Joy & Hope FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY OF GAUDIUM ET SPES March 22–24, 2015 † University of Notre Dame CONFERENCE SCHEDULE All events are in the Notre Dame Conference Center at McKenna Hall on Notre Dame Avenue unless otherwise noted. Sunday, March 22, 2015 10:00 am Mass – Basilica of the Sacred Heart Cardinal Wilfrid Napier, O.F.M. of Durban, South Africa Celebrant & Homilist 2:00 – 4:00 pm CST Research Collaborative Wrap-Around (by invitation) – Room 109 4:00 – 7:00 pm Registration – Lobby 5:00 pm Dinner for Keynote Speakers and Cosponsors (by invitation) Hesburgh Room, The Morris Inn 7:00 pm Conference Opening & Keynote Address - Auditorium Opening Prayer Voices of Faith Gospel Choir Ensemble Welcome by Bill Purcell, M.Div., Associate Director of Catholic Social Tradition, Center for Social Concerns and Co-Director of the Catholic Social Tradition Minor, University of Notre Dame Keynote Address “An Echo in their Hearts”: The Church in Our Modern World Kristin Heyer, Ph.D. Bernard J. Hanley Professor of Religious Studies Santa Clara University Introduction by Rev. Paul V. Kollman, C.S.C. The Leo and Arlene Hawk Executive Director of the Center for Social Concerns, Associate Professor of Theology, University of Notre Dame 1 8:30 – 9:30 pm Dessert Reception – Atrium Live music performed by "Still Working on the Sound" Featuring Louis Albarran, Shawn Storer, and Joe Weber Monday, March 23, 2015 8:00 am Continental Breakfast, Registration and Networking – Lobby 9:00 am Workshops I: Three Concurrent Sessions (1) Learning the Catholic Social Tradition: A National Research Project – Room 100 – 104 The Catholic social tradition presents a rich array of principles and historical teachings increasingly emphasized within Catholic higher education. Yet we know little about how CST principles are learned and applied in the course of lives. How do students understand the Catholic social tradition as a component of faith? In what ways do they seek to apply CST principles in addressing complex moral challenges? How may learning about the tradition prompt life-long integration of inherent principles? A national research collaboration across a dozen colleges has begun to address such questions. We will share resources, present findings to date, and outline plans for future work. Presenters: Roger Bergman, Ph.D. Associate Professor Director, Justice & Peace Studies Program Creighton University Jay Brandenberger, Ph.D. Associate Director for Research and Assessment, Center for Social Concerns Concurrent Associate Professor of Psychology University of Notre Dame Harry Dammer, Ph.D. Chair, Sociology/Criminal Justice & Criminology University of Scranton, PA Kathleen Maas Weigert, Ph.D. Carolyn Farrell, BVM, Professor of Women and Leadership Assistant to the Provost for Social Justice Initiatives Loyola University Chicago Heather Mack Community Engagement Research & Assessment Director Office of Community Engaged Learning, Teaching & Scholarship Loyola University New Orleans 2 Michelle Nickerson, Ph.D. Associate Professor Graduate Program Director Department of History Loyola University Chicago Kurt C. Schlichting, Ph.D. E. Gerald Corrigan Chair in the Humanities & Social Sciences Professor of Sociology, Department of Sociology & Anthropology Fairfield University (2) Digitally Going Global: Using Technology & Partnerships for Global Citizenship Without Leaving Your Campus – Room 112 – 114 Calling all faculty! This workshop will offer the opportunity to share best practices for integrating international development and global solidarity into college curricula. Collaboration between universities and external organizations such as NGOs, the Church, and other actors in the international development sector is imperative today; the question is how best to do it. Catholic Relief Services (CRS) staff and faculty partners will offer analysis of what we have learned via the CRS Faculty Learning Commons (an initiative that translates CRS’ work in the field and its animating themes and partnerships into resources for the university classroom). We’ll share ideas on pedagogical techniques related to educating for solidarity, highlighting the use of information technology in connecting students to “the field” in particular. We'll also leave time for more general conversation on opportunities and challenges related to globally-minded teaching. Presenters: Louis Charest, M.A. Manager, University Engagement (US Operations), Catholic Relief Services Meghan Clark, Ph.D. Assistant Professor of Moral Theology, St. John's University (NY) Member of CRS University Faculty Advisory Board Margaret Kowalsky, MTS Faculty Consultant, Catholic Relief Services Faculty Learning Commons (3) “To Do in Love What the Truth Requires”: A Summons to be Artisans of Peace in an Hour of Supreme Crisis – Room 210 – 214 This session will offer some background on Church teaching on war, peace and conscience before and after the Second Vatican Council. It will also share some of the history of the drafting of and debate around the sections on war and conscience in Schema XIII (which came to be known as Gaudium et Spes). Additionally, an account of the beginnings and early efforts of the CPF (which had its origins in late 1964 and early 1965) will be shared as will an overview of its contemporary work with conscientious objectors, selective conscientious objectors, former military, parishes, and schools. Since the Council Fathers stress that the “courage of those who fearlessly and openly resist” those who issue unjust or criminal commands 3 “merits supreme commendation” (GS, no. 79), a portion of this session will be devoted to the words of those who have conscientiously objected to war. This workshop will conclude with time for participants to enter into discussion with the presenters and with others who are currently involved in the work of the CPF about how to respond to the Gospel call to be instruments of a peace which “symbolizes and results from the peace of Christ which radiates from God the Father.” (GS, no. 77) Presenters: Deacon Tom Cornell, D.H.L. Lifelong Catholic Worker Associate Editor, The Catholic Worker Co-founder of the Catholic Peace Fellowship Shawn T. Storer, M.Div. Director, Catholic Peace Fellowship Daniel E. Baker Catholic Peace Fellowship Adviser & Conscientious Objector Counselor 10:15 am Break 10:45 am Social Issues Colloquium I: Four Concurrent Sessions Session 1 (three presentations) Political Theology: Economics, War & the Person, Room 100 – 104 (1) David Carroll Cochran, Ph.D. Professor of Politics Director of the Archbishop Kucera Center for Catholic Intellectual and Spiritual Life Loras College Abolitionist Rather than Pacifist: Understanding the Vatican’s Position on War since Gaudium et Spes Drawing on Cochran’s recent book, Catholic Realism and the Abolition of War (Orbis Books), this presentation examines how Catholic teaching since Gaudium et Spes has endorsed abolishing war through greater global governance, even while endorsing the right of states to resort to military action in narrow circumstances until then. Without denying humanity’s fallen nature or the ongoing reality of sin, the Catholic tradition argues that moral progress is possible because social institutions can change for the better. The presentation evaluates this claim by looking at other forms on institutionalized violence once accepted as a routine, necessary, and inevitable part of everyday life, but which now are much rarer or abolished entirely. Examples include capital punishment, trials by ordeal, vendettas, duels, lynching, and chattel slavery. The presentation concludes by considering whether a similar process of gradual abolition is possible for warfare. 