RHYBUDD O GYFARFOD / NOTICE OF MEETING Cyfarfod : Awdurdod Parc Cenedlaethol Eryri Snowdonia National Park Authority Emyr Williams Prif Weithredwr Awdurdod Parc Cenedlaethol Eryri Penrhyndeudraeth Gwynedd LL48 6LF Ffôn/Phone (01766) 770274 E.bost/E.mail : [email protected] Emyr Williams Chief Executive Snowdonia National Park Authority Penrhyndeudraeth Gwynedd LL48 6LF Ffacs/Fax (01766)771211 Gwefan/Website: www.eryri-npa.gov.uk Pwyllgor Cynllunio a Mynediad Dyddiad: Dydd Mercher 4 Mawrth, 2015 Amser 10.00 y.b. Man Cyfarfod: Plas Tan y Bwlch, Maentwrog. Meeting: Planning and Access Committee Date: Wednesday 4 March, 2015 Time: 10.00 a.m. Location: Plas Tan y Bwlch, Maentwrog. Aelodau wedi’u penodi gan Gyngor Gwynedd Members appointed by Gwynedd Council Y Cynghorydd / Councillor: Elwyn Edwards, Thomas G. Ellis, Alwyn Gruffydd, Sion Wyn Jones, I. Dilwyn Lloyd, E. Caerwyn Roberts OBE., JP., John Pughe Roberts, Dyfrig Siencyn, Eurig Wyn; Aelodau wedi’u penodi gan Gyngor Bwrdeistref Sirol Conwy Members appointed by Conwy County Borough Council Y Cynghorwyr / Councillors : John A. MacLennan, Elizabeth Roberts, Joan Vaughan; Aelodau wedi’u penodi gan Llywodraeth Cymru Members appointed by The Welsh Government Dr. Iolo ap Gwynn, Mrs. M. June Jones, Mrs. Marian W. Jones, Mr. David L. Roberts, Mr. Ceri Stradling, Mr Owain Wyn. AGENDA 1. Apologies for absence and Chairman’s Announcements To receive any apologies for absence and Chairman’s announcements. 2. Declaration of Interest To receive any declaration of interest by any members or officers in respect of any item of business. 3. Minutes The Chairman shall propose that the minutes of the meeting of this Committee held on 21 January, 2015 be signed as a true record (copy herewith) and to receive matters arising, for information. 4. Charging for Pre-Application Advice – 6 Month Review To submit a report by the Head of Development Management and Compliance. (Copy herewith) 5. Inspection Panel Report To submit the report of the Southern Area Inspection Panel held on 28 January, 2015 together with a report by the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage on the application. (Copy herewith) 6. Reports by the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage To submit reports by the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage on applications received. (Copies herewith) 7. Update Reports To submit update reports, for information. (Copies herewith) 8. Delegated Decisions To submit the list of applications which have been determined in accordance with delegated authority, for information. (Copy herewith) ITEM NO. 3 SNOWDONIA NATIONAL PARK PLANNING AND ACCESS COMMITTEE WEDNESDAY 21st JANUARY, 2015 Councillor Elwyn Edwards (Gwynedd) (Chairman) PRESENT: Members appointed by Gwynedd Council Councillors Thomas G. Ellis, Alwyn Gruffydd, Sion W. Jones, John Pughe Roberts, E. Caerwyn Roberts, Eurig Wyn; Members appointed by Conwy County Borough Council Councillors John MacLennan, Joan Vaughan; Members appointed by the Welsh Government Dr. Iolo ap Gwynn, Mrs. Marian W. Jones, Mr. David L. Roberts; Officers Mr. G.I. Jones, Mr. J. Cawley, Mr. A. Lloyd, Mr. I. Evans, Mr. R.H. Roberts, Mrs. J. Jones, Mrs. A. Gaffey. 1. Apologies Councillors I. Dilwyn Lloyd, Elizabeth Roberts, Dyfrig Siencyn; Mrs. M. June Jones, Mr. Ceri Stradling, Mr. Owain Wyn. 2. Declaration of Interest No declarations of Personal Interests were made in respect of any item. 3. Minutes The minutes of the Planning and Access Committee meeting held on the 10th December, 2014 were accepted and the Chairman signed them as a true record. 4. Decreasing the number of Planning & Access Committee Meetings Submitted – A report by the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage to discuss and to seek Member support for reducing the number of Planning and Access Committee meetings from 10 to 8 per annum. Reported – The Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage presented the report and background. He advised that whilst the planning applications presented to Committee would take slightly longer to process, possibly by a week or two, there would be an overall improvement in performance, and for the majority of applicants a more efficient service. Members considered the report in detail and made the following observations:a slightly longer cycle will work in favour of some Community Councils who do not meet on a monthly basis. studies produced for the Welsh Government recommends officer delegation rates of 90%. - - - members would still have a right to “call in” applications to the Committee for determination with valid reasons for doing so. Officers agreed to look at the effectiveness of the “call in” provision and present a report to members in due course. Members noted concerns that reducing the number of committees would weaken the Authority’s case for continuing with the planning function and make it more difficult for Members to deliver National Park purposes if no longer involved in making planning decisions. The Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage advised that he did not believe that this would affect any future decisions taken by the Welsh Government. members were agreed that the number of planning applications presented to committee were greatly reduced. the other two Welsh National Parks operate this system with positive feedback. the quality of the decision is more important than speed. to trial the reduction for a period of 12 months to measure its effectiveness. to present the following recommendations to the Authority:1. to approve the reduction in the number of Planning and Access Committee meetings from 10 to 8 per annum for a trial period of 12 months. 