attitudes and create mood. For kinaesthetic appeal, the class could construct a class display on which they pin self-penned examples of different devices, e.g. similes, metaphors, alliteration etc. I'd also suggest some revision of past/present tense, cohesion and paragraphing and a spiral approach to curriculum (Bruner, 1960) could prove useful in this classroom. This methodology sees basic knowledge and concepts revisited repeatedly as new material is introduced. This will allow the student's learning to develop in a spiral fashion as earlier knowledge and concepts are recircled and enriched. Similarly, Education Queensland's 'Break it down, build it up' approach, which provides a framework for working with ESL learners in a whole-class context may also have merit in this case. Some personal autobiographical work might help to the learners to practice the concepts of tenses, e.g. they each have to write their own life story, but also include what they will do, as well as what they have done. Some simple in-class worksheets (students could perhaps work in groups) featuring punctuation and capitalisation drills for revision. Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 7 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. Part B a. Key themes The process of assessment is three-fold. Firstly, it involves the collection of evidence relating to an attribute to be tested. In this case, we are testing the student's ability to write a narrative based around the film, Rabbit Proof Fence. The evidence is the historical diary entry which has been drafted by the student. Secondly, it calls for the evaluation of the evidence. We may draw on a number of sources on which to base our analysis of the evidence. In this example, I drew from NAPLAN, ACARA and the NSW English (ESL) syllabus. Thirdly, whichever judgement we make about the student's work will be shaped by our intentions and purposes – i.e. what we need to teach according to the syllabus. In other words, assessment does not, and cannot, take place in isolation of other teaching functions. It plays a central role in the learning process, where we want to determine how the student is performing and use this knowledge to plan other experiences to build on their ability and results. To allow performance to be improved, the results of assessments are reported to the students themselves, their parents and to other teachers. The results are also used to inform external stakeholders. The type of assessment will vary according to its purpose (Brady & Kennedy, 2009, p. 16). Assessment can be formative or summative, and it may call for a written response (multiple choice, writing task, short-answer), an oral response (presentation, debate, role-play, demonstration) or it may test understanding by asking the students to draw from multi-modal sources (digital media). While each approach has its advantages and disadvantages, I'm a strong advocate of Hattie's assertion that “the simplest prescription for improving education must be “dollops of feedbackO.providing information about what a student does and does not understand, and what direction the student must take to improve.” (Hattie 1999). I have, even in this hypothetical example, taken a great deal of care to provide constructive feedback (see Appendices) which would hopefully support the student on the continuation of their learning journey. Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 8 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. b. Questions to ask mentor teacher (HSIE) 1. From your experience, how do students in Years 7 and 9 currently prepare for, and feel about, the NAPLAN examination? NAPLAN commenced in 2008, so, for the Year 7 students, I guess they've never known any different. When I went to school, our first formal examination was the Year 10 School Certificate, so the thought of being formally tested every two years is, for an anxious student like me, quite daunting. Relevant teaching/learning areas: pedagogy, child development, assessment, literacies). 2. How many opportunities do today's teachers get to work one-on-one with students who are struggling in a particular area? For example, in the Historical Diary case detailed above, the student could probably benefit from some oneon-one time with the teacher to practice important skills which brought their mark down, e.g. their punctuation and paragraphing, and the cohesive devices. Would that be an idealistic expectation in your classroom, or would remediation be restricted to group/class activities? Relevant teaching/learning areas: assessment, teaching strategies, classroom management, ESL). Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 9 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. References ACARA (2013) Senior English as an Additional language or Dialect Curriculum. Retrieved in April 2013 from http://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/SeniorSecondary/English/English-asan-Additional-Language-or-Dialect/Curriculum/SeniorSecondary Brady, L. and Kennedy, K.J. (2005) Celebrating student achievement: assessment and reporting. Frenchs Forest: Pearson Education Australia Bruner, Jerome (1960) The Process of Education, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Harvard University Press Collier,V.P. 1995. Acquiring a Second Language for School: Directions in Language and Education. National Clearing House for Bilingual Education, 1(4). Cummins, J. (1984) Bilingualism in special education: issues in assessment and pedagogy. Clevedom, Multilingual Matters. Education Queensland (2013). ESL in the Classroom. Retrieved in April 2013 from https://www.learningplace.com.au/deliver/content.asp?pid=48625 Hattie, J. (1999).Influences on Student Learning: inaugural Lecture: Professor of Education, University of Auckland. Retrieved in April 2013 from www.education.auckland.ac.nz/uoa/fms/default/education/staff/ Prof.