4 (2) Ellen Van Stichel Postdoctoral Research Assistant Anthropos Project Faculty of Theology & Religious Studies KU Leuven (Catholic University Leuven) Gaudium et Spes: From a Personalist to a Trinitarian Anthropology and its Implications for Reflecting on the (Global) Economy In the Pastoral Constitution Gaudium et Spes the Second Vatican Council’s ‘aggiornamento’ results in a very open attitude towards the world, based on a positive, social anthropology that appreciates the human being’s capacities to transform the world (s)he lives in. Considering the changes the world has undergone since the Council, we might ask whether its social personalistic anthropology underpinning Catholic social thought does not need to be updated and if so, what such an update would look like and what its inspirational sources might be. Looking at globalization and its effect on all parts of the whole world, an even more thoroughly relational anthropology seems most adequate. It therefore seems appropriate to to further develop and investigate the Trinitarian anthropology glimpsed at in Gaudium et Spes (§24) in light of later contributions of both Caritas in veritate and Evangelii Gaudium, and to do so with regard to its relevance for reflecting on the economy. In this paper, I aim to show how an anthropology focused on being the image of the Trinitarian God opens promising avenues for rethinking some basic assumptions of economic behaviour. Although developing comprehensive solutions towards revising the global economy lies outside the scope of this paper, at least some concrete suggestions for change can be suggested – since glimpses of the practical implications of this anthropology can already be noticed wherever this Trinitarian anthro is applied in economic entrepreneurship, as for instance in the ‘economy of communion’ project. (3) Michael Griffin, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Theology Holy Cross College Respondents: David Lutz, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Philosophy Holy Cross College Isaac Desta, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Business Holy Cross College Neither Capitalist nor Socialist: the Distributist Alternative If Catholic Social Teaching critiques the concentration of ownership both by corporations and by the state, then what exists as an alternative to these various degrees of capitalism or socialism? In this paper I will suggest that the answer is distributism, an economic school that arose in Catholic circles during the late 19th and early 20th Century. After presenting a key foundational claim of distributism, my colleagues David Lutz and Isaac Desta will offer responses that reflect insights from non-Distributist Catholic alternatives to capitalism and socialism. 5 Session 2 (three presentations) Pastoral and Pedagogical Applications, Room 112 – 114 (1) Angela Gray-Girton Associate Director, Center for Faith & Justice Xavier University Justice-Based Student Development Developed by a group of scholar/practitioners at Xavier University, this Justice-Based Student Development Model seeks to identify the developmental path of students who engage in community engagement and service-learning activities. Based on the Break Away Active Citizen Continuum and informed by moral development models, a spiritual growth model, a white consciousness development model, and a solidarity model, this model identifies a path of intellectual, emotional, and interpersonal justice-focused growth that can come from experiences of intentionally, effectively facilitated community engagement/service-learning which includes thoughtful reflection and social analysis. (2) Justin Menno Doctoral Candidate Department of Theology University of Dayton Remembrance and Recognition: The Burial of the Dead as a Work of Justice This paper seeks to comment on the corporal work of burying the dead in an attempt to better integrate reflections in Gaudium et Spes on human dignity and the meaning of death. Building on the principle that remembrance is vital to recognition, this paper intends to show how the corporal work of burying the dead is indispensable not only to recognizing, but even promoting intrinsic human dignity. To this end, two opposing cases will be treated. The first will examine the role that burying the dead played in promoting interracial justice in apartheid South Africa. And the second will focus on the contemporary negative effects of denying burial to pre-born victims of abortion violence. In closing, the challenge and fruits of burying the dead will be rooted in reflection on the burial of Christ. (3) Grégoire Catta, S.J. STD Candidate School of Theology and Ministry Boston College Catholic Social Teaching as Theological Discourse. The Legacy of a Crucial Footnote of Gaudium et Spes About the Meaning of a “Pastoral” Constitution The footnote associated with the title of Gaudium et Spes (GS) has a tremendous importance. It states that the qualifier “pastoral” should not be opposed to the qualifier “doctrinal” but that, on the contrary, both parts of the pastoral constitution are at the same time pastoral and doctrinal. This means that dealing with contingent social ethical issues is not an impediment to producing a theological or doctrinal discourse but rather a path toward it. This paper intends to show how post-Vatican II’s Catholic social teaching, following the path opened by GS, contributes to enriching theological discourse by shedding light, through its addressing of social issues, on some aspects of the mystery of “God for us.” The aspect chosen as a case study will be Christology. 6 Session 3 (two presentations) Solutions to Systemic Injustice, Room 202 (1) John Sniegocki, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Christian Ethics Xavier University Catholic Social Teaching and Food Ethics This paper explores the resources contained in Gaudium et Spes and other CST documents for developing Catholic ethical reflections on our dietary choices. These choices have profound impacts on issues such as world hunger, ecology, human health, the rights of workers, the well-being of farmers, and the treatment of animals. With regard to ecology, for example, leading climate scientists such as James Hansen have suggested that our dietary choices are perhaps the most critical individual choice that we make that impacts greenhouse gas emissions. Similarly, the United Nations and other analysts have suggested that significant dietary changes will be needed among the world’s wealthy in order to allow for the possibility of a growing world population to be adequately fed. Such issues have received very little explicit attention in CST, yet valuable resources exist within the tradition that can be drawn upon in addressing them. At the same time, I will also suggest several ways that CST could be further deepened. (2) Mary Beckman, Ph.D. Associate Director/Faculty, Academic Affairs and Research Center for Social Concerns University of Notre Dame and Danielle Wood, Ph.D. Assistant Director, Community-Based Research and Impact Center for Social Concerns University of Notre Dame Promoting Justice in a Pluralistic World through Higher Education: Addressing the Second Foot of Justice The United States Catholic Bishops Conference (USCCB) highlights the importance of considering two feet in working for social justice. One foot provides service to those impacted by injustice and the other focuses on the structures and policies that perpetuate injustices. According to this framing, some efforts address symptoms or conditions of injustice. Other efforts focus on the systemic causes in the hope that, ultimately, we will minimize the conditions of injustice. Using examples of challenges in South Bend, Indiana, our presentation will describe manifestations of injustice calcified into self-perpetuating systems. Drawing from systems literature, we will offer an approach to deconstructing how they have developed into systems that reinforce injustices. We will also be exploring how college and university students and faculty might use academic community engagement in the process of disrupting such systems. 