as at 9 February 2015
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
SITTING OF THE COURT OF APPEAL
CONFIRMED FIXTURE (AMENDMENT NO. 2)
COMMENCING MONDAY, 9 FEBRUARY 2015 TO FRIDAY, 13 FEBRUARY 2015
APPEALS/APPLICATIONS FOR HEARING
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------9 FEBRUARY 2015, MONDAY
10:00 AM
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
1 CORAM
ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
APPEAL NO.
: CA 91/2014 DECISION OF JUSTICE TAY YONG KWANG
IN S 357/2012
APPELLANT
: ANANDA UK (CHINA) LIMITED
(SANKARAN KARTHIKEYAN)
(TOH TAN LLP)
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: CULINDO LIVESTOCK (1994) PTE LTD
(TITO SHANE ISAAC/CHAN YEW LOONG JUSTIN/
TOH YUNYUAN SELINA)
(TITO ISAAC & CO LLP)
: SALE OF GOODS; CONTRACT
TIME ALLOWED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT:
TOH TAN LLP - 20 MINS
TITO ISAAC & CO LLP - 20 MINS
1 of 11
2
CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
NOT BEFORE 11:30 AM
3 CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
: CA 92/2014 DECISION OF JUSTICE TAY YONG KWANG
IN S 357/2012
: CULINDO LIVESTOCK (1994) PTE LTD
(TITO SHANE ISAAC/CHAN YEW LOONG JUSTIN/
TOH YUNYUAN SELINA)
(TITO ISAAC & CO LLP)
: ANANDA UK (CHINA) LIMITED
(SANKARAN KARTHIKEYAN)
(TOH TAN LLP)
: SALE OF GOODS; CONTRACT
TIME ALLOWED FOR THIS APPEAL IS INCLUDED IN CA 91/2014
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
: CA 143/2014 DECISION OF JUDICIAL COMMISSIONER
EDMUND LEOW IN S 364/2013
: TIONG TUANG YEONG & ORS
(DANIEL KOH CHOON GUAN)
(ELDAN LAW LLP – INSTRUCTED COUNSEL)
(TAN CHAU YEE)
(HARRY ELIAS PARTNERSHIP LLP)
: LIM AH SIA
(AHMAD KHALIS BIN ABDUL GHANI/RAJARAM MURALLI RAJA)
(STRAITS LAW PRACTICE LLC)
: COMPANIES — MINORITY OPPRESSION
TIME ALLOWED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT:
APPELLANT- 20 MINS
RESPONDENT - 20 MINS
2 of 11
NOT BEFORE 2:30 PM
4 CORAM
APPLICATION NO.
APPLICANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
5
CORAM
APPLICATION NO.
APPLICANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
TAY YONG KWANG J
: SUM 6189/2014 – CA 121/2014
: LOW KIN KOK @ LOW KONG SONG
(BOON KHOON LIM)
(DORA BOON & COMPANY)
: LEE CHIOW SENG
(IN-PERSON)
: CIVIL PROCEDURE – APPLICATIONS TO STRIKE OUT NOTICE
OF APPEAL
TIME ALLOWED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT:
APPLICANT – 15 MINS
RESPONDENT – 15 MINS
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
TAY YONG KWANG J
: SUM 175/2015 – CA 121/2014
: LOW KIN KOK @ LOW KONG SONG
(BOON KHOON LIM)
(DORA BOON & COMPANY)
: LEE CHIOW SENG
(IN-PERSON)
: CIVIL PROCEDURE – APPLICATIONS TO STRIKE OUT NOTICE
OF APPEAL
TIME ALLOWED FOR THIS APPLICATION IS INCLUDED IN
SUM 6189/2014
3 of 11
NOT BEFORE 3:00 PM
6 CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
TAY YONG KWANG J
: CA 67/2014 DECISION OF JUSTICE CHOO HAN TECK
IN S 486/2013
: TRIDENT PHARM PTE LTD
(PONNAMPALAM SIVAKUMAR)
(BERNARD & RADA LAW CORPORATION)
: YONG PEI PEI TRACEY & ANOR
(PONNIAH JAMES LESLIE/LEONG SUE LYNN)
(WONG & LIM)
: EMPLOYMENT — EMPLOYEES’ DUTIES; TORT — INDUCING
BREACH OF CONTRACT — CONSPIRACY
TIME ALLOWED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT:
APPELLANT – 20 MINS
RESPONDENT – 20 MINS
4 of 11
10 FEBRUARY 2015, TUESDAY
09:30 AM
7 CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
8
CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
: CA 91/2014 DECISION OF JUSTICE TAY YONG KWANG
IN S 357/2012
: ANANDA UK (CHINA) LIMITED
(SANKARAN KARTHIKEYAN)
(TOH TAN LLP)
: CULINDO LIVESTOCK (1994) PTE LTD
(TITO SHANE ISAAC/CHAN YEW LOONG JUSTIN/
TOH YUNYUAN SELINA)
(TITO ISAAC & CO LLP)
: SALE OF GOODS; CONTRACT
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
: CA 92/2014 DECISION OF JUSTICE TAY YONG KWANG
IN S 357/2012
: CULINDO LIVESTOCK (1994) PTE LTD
(TITO SHANE ISAAC/CHAN YEW LOONG JUSTIN/
TOH YUNYUAN SELINA)
(TITO ISAAC & CO LLP)
: ANANDA UK (CHINA) LIMITED
(SANKARAN KARTHIKEYAN)
(TOH TAN LLP)
: SALE OF GOODS; CONTRACT
5 of 11
NOT BEFORE 10:00 AM
9 CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
NOT BEFORE 2:30 PM
10 CORAM
APPLICATION NO.
