Building the Evidence Base for Male Involvement in Malawi

Building the Evidence Base for
Male Involvement in Malawi
Targeting Men in Cross-Generational Relationships:
Results from the Malawi Male Motivator Study
October 4, 2011: Interagency Gender Working Group
Brad Kerner, Adolescent Reproductive Health, Sr. Specialist
Increasing Family Planning Utilization by Youth
Access
Quality
Community
Based
Distribution
by Youth
Improved
Supervision
Expanding
LAM use
through
TBAs
Family
Planning
Logistics
Workshops
Demand
Enabling
Environment
Teen Mother
Clubs
Initiation
Counselors
Male
Motivators
National FP
meetings
Male Motivator Operations Research Design
40 Male
motivators
trained
Randomized
Controlled
Trial with
400 couples
Pre/Post
quantitative
assessment
Qualitative
interviews
14 ♂
30 ♀
The Intervention
Visit 1
• INFORMATION: Socio Economic benefits
of birth spacing, Family Planning 101
Visit 2
• MOTIVATION: Norms and perceptions of
men who use family planning; disclosure
of educators own experiences
Visits
3, 4 & 5
• BEHAVIOR CHANGE: Skills development
and role plays to encourage couples
communication
5 visits over 8 months
Quantitative Results
Outcome Measurement 1:
Increased uptake of modern family planning methods
100
80
60
Treatment
40
Control
• Both arms increased
significantly (p < .01)
20
0
Baseline
Post
Increase in Treatment arm
significantly greater
than Control (p < .01)
Quantitative Results
Outcome Measurement 2:
Increased Family Planning Knowledge
58
56
54
Treatment
52
Control
50
48
Baseline
Post
Values represent the average percentage correct for each group.
• Both groups showed
significant increases
in their family
planning knowledge
(p < .05)
• No statistical
differences in group
scores over time
Outcome 3 :
Improved Attitudes toward Family Planning & Gender Equity
Outcome 4:
Improved Family Planning self-efficacy
4.5
• FP self-efficacy scale,
Gender Equitable Male
scale, FP attitudes scale.
4.25
• Both groups showed
significant increases in
each of the variables
(p < .05)
4
3.75
Baseline
Post
Strongly Disagree (1) – Strongly Agree (5) Likert Scale
• No statistical differences
in group scores over time
Quantitative Results
Outcome 5a:
General Communication about family planning
4.5
•
Treat CG
4.25
Cont CG
Communication General Scale
– Assesses whether participants’
discussed family planning with wives,
extended family, friends
•
•
Both groups significantly increased
scores on variable (p < .01)
No statistical differences between
groups at baseline or post intervention
4
Baseline
Post
5 point Likert-scale
Strongly Disagree
EASE OF COMMUNICATION WITH WIFE
was found moderately significant
(OR =1.57, p=.08)
“ It is easy to discuss family planning with your
wife?”
Quantitative Results
Outcome 5b:
Communication Frequency about family planning
•
Communication Frequency Scale
– Assesses how often participants’
discussed family planning with wives,
extended family, friends
•
3
2.75
Treat CF
Both groups significantly increased
scores on variable (p < .01)
2.5
Cont CF
2.25
2
Significant change over time was
identified between the two groups with
communication with wives (p < .05)
“How often do you discuss family planning
with your wife?”
Baseline
Post
Qualitative Results
Pathways to FP Use
Improved Ease in Communication
Results: Qualitative
Qualitative Results
Pathways to FP Use
Improved Frequency of Communication
Wife states…
“We never discussed matters, but since his
participation in the study we talk about sex,
family planning, and how to enjoy
marriage.”
Qualitative Results
Communication Patterns
Theme
# of
male
(n=14)
# of
female
(n=30)
Man initiates conversation
10
18
Man communicates support of
FP
2
15
Woman initiates conversation
2
9
Woman previously initiated
conversation
0
9
“There has been an
improvement in
the way we
discuss FP issues
because I have
been telling my
husband about
FP but he never
believed me
until the coming
of the Male
Motivator.”
Qualitative Results
Family Planning Decision Making
Decision to use Family Planning
Joint
Decision
MaleDominated
Female
Dominated
# of male
7
8
0
# of female
9
18
4
“I have seen my husband consulting me in some
issues, a thing I think he has learned from the
study initiative. This attitude gives me the
impression that I am considered worthy and
trustworthy friend in the family”
Thank you!
Changes in Couples’ Communication as a Result of a Male Involvement
Family Planning Intervention; Miriam Hartmann, Kate Gilles, Dominick
Shattuck, Brad Kerner, Greg Guest, Journal of Health Communication,
accepted Feb 2011 (Forthcoming)
Motivating Men to Communicate about Family Planning and its Effect on
Contraceptive Uptake: The Malawi Male Motivator Project, Dominick
Shattuck; Brad Kerner; Katherine Gilles; Miriam Hartmann; Thokozani
Ng'ombe; Greg Guest; American Journal of Public Health April14th, 2011