7 Session 4 (three presentations) Common Good: Local & Global, Room 210 – 214 (1) Jeffery L. Nicholas, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Philosophy Providence College The Hope for and of the Common Good: The Missing Role of Practical Reason in Catholic Social Thought In Gaudium et Spes, the Council follows John XXIII in his definition of the common good, a definition that has become paradigmatic for Catholic social thought. Defined as conditions for human flourishing, the common good includes a set of material, moral, and spiritual goods and rights to these goods. I will argue, however, that the common good as presented misses one of the most important features of social life— practical reasoning. Alasdair MacIntyre shows that common goods are those goods identified in communion with others that form the basis of practical reasoning. The hope for the common goods of human life is a hope from which we in communion are able to reason practically about justice. The hope of the common good is for that justice to occur. When we leave out practical reasoning, we reify the common good as singular and static. Yet, following MacIntyre’s account, we must recognize that justice consists in a multiplicity of common goods that are conditioned historically. These include the goods of the various associations within a historically existent community; the members of that community who form those associations come together under the aegis of the natural law to prioritize those goods and establish justice. I will begin by contrasting the official account of the common good with that of MacIntyre’s account. This differentiation will include a brief discussion of Mary Keys’ analysis of Maritain and Deborah Wallace’s engagement with MacIntyre. Second, I will examine how practical reasoning works within local communities to establish the common goods. This examination will include a discussion of human desire as a foundation for common goods, referring back to Thomas’ discussion of natural inclinations in ST I-II 94. Finally, I will propose how this account of the relationship between practical reasoning and common goods strengthens how the Church promotes peace and justice, giving a brief look at the issue of globalization. (2) William French, Ph.D. Associate Professor, Religious Ethics Institute of Environmental Sustainability Theology Department Loyola University of Chicago Revising Gaudium et Spes in Light of the Ecological Signs of Our Times Gaudium et Spes does an admirable job in stressing that dynamic historical trends have pushed humanity into a position where we must accept that all of humanity is a global community to which we all owe “solidarity.” But across the 50 years since its publication rising ecological “signs of the times,” require the Church to mobilize new ethical attention and mobilize for new responsibilities. These new ecological signs offer an important lens for examining the theological anthropology present in Gaudium et Spes. An ecologically-informed reading of Gaudium et Spes finds a sustained human-centered, personalist philosophical and theological vision that nicely highlights human sociality and our solidarity with other humans. It fails, however, to situate the “social question” inside the larger “ecological question.” Gaudium et Spes pushes the ethic of “solidarity” out to a universal commitment to the global human family. But the last 50 years scream that we need expand our sense of “solidarity” ecologically to include a sense of moral commitment to all of the community of species and ecosystems of the Earth. The text exhibits a heavy 8 reliance on appeals to Genesis 1 to stress humanity’s dominion and superiority over all of the rest of nature. Genesis 2 offers a much more ecologically sensitive language of “till and keep the Earth.” But it is not cited. Ironically when we begin to integrate an ecological perspective of the signs of the times into theological reflection, I argue, we begin to recover many theological and ethical themes about the community of creation that were prominent in the Medieval period. In my constructive agenda I note how many perspectives raised by contemporary ecological concerns integrate rather closely to some of the important emphases on the Book of Nature, Natural law, and the virtue of prudence found in the writings of Thomas Aquinas and other Medieval giants. These suggest the need for the Church to engage climate change concerns and embrace ecological responsibility as a set of top moral priorities for the next fifty years. (3) Kathryn Getek Soltis, Ph.D. Director, Center for Peace and Justice Education Assistant Professor of Christian Ethics Villanova University Gaudium et Spes and the Family: A Social Tradition with Room to Grow For those mining the Pastoral Constitution for insights on the development of Catholic social thought, the section on the family is typically of minimal significance. Yet, particularly in the midst of two consecutive synods, we are in need of a discourse that communicates the relevance of the family for the pursuit of justice. After noting the limitations of the approach found in Gaudium et Spes, this session focuses on three areas for development. First, there is need for a public understanding of family beyond that mediated through the education of children, including family practices of consumption and solidarity across socioeconomic boundaries. Second, new attention ought to be paid to society’s responsibility for the families of workers. Finally, the burdens of social injustice upon families necessitate methodological development. Mass incarceration provides one example of the importance of employing the lens of family flourishing among others as a method to critique social problems. 