Effects of Peer counseling on IYCF, Dr.Iqbal Kabir, Bangladesh

SAIFRN SEMINAR-2012: Peer
counselling intervention to improve
IYCF
Iqbal Kabir, MBBS, MD, PhD
Vice Chairperson, Bangladesh Breastfeeding Foundation
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Presentation outline
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Brief Background
Peer counseling for EBF
Peer counseling for complementary feeding
Lessons learned
Way forward
2
Introduction/Background
•
•
•
•
Initiation of breastfeeding within first hour remains
low in Bangladesh and south Asian countries.
IYCF practices in south Asia including Bangladesh
is not satisfactory. The rates of EBF remains low
(36%-42%) for last 15-20 years.
SAIFRN is working to produce evidence base to
identify reasons by analyzing the existing data set
(DHS)
To develop/conduct intervention studies to
improve IYCF in this region, thereby child survival.
3
Breastfeeding counseling in a diarrhoeal
disease hospital;
Bull WHO, 1996, Haider R, Kabir I et al.
Methods:
• Infants (n=250) aged up to 12 weeks who were admitted to
ICDDR,B hospital with diarrhea, were randomly assigned to
BF counseling and control (usual heath education) group.
• Mothers in the intervention group received individual (oneto-one) counseling: at least three counseling sessions
during their hospital stay by trained BF counselors.
• Data on feeding practice collected by research assistant
after 2 weeks at home
4
Effects of BF Counseling in Dhaka hospital: Rates
of EBF at discharge and 2-weeks follow-up
Interven
Control
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
At Disch
at 2-week
5
Effect of a community-based peer counsellors
on exclusive breastfeeding practices in Dhaka:
a randomised controlled trial
Haider R, Ashworth A, Kabir I, Huttly SRA; The Lancet 2000
Rates of EBF in the intervention and control groups
100
90
89
85
84
78
Percent %
80
70
70
60
50
40
32
30
23
17
20
11
10
6
0
1-mon
2-mon
3-mon
Interven
7
4-mon
Control
5-mon
Individual Counselling
8
9
Control
Individual
Group
10
6
M
on
th
5
M
on
th
4
M
on
th
3
M
on
th
2
M
on
th
1
th
M
on
Po
st
d
el
.
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
IMPACT OF COUNSELLING ON THE
COMPLEMENTARY FEEDING PRACTICES IN AN
URBAN COMMUNITY
I. Kabir, R. Haider, A. Ashworth, SRA Huttley,
S. Banu, T. Faruque, F. Begum Firu
11
Methods:
1.Two types CF were promoted; 1) Rice-gruel with or
without milk, oil and pinch of salt, 2) Khichuri;
Rice+lentil+oil
2. When the infant were 5 months old, mothers were
counseled and asked to start the CF along with
breastfeeding
3. A 24-h dietary recall method was used to assess the
BF and CF status
4. A portion of different complementary foods which were
fed to their infants, brought to nutrition laboratory were
analyzed for energy, protein and fat content
12
Proportions of infants fed different
types of CF in the intervention and control areas
.
Age of
Infants
Types of
CF
Control
n=277
Interventin
n=279
P value
6 months
Rice-gruel
62%
74%
<0.01
Khichuri
9%
18%
<0.01
Rice-gruel
60%
67%
<0.05
Khichuri
13%
26%
<0.01
Rice-gruel
52%
57%
0.3
Khichuri
13%
29%
0.05
8 months
10 months
13
Total energy intake (kcal) from CF of control and
intervention infants
Age of infants
6 Months
8 Months
10 Months
Food items
Control
Intervention
Gruel+Khichuri
208 (27-1357)
204 (15-1357)
Other foods
80 (10-697)
76 (8-650)
Gruel+Khichuri
244 (13-1792)
268 (10-1450)
Other foods
66 (9-460)
54 (5-558)
Gruel+Khichuri
271 (13-1460)
253 (3-1075)
Other foods
80 (4-1135)
76 (5-664)
14
Total energy, protein and fat Contents of CF
Recommended and practices by mothers
CF Types
Nutrients
Requirement Actual
Gaps (%)
Rice Gruel
Energy
(Kcal/100gm)
75
62
-18
Protein (gm %)
1.22
1.14
-7
Fat (gm%)
2.17
1.65
-14
Energy
(Kcal/100gm)
99
72
-27
Protein (gm%)
4.16
2.91
-30
Fat (gm%)
3.33
1.81
-46
Khichuri
15
SAIFRN STUDIES-2012
16
Minimum acceptable diet
(breastfed children only)
6-23 months
Sri Lanka
Nepal
India
Bangladesh
0
20
17
40
60
Percentage
80
100
Determinants of not having adequate CF
The most consistent determinants across all
countries are;
*Lack of maternal education.
*Lower household wealth.
Other factors found in more than 1 country:
• limited exposure to media
• inadequate antenatal care
• lack of postnatal contacts
18
Future issues and what is next??
 Knowledge and understanding of CF still limited
 CF is culture-specific and can not be promoted as prescription ;
in contrast to BF, that is universal
 More research are required to identify best CF; locally available,
affordable
 Extended peer counseling to improve the whole IYCF practice
(such as MSPT)
 Development of national document on policy, guideline on IYCF.
 Integration of IYCF into major MCH, health and nutrition
programs.
19
.
20