AA-Postscript 2.qxp:Layout 1

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 18, 2014
I N T E R N AT I O N A L
Murder for ‘honor’
Bloody tide sweeping Pakistan
SYDNEY: Prime Minster of India Narendra Modi acknowledges thousands of supporters at the Allphones Arena Olympic park in Sydney yesterday. Thousands of
Indian community members gathered at the arena to listen to Modi who is in
Sydney after attending the G20 Summit in Brisbane over the weekend. —AFP
Fans dub India’s Modi
‘rock star’ in Australia
SYDNEY: Thousands of rapturous supporters yesterday flocked to hear a public address by
Narendra Modi on the first visit by an Indian prime
minister to Australia in 28 years, many declaring
their love for him. Modi, who won India’s biggest
electoral victory in three decades in the April-May
polls, was greeted like a pop star on a trip to New
York in September and received a similar reception
in Sydney, which he is visiting after attending the
G20 summit in Brisbane.
“Modi’s a rock star!” screamed one supporter as
the Indian premier took the stage to a wildly
enthusiastic reception. “This love, this welcome... I
give this to the feet of the children of mother
India,” Modi said, observing that many people
were still outside, unable to gain access to the
packed venue. Modi drew cheers from the crowd
when he referenced the two nations’ shared passion, saying neither “Australia nor India can live
without cricket”. His speech also covered topics
such as Hindu nationalism and Indian independence. “He is our most charismatic leader and he is
going to take our country to the next generation,”
Sushil Chaddha, an IT consultant who has lived in
Australia for three decades, told AFP in stifling heat
outside Sydney’s Olympic Park.
‘We all love him’
Beside Chaddha stood dozens of people wearing “Modi in Australia” T-shirts printed with the
Indian leader’s face in the style of Barack Obama’s
“Yes We Can” 2008 election posters. Others chanted “Modi, Modi, Modi!” as they jumped, sang and
danced, with drums and music playing in the
background. Some 20,000 people, mostly from
the Indian diaspora in Australia, jammed the stadium, although some had travelled from as far as the
United States, Singapore and New Zealand.
Reports said there were 25 television crews from
India at the event. Scores of supporters arrived on
a train decked out in the country’s national colors.
Modi Express hits Sydney
The so-called “Modi Express” saw more than
200 supporters board a train from Melbourne for
the 12-hour journey to Sydney, singing and dancing in the carriages ahead of the event. “After a
long, long time, such a phenomenon, such an
excitement, such a wave has come, which is unparalleled,” one of Modi’s supporters on the train,
Rakesh Raizada, told the Australian Broadcasting
Corporation. “This is a new revolution, you can call
it.” There are around 450,000 people of Indian origin in Australia, including many from the student
community, and Australian Prime Minister Tony
Abbott will be rolling out the red carpet for Modi
in Canberra today.
His trip Down Under-for the G20 summit in
Brisbane and a state visit-comes just two months
after Abbott’s tour of India, during which the two
countries sealed a long-awaited nuclear energy
deal. Relations between India and Australia have
been rocky in recent years with tensions flaring
over allegedly racist attacks on Indian students in
Melbourne, and two-way trade has done nothing
but slide. But the Abbott government sensed an
opportunity when the pro-business Modi won
the Indian elections in a landslide in May, and is
keen to reignite Australian investment in India.
India’s foreign ministry described Modi’s visit
as part of efforts to “re-engage” Australia and its
businesses, and he will address parliament in
Canberra today. The Indian leader is also set to
meet industry leaders and sign several agreements on narcotics control, social security,
tourism and cultural cooperation. While Modi was
largely feted, not everyone at the stadium was
there to welcome him, with about 100 Sikh protesters lining a street beside the entrance. “The
main message is unity,” Karandeep Singh Chadha
said. “PM Modi and his associates are involved in
pro-Hindu movements that are trying to squash
minorities.” —AFP
Long-troubled
Afghanistan govt
undergoes overhaul
KABUL: Afghan President Ashraf Ghani has missed his
own deadline for naming a Cabinet as he undertakes a
major overhaul of his country’s government, which officials and analysts say has long suffered from a focus on
patronage rather than policy. The delay has raised concerns that Ghani and his former rival Abdullah Abdullah now in the prime minister-like post of chief executive cannot agree on who should take what Cabinet post.
But diplomats and officials say the two leaders are
restructuring the administration to focus on security, the
economy and social policy ahead of a vital donor conference in December. “There is no deadlock or difference of
opinion,” said Mujib Rahman Rahimi, Abdullah’s spokesman.
It takes time “to consider how to fill these positions in order
to have a functioning, professional Cabinet.”
Senior advisers are being appointed, regulatory
authorities set up, ministers’ duties defined, and some of
the 24 ministries merged to possibly as few as 18, officials and analysts said. Only when these tasks are complete can “the right people with the right skills be
appointed to the right jobs,” said another official close to
Abdullah, who spoke on condition of anonymity to speak
frankly about internal discussions. Ghani became president in September, promising to reverse the legacy of
corruption and nepotism of his predecessor Hamid
Karzai’s 13 years in office.
He inherited an anemic economy, endemic corruption, a lack of public trust in government and a still-virulent Taleban insurgency as US and NATO combat troops
prepare to withdraw at the end of the year. Ghani said he
would appoint his Cabinet within 45 days, but that deadline passed Thursday. He has met with around 80 percent of senior officials and asked each to explain the
functions and responsibilities of their institutions, Ghani’s
spokesman Nazifullah Salarzai said. “They all said there
was no political will to have an institution that functioned normally and accountably,” Salarzai said.