12:15 pm Break 12:30 pm Luncheon – Dining Room Remarks by Rev. Paul V. Kollman, C.S.C. The Leo and Arlene Hawk Executive Director of the Center for Social Concerns, Associate Professor of Theology, University of Notre Dame 2:00 pm Social Issues Colloquium II: Four Concurrent Sessions Session 1 (two presentations) Poverty & the Praxis of Charity, Room 100 – 104 (1) Bro. Raymond Fitz, S.M., Ph.D. Fr. Ferree Professor of Social Justice University of Dayton A Post Parochial Strategy for Advancing Urban Solidarity Two trends, the movement of the Catholic Church to the suburbs and the concentration of high poverty neighborhoods in the urban centers, are explored to highlight challenges that the Church has in advancing 9 justice in the city. Two resources are utilized to shape a response to these challenges: 1) the principles from Catholic social teaching that have been developed in conversation with Gaudium et Spes and 2) contemporary approaches to addressing multi-generational poverty in an urban neighborhood. These two resources help define elements of a post-parochial strategy for the Church in metropolitan regions to advance urban solidarity. (2) Brian R. Corbin Senior Vice President of Social Policy Catholic Charities USA and Cynthia S. Dobrzynski, M.A. Senior Vice President, Mission and Ministry Catholic Charities USA Gaudium et Spes and the Praxis of Charity This presentation reviews the work done by Catholic Charities throughout the US in its accompaniment of families in economic peril. The praxis of charity is aimed at achieving a future without poverty and must include both federal policy changes and immediate aid to the 45.3 million people living in poverty in this country. Session 2 (three presentations) War, Peace & Reconciliation, Room 112 – 114 (1) Roger Bergman, Ph.D. Associate Professor Director, Justice & Peace Studies Program Creighton University Conscientious Objection to Unjust War: Before and After Gaudium et Spes Blessed Franz Jägerstätter, the Austrian peasant who refused to serve in Hitler’s army, is the only officially recognized martyr of the just war tradition. This presentation will examine the Catholic tradition of refusal to participate in unjust war from Augustine through Aquinas, Vitoria, Suarez, and Grotius to Vatican II, the U.S. bishops, and the Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church, for evidence of justification for Jägerstätter’s witness. Despite the fact that Pope Pius XII in 1956 stated that “a Catholic citizen cannot invoke his own conscience in order to refuse to serve and fulfill those [military] duties the law imposes,” since 1968 the U.S. bishops have been repeatedly on record in support of SCO. Did Gaudium et Spes make the beatification of Franz Jägerstätter possible? And is he a hero to be admired, or a model to be emulated? Might he become the first of many Catholic conscientious objectors to unjust war? (2) Bernard Brady, Ph.D. Professor and Department Chair Theology Department University of St. Thomas Fifty Years After the Call "to Undertake an Evaluation of War with an Entirely Different Attitude" The “horror and perversity” of warfare in the contemporary world compelled the Council “to undertake an evaluation of war with an entirely new attitude” (GS, 80). Christian theology and practice have 10 followed. Over the five decades, there have been significant developments in the theoretical reflection of the morality of war and the promotion of peace. This presentation will discuss these developments. Yet, some things have not changed. For many Christians (not engaged in the theory and practice of war and peacemaking), there remains the sense of loyalty to national claims and the belief that war or war-like activities are often needed to advance human liberation. This paper suggests that the “people-building” praxis of Pope Francis, illustrated in his writing and ministry, may be a bridge to nourishing the “new attitude” expressed by the Council. (3) Tim Carey Ph.D. Candidate Department of Theology Boston College Peace, Justice, and Reconciliation: The Impact of Gaudium et Spes on the African Synods With its imagery of church as family, Gaudium et Spes catalyzed the African Synods of 1994 and 2009 which aimed to highlight some of the basic issues facing the mission and nature of the Catholic Church in Africa. While the former synod characterized the ministry of the African church through the model of family in God, the latest synod was charged with developing a model which promoted the themes of reconciliation, peace, and justice in light of regional conflicts arising within many sub-Saharan African countries. Underscoring both synods is the idea of the church as both local and global family, with church leaders seeking to reconcile the traditional African religious identity with the more foundational teachings of the Catholic Church. By considering the influence of Vatican II on the African Synods, this paper reflects on the lasting identity of the church in Africa especially as this pertains to the confluence of traditional belief systems and foundational Catholic teaching. Session 3 (two presentations) Conscience, Room 202 (1) Todd A. Salzman, Ph.D. Professor of Theology Creighton University and Michael G. Lawler, Ph.D. Amelia and Emil Graff Professor Emeritus of Catholic Theology Creighton University Gaudium et Spes on Human Dignity: The Plural Perspectives of Conscience Human dignity is a foundational ethical term in Gaudium et Spes (GS), which is committed to discerning what constitutes the truly human, fully human, or human dignity anthropologically and normatively. This commitment indicates an objectivist metaethic that realizes that what is good or right can be defined universally and that it is defined in terms of human dignity. GS’ focus on human dignity, combined with its statement on the nature and authority of conscience, opens up the possibility for moral pluralism in ethical discourse, including plural definitions of human dignity grounded in the integral and adequate consideration of the human person and plural definitions of norms that facilitate attaining human dignity. This paper explores natural law as an objectivist meta-ethical theory and we argue, using Bernard Lonergan’s epistemological theory of perspectivism, that through the role, function, and authority of a wellformed conscience, people can come to plural definitions of the good defined as human dignity and plural 11 formulations and justifications of norms for what facilitates and does not frustrate attaining human dignity. We note further that these plural definitions may, and often do, come into conflict with the hierarchical magisterium’s definition of human dignity and its absolute biomedical and sexual ethical norms. (2) Bernard G. Prusak, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Philosophy Director, McGowan Center for Ethics and Social Responsibility King’s College (PA) Conscience, Then and Now Section 16 of Gaudium et Spes puts forth a moving and oft-quoted account of conscience. Arguably, however, in the words of the current Bishop of Antwerp, Johan Bonny, conscience “was relegated to the background” as a consequence of the polarization that the Roman Catholic Church suffered in the aftermath of Humanae Vitae, coming on the heels of the Second Vatican Council. This paper examines 1) the account of conscience put forth in Gaudium et Spes and the role that this account plays within the document as a whole; 2) the travails of conscience since Humanae Vitae, both within Roman Catholic circles and in contemporary philosophy; 3) the credibility of the document’s account fifty years after its promulgation, which is to say whether its understanding of the provenance, formation, and authority of conscience can withstand critical scrutiny in a contemporary setting; and finally 4) what importance some such account has for Church teaching and life. Session 4 (two presentations) Faith Engaging Cultures, Room 210 – 214 (1) Damian M. Costello, Ph.D. University of Dayton (currently an independent scholar living on the Navajo Reservation) “‘My Little Son the Holy Mountain Called Me:’ Reading Gaudium et Spes