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
CHAN SEK KEONG SJ
: CA 157/2014 DECISION OF JUSTICE JUDITH PRAKASH
IN S 855/2012
: FREIGHT CONNECT(S) PTE. LTD.
(NAVINDER SINGH)
(NAVIN & CO. LLP)
: PARAGON SHIPPING PTE. LTD.
(K MURALITHERAPANY/EDWARD KOH)
(JOSEPH TAN JUDE BENNY LLP)
: ADMIRALTY AND SHIPPING — CARRIAGE OF GOODS BY SEA
TIME ALLOWED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT:
APPELLANT - 30 MINS
RESPONDENT - 30 MINS
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
: CRF 3/2014
APPLICANT
: PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
(HON YI/GORDON OH/CHERYL LIM)
(ATTORNEY-GENERAL’S CHAMBERS (FINANCIAL AND
TECHNOLOGY CRIMES DIVISON))
RESPONDENT
: SOLLIHIN BIN ANHAR
(THANGAVELU)
(THANGAVELU LLC)
: CRIMINAL - QUESTIONS OF LAW OF PUBLIC INTEREST - BAIL
SUBJECT MATTER
6 of 11
NOT BEFORE 3:30 PM
11 CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
: CA 134/2014
DECISION OF JUDICIAL COMMISSIONER
EDMUND LEOW IN S 56/2013
: THE ONE SUITES PTE. LTD.
(MICHAEL ANTHONY PALMER/CHEW KIAT JINN/
TAN GEK THENG)
(QUAHE WOO & PALMER LLC)
: PACIFIC MOTOR CREDIT (PTE.) LTD.
(ALBERT S BALASUBRAMANIAM)
(JING QUEE & CHIN JOO – INSTUCTED COUNSEL)
(CHEW CHING CHING)
(CHING CHING PEK GAN & PARTNERS)
: LAND – SALE OF LAND; CONTRACT
TIME ALLOWED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT:
APPELLANT - 20 MINS
RESPONDENT - 20 MINS
7 of 11
11 FEBRUARY 2015, WEDNESDAY
09:30 AM
DELIVERY OF JUDGMENT
12 CORAM
: CHAO HICK TIN JA, ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA AND
TAY YONG KWANG J
APPLICATION NO. : CRF 1/2014
APPLICANT
: MUSTAFA AHUNBAY
(N SREENIVASAN S.C./MURALLI RAJARAM/LISA CHONG)
(STRAITS LAW PRACTICE)
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
NOT BEFORE 10:00 AM
13 CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
(MAVIS CHIONH/KEVIN YONG/ LYNN TAN/EUGENE SNG)
(ATTORNEY-GENERAL'S CHAMBERS (CRIMINAL JUSTICE
DIVISION))
: CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
AND QUENTIN LOH J
: CA 148/2014 DECISION OF JUSTICE BELINDA ANG SAW EAN
IN S 663/2011
: WILLIAM CHENG
(MELVIN CHAN KAH KEEN/RACHEL TAN PEI QIAN)
(TSMP LAW CORPORATION)
: M/S ALLISTER LIM AND THRUMURGAN & ANOR
(CHRISTOPHER ANAND S/O DANIEL/GANGA D/O AVADIAR/
FOO LI CHUAN ARLENE)
(ADVOCATUS LAW LLP)
: TORT – SOLICITORS’ NEGLIGENCE – SALE OF LAND;
CONTRACT – FRAUDULENT MISREPRESENTATION
TIME ALLOWED FOR THIS APPEAL IS INCLUDED IN CA 152/2014
8 of 11
14 CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
AND QUENTIN LOH J
: CA 152/2014 DECISION OF JUSTICE BELINDA ANG SAW EAN
IN S 663/2011
: M/S ALLISTER LIM AND THRUMURGAN & ORS
(CHRISTOPHER ANAND S/O DANIEL/GANGA D/O AVADIAR/