%20John %20Hattie/Documents/Presentations/influences/Influences_on_student_learning.pdf) NAPLAN (2010) Narrative Marking Guide. Retrieved in April 2013 from http://www.nap.edu.au/verve/_resources/2010_Marking_Guide.pdf#search=n arrative marking NSW Board of Studies (2009) HSC English: English as a Second Language Syllabus. Retrieved in April 2013 from http://www.boardofstudies.nsw.edu.au/syllabus_hsc/english-esl.html Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 10 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. Appendices 1. Evaluation of work sample against ACARA Narrative Marking Guide, 2010 Criterion Score Annotations 1. Audience 4 out of 6 Supports reader understanding and attempts to engage the reader. “I admire you Molly” and “..you took good care of me and Daisy.” Language choices control the reader/writer relationship “I remember you me and Daisy used to go hunting...”, reveal the writer's values and attitudes “I'm very sorry” and “I should've not listened to that lying man”. 2. Text structure 3 out of 4 Contains an orientation “I haven't heard from or contact you.”, a complication “I remember when we ran away from Moore River” and a resolution “I'm very sorry”, “I should've not listened to that lying man” and “But my life is ok”. 3. Ideas 3 out of 5 Ideas show some development or elaboration and relate coherently to a central storyline. Some ideas contain unnecessary elaboration (repetition of Gracie's belief that Molly was a good hunter) 4. Character/setting 3 out of 4 Characterisation is emerging through description and the attribution of thoughts and feelings to a character. We learn that Gracie has a lot of respect for Molly because her friend was clever and took care of her and Daisy. 5. Vocabulary 2 out of 5 Uses mostly simple verbs, adverbs, adjectives and nouns. Good use of attitudinal word “that lying man”. 6. Cohesion 2 out of 4 Some correct links between sentences, but reader has to occasionally re-read or deduce their own links to clarify meaning. Uses small selection of simple connectives and conjunctions “but”, “now”. 7. Paragraphing 1 out of 2 Writing is organised into paragraphs that are mainly focussed on a single idea or set of ideas. Writer has used three paragraphs to mark formulaic narrative structure (start, middle, end). 8. Sentence structure 2 out of 6 Most simple sentences are correct. The meaning is predominantly clear. 9. Punctuation 3 out of 5 Some correct punctuation across categories. 10. Spelling 4 out of 6 Correct spelling of simple words and most common words. Mark 27 out of 47 (57%) Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 11 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. 2. Evaluation of work sample against NSW Board of Studies Stage 6 Syllabus English (ESL) Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 12 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. 3. Analysis of work sample against indicators cited in the ACARA National Curriculum for the course Senior English as an Additional Language or Dialect Most applicable unit of work (assumption, as we don't know the task/context in which it was set) Unit 3 • • • ACARA Learning Objectives By the end of this unit, students will: •use communication skills to evaluate how Analyses how language choices are used to achieve texts present ideas and opinions different purposes and effects in a range of contexts. •understand the relationships between Develops SAE language skills so they can be used to information, ideas, language and values in describe, inform, express a point of view and texts persuade for different purposes and audiences. •investigate and compare personal, social Explores how language choices shape meaning and and cultural attitudes and perspectives in a influence audiences by creating a range of oral, range of texts from different contexts written and multimodal texts. •plan, create and refine extended oral, Analyses and evaluates how the representation of written and multimodal texts appropriate to ideas, attitudes and values and how these vary different contexts, purposes and audiences across cultures and within different contexts (especially the Australian context). Relevant content • Evidence • Selects and sustains register and tone to suit different purposes, contexts and audiences (ACEEA060) Student has used appropriate register and tone for historical diary entry • Explains cultural beliefs and assumptions reflected in texts (ACEEA064) Emerging understanding of cultural beliefs and assumptions ('That lying man'.) • Uses language that influences the audience or that privileges certain ideas or perspectives over others (ACEEA076) 'That lying man' “I admire you” “A good hunter” “You took good care of me and Daisy” GRADE ALLOCATED UNDER ACARA: D Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 13 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. 4. Teacher's feedback to student [Name of student], you have demonstrated that you have thought about who your audience is, and how Gracie would feel as she's writing her piece. You do a good job of relating what happened when the girls were taken away and at getting across the idea that Gracie feels sorry about leaving Molly and Daisy. The reader also gets a real sense of the admiration and affection Gracie has towards Molly, so the work you have done to build on her characterisation is working well. While your spelling is quite sound and your ideas are clearly expressed, your work could be improved through the better use of punctuation and paragraphs. I also have some ideas for you on how you can use some devices (called connections and conjunctions) to improve the 'flow' of your ideas. You've already used some examples (but and now), but other examples which would work well in a diary entry are words like then and so. This is something we will look at in class through some more writing exercises in the next few weeks. We will also be doing some work, as a class, to see how we can create mood in texts which are written from a personal point of view (like diary entries). Overall, you've made a good effort. Well done. Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 14 Assignment template All areas of this form marked with * are essential information and must be completed. 