in the Navajo Nation” This paper examines the concept of creation, specifically land, in Gaudium et Spes from the perspective of Navajo tradition and the history of Catholic missions on the reservation. The document declares unequivocally that the created order is good as it is “created and sustained by its Maker’s love” (2). As in most orthodox Catholic theology, however, creation plays a rather minor role in Gaudium et Spes: as the setting for humanity’s agency, a resource to be utilized, or an object to be contemplated. Land, in other words, has little or no moral agency in the drama of salvation history. Creation’s relatively passive role in Catholic theology stands in stark contrast to many indigenous traditions. This paper will explore the relational link between land and humanity in Navajo tradition and ask if an analogous relationship between humanity and the created order is possible in Catholic theology. Can land have moral agency in a Catholic setting without becoming idolatry? Can the ceremonial relationship between particular land be fostered through Catholic liturgical traditions? What effect would a transformation in the Catholic understanding of land have on Catholic Social Tradition? How would a transformation improve evangelization and church life among indigenous peoples? 12 (2) Peter Jeffery, Ph.D. Michael P. Grace II Professor of Medieval Studies Associate Director of Sacred Music Concurrent Professor of Theology Concurrent Professor of Anthropology University of Notre Dame The Right to Culture: Three developments since the Council that are leaving the Church behind Gaudium et Spes was the first Roman Catholic document to assert that there is a “right to culture,” though the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) had already done so. In the fifty years since, however, theological discussion of culture and inculturation has rarely been framed as a matter of human rights. At the same time, theologians and the Church have been largely absent from three major worldwide developments that have happened in the years since the Council: 1. The formation of a large body of international law regarding the right to culture. 2. A massive academic discussion within the social sciences as to the nature and definition of culture. 3. In biology and zoology, the identification of "cultures"--discrete communities defined by shared, learned behavior--within many animal species. Each of these developments poses numerous questions that challenge Christian understandings of human nature and community. It is long overdue for Catholic voices to join the three conversations. 3:30 pm Break 5:15 pm Daily Mass – Basilica of the Sacred Heart Bishop Ricardo Ramìrez, Bishop Emeritus of the Diocese of Las Cruces, New Mexico Celebrant & Homilist (Annual Mass in honor of Archbishop Oscar Romero, sponsored by LANACC) 6:00 pm Dinner – Dining Room 7:30 pm Keynote Address – Auditorium “Visions of the Good Life, Pluralism, and Commitment” Miroslav Volf, Ph.D. Henry B. Wright Professor of Systematic Theology, and Founding Director, Yale Center for Faith & Culture, Yale University Introduction by Todd Whitmore, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Theology and CoDirector of the Catholic Social Tradition Minor, University of Notre Dame 13 Tuesday, March 24, 2015 8:00 am Continental Breakfast – Lobby 8:30 am Social Issues Colloquium III: Four Concurrent Sessions Session 1 (3 presentations) Response to Marginal Communities, Room 100 – 104 (1) Matthew J. Bagot, Ph.D. Associate Professor Department of Theology Spring Hill College A bruised, hurting, and dirty Church out on the streets: the symmetry of Evangelii Gaudium and Gaudium et Spes What is the legacy of Gaudium et Spes (“Joy and Hope”)? More specifically, what has been its impact on recent Church teaching? In this paper, I will explore certain common themes in Gaudium et Spes (“Joy and Hope”) and Pope Francis’ recent Exhortation, Evagelii Gaudium (“The Joy of the Gospel”): a distinctive vision of self-fulfillment; a grounding of this vision in the Trinity; a focus on the work of the laity; reflection on the economy and, in particular, property; and, finally, the need for dialogue and cooperation in fostering peace. I will argue that there is a symmetry to the two documents, which reflects their mutual place in the tradition of Catholic Social Teaching. (2) Sister Larraine Lauter OSU, M.T.S. (Ursuline Sisters of Mount Saint Joseph) St. Meinrad School of Theology Executive Director of Water With Blessings Gaudium et Spes et Holy Charity: Wells of Joyful Hope in Marginal Communities Water With Blessings is an organization that carries out its mission of “clean water for God’s thirsty children” through a program model that draws deeply upon the principles of Catholic Social Teaching. Water With Blessings will serve to illustrate an intentional and creative application of CST as expressed in Gaudium et Spes. Particular attention will be given to real examples of women and men serving as agents of transformation in their own communities, as opposed to mission models that presume the necessary intervention of messiahs from outside the culture. (3) Joseph Weber Catholic Relief Services Head of Office, Bamiyan, Afghanistan Joy and Hope in Afghanistan’s Central Highlands “How the Church’s Social Tradition Informs and Can Be Informed By the Experience of Working with Families in a Remote Corner of the World” For many Catholics in the United States, it seems counter-intuitive that Catholic Relief Services (CRS), an agency operated by the USCCB, would be working side by side with poor and marginalized Muslim families in rural-Afghanistan. Many such families struggle to eek out a living from small plots of arable land, to grow enough food or find fuel for cooking and heating, or to provide their children with formal education. For these families, CRS education and livelihoods programming offers a rare ray of 14 hope. Stories of these programs provide concrete examples of how documents like Gaudium et Spes continue to shape the interaction between the Church and today’s world. Reflecting on those experiences offers insights to guide the Church going forward. Session 2 (three presentations) Catholic Business, Catholic Workplace, Room 112 – 114 (1) Matthew A. Shadle, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Theology and Religious Studies Marymount University Secularity or Theological Vocation?: Economic Activity in Gaudium et Spes and Beyond Part I of Gaudium et Spes, and in particular its last two chapters, on “Human Activity Throughout the World” and “the Role of the Church in the Modern World” respectively, puts forward a dramatic tension between the secularity of the economy, as one important dimension of “the world,” and the deeply theological vocation of humankind to transform the world through labor, a tension left unresolved in the document and that continues to be worked out in the Catholic Church’s theological reflection and social activism today. This paper will explore this tension between the secularity of economic activity and that activity’s theological dimension, and also examine how Gaudium et Spes’s teaching both affirmed and challenged the initiatives of Catholic groups devoted to social activism in the economic sphere at the time of the council, such as Catholic Action and labor unions. It will also consider how this tension has played out in the decades since the