FOO LI CHUAN ARLENE)
(ADVOCATUS LAW LLP)
: SU AH TEE & ORS
(THOMAS LEI)
(LAWRENCE CHUA & PARTNERS FOR 1st TO 3RD R)
(MELVIN CHAN KAH KEEN/RACHEL TAN PEI QIAN)
(TSMP LAW CORPORATION FOR 4TH R)
(IN-PERSON FOR 5TH R)
(IN-PERSON FOR 6TH R)
: TORT – SOLICITORS’ NEGLIGENCE – SALE OF LAND;
CONTRACT – FRAUDULENT MISREPRESENTATION
TIME ALLOWED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT:
ADVOCATUS LAW LLP - 45 MINS
LAWRENCE CHUA & PARTNERS - 30 MINS
TSMP LAW CORPORATION - 30 MINS
5th R - 30 MINS
9 of 11
12 FEBRUARY 2015, THURSDAY
10:00 AM
: SUNDARESH MENON CJ, CHAO HICK TIN JA AND
15 CORAM
ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
APPLICATION NO. : CRF 7/2014
APPLICANT
: PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
(TAN KEN HWEE/SANJIV VASWANI/YAU PUI MAN)
(ATTORNEY-GENERAL’S CHAMBERS (FINANCIAL AND
TECHNOLOGY CRIMES DIVISON))
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
NOT BEFORE 2:30 PM
16 CORAM
APPLICATION NO.
APPLICANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: LIM YONG SOON BERNARD
(IN-PERSON)
: CRIMINAL - QUESTIONS OF LAW OF PUBLIC INTEREST PROVIDING FALSE INFORMATION
: CHAO HICK TIN JA, ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA AND
JUDITH PRAKASH J
: SUM 6346/2014 – CA 74/2010
: HO PAK KIM REALTY CO PTE LTD
(IN-PERSON)
: REVITECH PTE LTD
(TITO SHANE ISAAC/CHAN YEW LOONG JUSTIN/
NEO WEI CHIAN VALERIE)
(TITO ISAAC & CO LLP)
: CIVIL PROCEDURE – STAY OF EXECUTION
TIME ALLOWED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT:
APPLICANT - 20 MINS
RESPONDENT - 20 MINS
10 of 11
NOT BEFORE 3:30 PM
17 CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: CHAO HICK TIN JA, ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
AND JUDITH PRAKASH J
: CA 2/2014 DECISION OF JUDICIAL COMMISSIONER
LIONEL YEE IN DT 1070/2012
: AEH
(PATRICK CHIN MENG LIONG)
(CHIN PATRICK & CO – INSTRUCTED COUNSEL)
(WONG CHAI KIN)
(WONG CHAI KIN)
: AEI
(MARY ONG/CHONG YUE-EN)
(MARY ONG & COMPANY)
: FAMILY LAW
TIME ALLOWED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT:
WONG CHAI KIN - 15 MINS
MARY ONG & COMPANY - 15 MINS
18
CORAM
APPEAL NO.
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
SUBJECT MATTER
: CHAO HICK TIN JA, ANDREW PHANG BOON LEONG JA
AND JUDITH PRAKASH J
: CA 3/2014 DECISION OF JUDICIAL COMMISSIONER
LIONEL YEE IN DT 1070/2012
: AEI
(MARY ONG/CHONG YUE-EN)
(MARY ONG & COMPANY)
: AEH
(PATRICK CHIN MENG LIONG)
(CHIN PATRICK & CO – INSTRUCTED COUNSEL)
(WONG CHAI KIN)
(WONG CHAI KIN)
: FAMILY LAW
TIME ALLOWED FOR THIS APPEAL IS INCLUDED IN
CA 2/2014
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------FOO CHEE HOCK
REGISTRAR
SUPREME COURT, SINGAPORE
11 of 11