Ghani already has appointed former Interior Minister
Mohammad Hanif Atmar as national security adviser and
acting Finance Minister Hazrat Omar Zakhilwal as national
finance adviser. Women are expected to take a number of
senior positions, while the Women’s Affairs Ministry, widely derided as ineffectual, could be among those to go, a
number of officials said. Ghani and Abdullah want to
name most of the Cabinet before they meet international
donors in London in December to secure funding for
post-war development, said a Western ambassador,
speaking on condition of anonymity to talk about internal
Afghan discussions. At the London conference, Ghani will
be expected to demonstrate progress on reform, including graft and security. —AP
SUKKUR: Razia Shaikh looks up
to the sky, her eyes glistening
with tears and a Quran in her lap,
seeking divine justice for one
missing daughter and another
slain by vengeful relatives in the
name of “honor”. The widow, in
her 40s, wails as she shows two
photos of her daughter-brighteyed and vivacious in one, in the
other cold and lifeless, shrouded
in her white burial cloth. Shaikh is
one of countless mothers to suffer the misery of “karo-kari”, murders carried out supposedly to
preserve family honor or avenge
some perceived slight. The Aurat
Foundation, a campaign group
that works to improve the lives of
women in Pakistan’s conservative, patriarchal society, says
more than 3,000 have been killed
for “honor” since 2008.
Marriage and murder
Sitting on a traditional charpoy bed outside her one-room
home in Sachal Shah Miani village, off the bank of the River
Indus in southern Sindh
province, Shaikh recounts her
tale of woe. It began when her
elder daughter Khalida went
missing from the home of her inlaws in the southern port city of
Karachi in 2010. What became of
Khalida is unclear, but the in-laws
blamed Shaikh, a widow struggling to keep her dignity despite
extreme poverty.
As Shaikh was grieving for her
missing daughter, her in-laws
started demanding she marry
her younger daughter Shahida to
another of their sons. Shaikh
refused and three men broke into
her home, shooting her second
daughter in the back. They justified the murder by accusing her
of adultery and have not been
punished. “For the sake of Allah I
appeal to the ministers, the
judges and the police to get me
justice,” said Shaikh, weeping.
Government efforts to crack
down on these attacks have had
little success and the killings
remain a particular problem in
poor and rural areas of Pakistan.
In the absence of material
wealth, concepts of honor and
preserving the family’s good
name are highly valued.
Moreover, Pakistani law allows
the relatives of a victim to “forgive” the killer in return for blood
money-meaning that if the relatives themselves have arranged
the killing, prosecution can be
avoided. Marriages in Pakistan
are usually arranged and often
take place between cousins,
which can add a further motive
in the form of rows over dowries.
Irum Awan, a female police officer, heads a special force set up
in Sindh in 2008 to fight the
menace. “In most cases, ‘honor’ is
just a pretext whereas the real
motive is that they don’t want to
give the shares in property to
their sister or daughter,” Awan
said.
capture my land,” Hasan said in a
tiny house, located in a scruffy
alley by an open sewer. The landlord sent his men to threaten
Hasan, giving him the choice of
surrendering his land, his only
source of income, or paying
800,000 rupees ($8,000) to settle
the dispute-or face the consequences. “My life is in dangerthey have already attacked me
three times,” Hasan said. “I am a
poor man, I am just sitting at
pects are able to work the system
to avoid justice. “Some days ago
we conducted, you won’t believe,
more than 10 raids to arrest a
person who killed his wife,” she
said. “But when we produced him
before the honorable judge, he
released him on bail.”
Annually, estimates suggest
more than 350 murders are committed in the name of honor in
Sindh. “If you look at the Sindhi
newspapers, two to three inci-
SUKKUR: Pakistani villager Razia Shaikh, one of countless mothers to suffer the misery of “karo
kari”, shows a photograph of her daughter during an interview with AFP in Sukkur. —AFP
Feudal ties
It is not only women who suffer and not only matters of love
and marriage that lead to such
killings. Criminal justice in
Pakistan is deeply mired in local
politics, particularly in areas like
Sindh where society remains
largely feudal, with huge power
concentrated in the hands of big
hereditary landowners. And
questions of “honor” can be
invoked to settle other unrelated
disputes. In a small village west of
the town of Sukkur, Mohammad
Hasan lives in hiding after being
declared “karo” by the local feudal
landlord.
“I was declared karo after a
dispute that started about land
which was mine. They wanted to
home and hiding here and there.
He is an influential man, he can
do anything with me.”
The abuse of women and poor
men under the guise of “honor”
has gone on for centuries across
South Asia, but the British colonial rulers suppressed the practice. “In the British rule, they
would hold responsible and
round up the whole village
where the karo-kari would take
place, and thus the menace vanished during that time,” said
Javed Alam Odho, the police
chief of the Sukkur region. But
now weak law enforcement and
poor prosecution, often influenced by powerful people, keep
the killers at large.Awan admits
her frustration at the way sus-
dents are reported daily and this
is a routine,” said Khalid Banbhan,
bureau chief of Ibrat, a prominent Sindhi-language daily.
“Hardly there is a day when no
report appears in the newspapers about karo-kari.” Covering
the problem in rural areas is a
challenging task for local journalists, who are exposed to the
wrath of local feudal chieftains
who are usually power ful
enough to have troublemakers
punished, or even killed, with few
repercussions. Banbhan referred
to a case in which a journalist
received death threats after
reporting a case of a landlord
holding a village council that
sentenced two women to death
after declaring them “kari”.—AFP