council, concluding with how the teachings of Gaudium et Spes can inform and challenge Catholic efforts to transform the economy today. (2) Henry J. Davis, Ph.D. Graduate School of Social Service Fordham University Adjuncts First: Applying Gaudium et Spes to Adjunct Wage Inequality Adjunct wage inequality is not just a concern for higher education institutions but for those societies openly committed towards achieving social justice. The issue of improving financial equity for struggling adjunct instructors takes on a marked significance within the Catholic faith community where Catholic Social Teachings (CST) help guide ethical actions. In light of the 50th anniversary of Vatican II’s Gaudium et Spes, this workshop will contextually apply the Pastoral Constitution’s Economic Development section to the current U.S. adjunct situation. Prevailing themes such as human dignity in labor and serving worker needs above profits will offer participants a social template for supporting adjunct and part-time academic labor. (3) Angela Senander, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Theology, University of St. Thomas Research Fellow, Georgetown University’s Berkley Center for Religion, Peace and World Affairs Integrity and Corporate Social Responsibility: Dialogue between Gaudium et Spes and Business on Scandal At the Second Vatican Council, the Catholic bishops of the world used the biblical language of scandal to highlight three particular obstacles to faith: the scandal of inequality and unjust discrimination, the scandal of separating faith from the rest of one’s life, and the scandal of poverty (Gaudium et Spes #29, 15 #43, #88). Many businesses work to eliminate unjust discrimination in the workplace through their human resource policies, and some companies respond to poverty through their corporate social responsibility practices, ranging from philanthropy to mission integration. Few would identify these policies and practices in terms of faith. In fact, many find the privatization of religion to be greater in business than in political life. This paper examines the conditions in business for dialogue about these three scandals and the need for disciples who are business leaders to address these obstacles both within and beyond their organizations. Session 3 (2 presentations) Women’s Issues, Room 202 (1) Stefanus Hendrianto, S.J., Ph.D. Visiting Lecturer of Law/Adjunct Professor Political Science Santa Clara University School of Law Gaudium et Spes and The Mission of Motherhood: A Catholic Vision of Work, Pregnancy, And Women’s Equality This paper addresses two main subjects that became the concern of the Gaudium Et Spes: marriage and the family life, and, economic and social life. The thesis of this paper is that the Catholic Church advocating women equal respect and opportunity to men; however, equality in Catholic perspective must go hand in hand with the recognition of both the difference and complementarity between men and women. This paper posits that Catholic Social Thought provides a broader concern than merely protecting women against discrimination. The main concern for Catholic Social Thought is the promotion of family life and the dignity of human persons. The Gaudium et Spes proclaims that it must be the aim of every human institution to serve the common good, including corporations. Thus, there are some more urgent need for the whole labor process to be reorganized and adapted to respect the needs of working mothers to fulfill their duties as wife and mothers. Catholic Social Thought believes that the workplace must have an affirmative obligation to support families, especially female workers during their pregnancy. (2) Anna Robertson M.Div. Student School of Theology and Ministry Boston College Her Light, Life, and Freedom: Freeing the Body of Christ from the Patriarchal Imagination The text of Gaudium et Spes says that the message of the Church should bring “light, life and freedom” to the development of all people. To what extent has the message of the Church brought light, life, and freedom to women? In a paper which draws upon the work of Elizabeth Johnson and experiences of women in Latin America, I assess the ways that, on the one hand, women’s voices are systematically excluded from the narrative-telling process today and, on the other, women’s bodies are violated through overt and subtle violence. If the Church is committed to responding to the signs of the times, it must respond to the reality of violence against women and the marginalization of their stories in the world today. I argue that the Church finds itself in a crisis of imagination which impedes its ability to adequately interpret the signs of the times, especially for women. If the metaphors, symbols, and stories we use to describe reality in fact shape the way we experience reality, we must critically dismantle the vestiges of patriarchy present therein and work to reinterpret the living tradition in a way that is liberating for women. 16 Session 4 (3 presentations) Science & Technology, Room 210 – 214 (1) Lara Shamieh, Ph.D. Assistant Professor of Biology Regis University Social Justice through Science: Where Religion and Science Intersect In the world today, there are currently more living scientists than in all of history put together. The collective power of human minds working together towards the advancement of science has led to incremental advances that collectively have become central contributions to society, leading to many novel social justice issues. Science, in its purest form, is the pursuit of truth. The pursuit of truth is inherently good; however, its applications must be guided through some moral standard, namely the teachings of the Church. Gaudiem et Spes clearly states that science must be applied to the benefit of humanity under the guidance of Church teaching, or at the very least in harmony with Church teaching. (2) Patrick Flanagan, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Department Theology & Religious Studies St. John’s University (NY) Advancing Technology for Peace: Bridging the Digital Divide with an Appeal to the Common Good Since its introduction into the public square thirty years ago, the World Wide Web has transformed social communication, commerce, and politics. The Web has had “a new kind of impact on the cultural sphere and on modes of thought” on “the face of the earth” (GS 5). The resourcefulness and capabilities of this technology has served as a valuable platform for the advancement of peace as evidenced in the leveling of oppressively destructive monopolies of power, engaging different cultures in greater human interdependence, and in the realizing of more free societies in contemporary times (GS 33). While the explosive growth of information technology is often rightly celebrated as a democratic and participatory medium, connecting the global village, there is a large portion of the world’s population does not have access to the Web. Contrary to popular belief, access to the Web is not ubiquitous. The socio-economic political construction of the “digital divide” is a disruptive reality that has marginalized an already vulnerable segment of the global community, resulting in informational poverty, social exclusion, economic isolation, and political segregation. It would then well serve those beyond the richly endowed bandwidth borders to investigate the digital divide through the lens of Christian ethics and