5. Teacher's marking notes Geraldton, 25/5/80 Dear Molly, Hello,i I haven’t heard from,ii or contactediii youiv. How are things going back at Jigalong?v vi I remember you, Daisy and I viiused to go hunting with all the family,viii and Iix remember that we had to hide from the policeman. I admiredx you,xi Molly, xii because you were a good hunter and you took good care of Daisy and I.xiii I still remember the day that our family was crying for us when we were taken away. I still remember xiv things about Moore Rxviver. We had to speak English all time. The food was very disgusting.xvi Wxviie had do our jobs every morning before breakfast,xviii and we had use a bucket forxix toilet. I remember when we ran away from Moore River the tracker, Mr. Dxxevil and the police couldn’t catch us -xxi you were smarter than the tracker. I still remember that you were a good hunterxxii and were xxiii very good at catching bush tucker;xxiv like when you caught that goanna off the tree. YxxvYou were xxvi very clever xxvii. How is Daisy? How old is she now? Is she okay? xxviii Txxixell her that I really miss her. I’m very sorry that I left you and Daisy alone at Meekatharra when the police recaptured me.xxx I should not havexxxi listened to that lying man. I feel kind of bored without you and Daisy and all the other family back xxxiiat Jigalong, andxxxiii I feel very sad about it. But my life is okay.xxxiv I havexxxv six children. Myxxxvi husband's name is Harry Cross.xxxvii He is a young station-hand man. I work as a domestic help on xxxviii various farms in the wheat belt and I am now I working in Shark Bay District, which isxxxixwhere I first met Harry. xl What about you and Daisy? Have eitherxli of you got any children yet? What sort of work are you two doing? I miss you two so much. I wish I was back there at Jigalong.xlii From Gracie Field Double click here to fill in this footer Bailey__Jo-Anne_ETP425_ Semester 1_Assignment number 1. 15 i ii iii iv A comma after 'Hello' is required for this greeting to make sense. Suggest including a comma to make this sentence 'flow' a little better. 'Contact' should be 'Contacted' instead. It would be good if you could add some 'time' context here, to really 'set the scene'. For example, how long has it been since 'Gracie' heard from Molly? A time-frame of 50 years might be appropriate since the story/film is set in 1931. This would place Gracie's letter as being written two years before she died. v This is a new idea/topic, so you should start a new paragraph here. vi Again, you are introducing a new topic, so it's best to use this sentence as the start of a new paragraph. vii Standard Australia English (SAE) requires “you … and I” viii A comma is required here. ix This sentence would work better with the insertion of a second 'I'. x Because you are writing about something that happened in the past, you should add a 'd' to 'admire'. xi A comma here would make your text sound more conversational and more in-keeping with common speech patterns. This is something you could expect to see in diary writing. xii As per (xi) above.. xiii Correct SAE requires “... and I” xiv The word 'the' probably isn't necessary here. xv Moore River is the name of a place, so the first 'r' in River needs to be capitalised. You've written it correctly later in your diary entry – well done. xvi It would be good to use a full stop here to break this sentence up. xviiNew sentence. xviii A comma would work well here to separate the two ideas in this sentence. xix Thinking about the context in which 'Gracie' is writing, the use of the word 'for' is probably okay, but it would be more correct to use 'as our' instead. xx Correct grammar would require a full-stop after the title 'Mr' and a capital D for 'Devil'. xxi It would be good to add a hyphen in here to add extra emphasis on the idea that you remember Molly being smart. xxiiRepetition – “Gracie” has already mentioned that she thought Molly was a good hunter. xxiiiThe addition of the word 'were' would help this sentence to 'flow' better. xxivYou could add a colon (:) here to provide further explanation of your bush tucker idea xxv I think giving this section its own sentence would be give this idea more impact. xxviRemembering that this is talking about things which happened a long time ago, it would be better to use the past tense – 'You were' rather than the present tense – 'You're'. xxviiThis may not be necessary. xxviiiCorrect spelling – 'okay' rather than the abbreviated 'ok'. xxixNew sentence xxxThis sentence is a bit long. Break it up with a full-stop. xxxiWhile I understand the meaning you are trying to convey, you've confused your contraction – the word you're trying to shorten using an apostrophe. Instead of saying “I should've (should have) not”, correct SAE uses 'I shouldn’t (should not) have...” xxxiiInserting the word 'back' here would help any reader who wasn't familiar with her story to recognise that Gracie is no longer at Jigalong, but her friends (including +Molly) are. xxxiiiSome punctuation (a comma) would break this long sentence up and make it easier to read. xxxivAs before, you should use the correct spelling, 'okay'. xxxvCorrect grammar is 'have', rather than 'got'. xxxviThis sentence is quite long. It would be good to use a full-stop here to separate your ideas. xxxviiSome improvements to punctuation and grammar (apostrophe, swapping of words) would help this sentence to read better. xxxviiiYou're talking about 'Gracie' doing work on more than one farm (she says 'various farms'), so you should remove the 'a' from here because it implies she's only working on one. xxxixBe careful about your use of tense. I have made some corrections which would better explain what Gracie is doing now. xl With this section, 'Gracie' is going back to asking about someone else, rather than talking about herself. Because it's a new idea, it would read best as a new paragraph. xli When you use the word 'any', it implies that you're talking about several, or a lot, of people. However, if you replaced it with the word 'either' it better implies that you're asking after only two – Molly and Daisy. xlii The ideas here are all very different, so they should be written as separate sentences. In addition, keeping each those last two sentences short is a good way of adding impact – the tone helps the reader to get a powerful impression of how 'Gracie' is feeling; she is feeling lost, alone and she misses her friends and life.
© Copyright 2024