propose plausible strategies for erasing or, at best, softening, the chasm. This paper critically analyzes this reality and proposes the common good, “the sum of those conditions of social life which allow social groups and their individual members relatively thorough and ready access to their own fulfillment, today takes on an increasingly universal complexion and consequently involves rights and duties with respect to the whole human race,” as a rejoinder (GS 26). This paper presentation proceeds in three parts. First, it will demonstrate the significant positive yet critical appreciation Gaudium et Spes has for technology. Second, it will introduce readers to the digital divide, identifying critical demographic and sociological data, the underlying causes of the inequality, and various in-place practices and long-term proposals for rectifying the technological gap. Third, the paper will offer a critical assessment of this inequality from the classical perspective of the common good (GS 26, 56) paying close attention to the Web’s resourcefulness in the advancement of peace through the actualization of solidarity. Finally, the paper will explore the strengths of 17 these proposals vis-á-vis those already in place and offer concrete ways to bring access and distribution of information technology in line with the demands of solidarity. (3) Ted Nunez, Ph.D. Senior Advisor at Zen Pearls Asst. Professor of Religious Studies, Marywood University Silicon Valley Speak: Exponential Technologies and the Future of Catholic Social Thought Life is coming to imitate science fiction as exponential technologies--AI, robotics, computer networks, 3D printing, bio-engineering, etc.—disrupt business models and markets in one industry after another. Recently, Jaron Lanier and other Silicon Valley critics have drawn attention to the dark side of exponential technology’s current design patterns, applications, and ownership structures. In particular, the specter of what John Maynard Keynes called "technological unemployment" is now being taken more seriously by a growing number of economists. What is the meaning of work in a highly automated world where ultra-smart robots and 3D printers provide a thousand-and-one customized products and services? How will the market, government, and civil society deal with mass unemployment? Is a humanistic information economy even possible, and how could it be designed and created? In this session we'll consider the case for the coming end of work as we've known it, review old and new policy proposals for managing the transition to a post-work society, and reflect on the implications of these questions for the future direction of Catholic social thought. 10:00 am Keynote Panel on Living Joy & Hope in the Church – Auditorium “Pope Francis and the Legacy of Gaudium et Spes” R. Scott Appleby Marilyn Keough Dean of the University of Keough School of Global Affairs University of Notre Dame “The Joy and Hope of Philanthropy” Alexia Kelley President & CEO of FADICA (Foundations and Donors Interested in Catholic Activities) “Gaudium et Spes, Medellín, and Puebla in the Witness of Archbishop Oscar Romero” Bishop Ricardo Ramìrez Bishop Emeritus, Diocese of Las Cruces, New Mexico Introduction by Bill Purcell, M.Div., Associate Director of Catholic Social Tradition, Center for Social Concerns and Co-Director of the Catholic Social Tradition Minor, University of Notre Dame 11:15 am Break 18 11:30 am Social Issues Colloquium IV: Four Concurrent Sessions Session 1 (two presentations) Latin American Context, Room 100 – 104 (1) Thomas M. Kelly, Ph.D. Professor of Systematic Theology Creighton University From Gaudium et Spes to Medellín: Justice, Dynamism and a Preferential Option for the Poor Perhaps nowhere else has the Vatican II document Gaudium et Spes been appropriated more radically and completely than by the Catholic Church of Latin America. The gathering of bishops at Medellín, Colombia in 1968 and the documents produced there represent a significant appropriation of the new possibilities opened up by Gaudium et Spes. The new emphasis on “justice” allowed the Church to leave older “charity” approaches aside and the “dynamism” embodied by social doctrinal change would allow this episcopal body to affirm a preferential option for the poor that was both multifaceted and revolutionary. A careful consideration of documents from the Medellín Conference reveal the strong influence of Gaudium et Spes, especially in how the Latin American Church moved beyond the traditional societas perfectas model of church/state relations indicative of past centuries with its new commitment to transforming the world. This presentation will highlight certain texts of Gaudium et Spes and their influence upon the Medellín documents. (2) Terence McGoldrick, STD (Fribourg, Switzerland) Assistant Professor of Theology Providence College The CST Evaluation of Water as A Human Right in Bolivia, its Mother Earth Laws and the Church’s role in Social Transformation Bolivia’s natural gas and water wars are considered the nadir of neoliberalism in Latin America. The Episcopal Conference of Bolivia (CEB), living in the midst of these important social justice issues have responded with three CST applications to the questions of water as a human right, property rights and environmental stewardship. The sacred connection between Pachamama and its people that inspired Bolivia’s recent laws on the rights of mother earth, inscribed in its new constitution, are inseparable from these movements. As Bolivians struggle to secure their native identities and preserve a balance with Pachamama in the face of globalization, the CEB provides a case study of the development of CST as well as the local Church’s part in decades of grass roots activism toward social transformation in Bolivia. Session 2 (2 presentations) Solidarity, Room 112 – 114 (1) Rachel Novick, Ph.D. Director of the Minor in Sustainability University of Notre Dame Teaching Climate Change with Hope and Joy Those of us who teach about climate change to today’s generation of college students are faced with an enormous challenge: we know it is critical that they be well-informed, but the more we teach them, the 19 higher grows the mountain of seemingly insurmountable challenges and the greater the opportunity for despair. If one is to teach about climate change, it is a great gift to teach it at a Catholic university because we can draw on the strength of Catholic Social Teaching in addressing injustice while finding inner peace. Gaudium et Spes, I would argue, is even more relevant today than it was when it was published, and in no area more so than that of climate change. The struggle for the common good, across nations and across the gulf between rich and poor, has become a struggle for the survival of humanity. I will explore approaches and methodologies for teaching climate change in a Catholic context that embody the teachings of Gaudium et Spes and thereby strengthen students’ abilities to face the future with honesty, strength, and hope in their own capacity to contribute to the common good. (2) Vincent J. Miller, Ph.D. Gudorf Chair in Catholic Theology and Culture Department of Religious Studies University of Dayton Solidarity Amidst Structures of Indifference This paper will seek to continue Gaudium et Spes’ imperative to scrutinize the “signs of the times” by analyzing the particular nature of the structures of contemporary everyday life in order to evaluate how they enable and/or prevent the exercise of solidarity and the common good. It will argue that we live in an “architecture of individualism” in which everyday life disciplines us as isolated individuals unaware of our interconnections and unable to imagine how to help one another. If it is these structures which discipline us as individuals, then preaching against individualism and selfishness will miss the mark. What is needed are alternative places structured not by individualism but by the communion to which Christianity believes we are called. The paper will conclude with a consideration of how parishes both fail and succeed to provide alternate spaces for the experience and practice of solidarity on both the local and global level. Session 3 (2 presentations) Challenges & New Models: Critique & Suggestion, Room 202 (1) Anna Patricia Blackman Ph.D. Candidate Centre for Catholic Studies Durham University Solidarity: A Neoliberal Possibility? This paper will question whether it is possible to act outside the structures of neoliberalism to join in real and complete solidarity with the oppressed, both in our own countries and globally. The paper will primarily focus on whether Catholic social teaching can ever really be authentically and faithfully applied in Western neoliberal developed societies or whether these very structures jeopardise or even disable this project as argued in current critiques, such as those of Stanley Hauerwas and the Radical Orthodoxy movement. Indeed, in this context is the principle diminished simply to a rhetorical nicety? This paper will therefore question whether the Church’s teaching has gone far enough in condemning the neoliberal system. In turn it will question whether it is ever possible to find a space outside of the pervading structures of neoliberalism and imperialism in which to work to act in true solidarity with the globally oppressed and exploited, or if there is only so far that solidarity can ever stretch. This paper will seek to address this issue by tracing the articulation and development of the principle of solidarity in Church teaching, going on to question how effectively it has been articulated and applied. In order to make concrete and further this 20 analysis, the paper will present a case-study explaining how the London Catholic worker movement has drawn upon Church teaching in order to carry out their work with asylum seekers and refugees. Whilst the London Catholic workers live in community with these persons, who they see and treat as their guests, this paper will analyse the practical problems that appear and the inevitable fundamental division between the guests and the workers themselves. By trying to show how the movement attempts to overcome these practical difficulties in applying solidarity, this paper will hope to offer a reflection on the possible solutions, referencing back to the official Church teaching. (2) James Martin Carr, BA, MA, BSc (Pharm) Doctoral Student University of Bristol (England) Catholic political engagement in post-modern democracy: naïve incompetence or evangelical witness? Reviewing the debate surrounding same-sex marriage in the United Kingdom in 2012/2013, it would appear that Catholic citizens, drawing inspiration from Gaudium et Spes, should have (a) respectfully engaged in this important political debate, and (b) striven to articulate the Pastoral Constitution’s vision of marriage and family in a manner comprehensible and edifying to all of society. Utilizing the communications theory concepts of agenda-setting and framing, I will contrast, on the one hand, the actual contributions of a lay Catholic group, Catholic Voices, and of the English and Welsh Catholic bishops to this debate with, on the other, the manner in which these contributions were framed by the mainstream British press. I will argue that, notwithstanding a sincere effort on the part of these Catholics to confine themselves to arguments based on reason and prudential public policy, opponents and supposedly impartial media consistently portrayed them as intolerant bigots whose true reasons for opposing same-sex marriage were homophobia and intolerance. I will conclude by arguing that some of the optimism evinced in Gaudium et Spes may be misplaced in the context of a radically secular democracy in the early 21st century which, in Europe at least, betrays subtle but discernible totalitarian impulses. Session 4 (2 presentations) Justice, Liturgy and Scripture, Room 210 – 214 (1) Francis X. Klose, D.Litt. Religious Studies Cabrini College Singing a New Song: Promoting the Vision of Peace and Justice in Gaudium et Spes Through Music in the Liturgy Reflecting upon Gaudium et Spes, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops in Sing to the Lord writes, "The Paschal hymn, of course, does not cease when a liturgical celebration ends. Christ, whose praises we have sung, remains with us and leads us through church doors to the whole world, with its joys and hopes, griefs and anxieties" (3). The liturgical music minister then has a new role when Gaudium et Spes is applied: to lead the assembly's song. Superficially, the music minister physically is the leader as an assembly takes on singing. But, the song must continue after the congregation leaves the church. Therefore, carefully selected hymnody in the liturgy can forward the promotion of peace and justice in a pluralistic world. 21 (2) Clemens Sedmak, Ph.D. FD Maurice Professor of Moral and Social Theology Department of Theology and Religious Studies King’s College London Lazarus in the Parish: Reflections on Gaudium et Spes 27 GS 27 exhorts the people of good will to consider the neighbor “without exception as another self”, taking into account the means necessary to living with dignity, “so as not to imitate the rich man who had no concern for the poor man Lazarus”. What does this mean in a socially competitive, institutionally complicated, and globalized world? The talk compares the concern with a “Church of the Poor” with the concept of therapeutic communities and argues that “Gaudium et Spes” calls for a therapeutic approach towards the world (cf. e.g. GS 11,12, 21, 26) very much in line with Pope Francis’ well known image of the Church as a “field hospital” (see also Evangelii Gaudium 67,69,77). 12:45 pm Lunch (on your own) 2:00 pm Workshops II: Two Concurrent Sessions (1) Social Action with Justice Partners – Auditorium Presentation and discussion of college-social ministry partnerships Catholic Charities USA and Catholic Relief Services (2) Abolition of Capital Punishment: Strategies for Developing a State Commission Room: 100 – 104 This session will offer participants an opportunity to learn particular strategies for developing a state commission to examine abolition of the death penalty. Based on her work in the state of Maryland and elsewhere, Vicki Schieber will present best practices for consideration and discussion. Presenter: Vicki Schieber Catholics Mobilizing Against the Death Penalty 3:15 pm Break 4:00 pm Keynote Address – Auditorium “Impact of Gaudium et Spes on the Church in Southern Africa” Cardinal Wilfrid Napier, O.F.M. Durban, South Africa Introduction by Rev. Paul V. Kollman, C.S.C. The Leo and Arlene Hawk Executive Director of the Center for Social Concerns, Associate Professor of Theology, University of Notre Dame 5:30 pm Wrap-Up and Conclusion – Auditorium 22
© Copyright 2024