2. to report on the impact of the proposal on the performance of the service at the end of the 12 month trial period. RESOLVED to note the report and await a further report to the Authority on 4th February 2015. 5. Northern Area Inspection Panel Submitted – The report of the Northern Area Inspection Panel held on 19th December, 2014. NP4/12/130D Retention of existing shelter for agricultural use in its current location on a permanent basis, land adjoining Tan yr Onnen, Rowen, Conwy. Reported - Further letter from Agent and letter from neighbour maintaining objections reported. Public Speaking Jan Tyrer, the Agent, addressed the Planning and Access Committee and asked Members to consider the following: the agent emphasised that the applicant had consulted with, and followed the advice of SNPA officers. the report refers in error to the size of the site and use of the land. the shelter is located on the lowest and flattest part of the field. To relocate 15m higher up the field would be impractical, as would changing its orientation, with prevailing wind issues and the need for further excavation. the shelter is set back by over 2m from the fence and the structure is substantially screened by it, with only the roof visible from Cynefin. the shelter is not unduly prominent in the landscape and as such accords with Development Policy 1 of the Eryri Local Development Plan. the recommended refusal is unjustified and unsubstantiated. RESOLVED to authorise the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage to grant permission. 6. Reports by the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage Submitted – Reports by the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage on planning applications and compliance matters. Please see the Schedule of Planning Decisions attached. 7. Update Reports Submitted – Update reports by the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage on planning applications and compliance matters. Please see the Schedule of Planning Decisions attached. 8. Delegated Decisions Submitted and Received – List of applications determined in accordance with delegated authority. RESOLVED to note the report. 9. Planning Appeal Submitted and Received – copy of the following appeal decision:Appeal by Mr. Ian Alfred Bryan Patrick against a Listed Building Enforcement Notice issued by the Authority for the contravention of listed building control for, without consent, the construction of a single storey conservatory extension to the south facing elevation of Gelli Grin, Maentwrog, Gwynedd. LL41 4HY (Appeal dismissed) The meeting ended at 11.05 a.m. SCHEDULE OF PLANNING DECISIONS – 21st JANUARY, 2015 Item No. 1. NP5/58/L2B – Construction of porch, Ger y Neuadd, Dyffryn Ardudwy. RESOLVED to authorise the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage to grant permission subject to appropriate conditions. 2. NP5/59/511B – Amended details to site layout and dwelling types to that approved under planning consent NP5/59/511A, Land at rear Penrhiw, Llan Ffestiniog. RESOLVED to refuse permission in accordance with recommendation. 2. NP5/59/511D – Change of use from 1 dwelling to 2 dwellings and construction of 2 side extensions, 1 rear extension and detached garage, Plot 4, Land at Penrhiw, Llan Ffestiniog. RESOLVED to refuse permission in accordance with recommendation. 4. NP5/75/126C – Use of land for siting of 10 tents and 4 bell tents together with compost toilet, Cefn Crib, Pennal. Reported – Case Officer advised that the siting of 10 tents was no longer part of the application. Letter of support from FUW reported. Observations from fire officer awaited. RESOLVED – Site Inspection. Update Reports (1) Summary of Compliance Cases – For Information RESOLVED to note the report. (2) Planning, Enforcement Notice and Certificates of Lawful Use Appeals submitted and awaiting decision – For Information RESOLVED to note the report. (3) Section 106 Agreements – For Information RESOLVED to note the report. (4) Outstanding Applications where more than 13 weeks have elapsed – For Information RESOLVED to note the report. (5) Policy Section Report on Consultations Received – For Information RESOLVED to note the report. ITEM NO. 4 MEETING Planning and Access Committee DATE 4 March 2015 TITLE CHARGING FOR PRE-APPLICATION ADVICE – 6 MONTH REVIEW REPORT BY Head of Development Management and Compliance PURPOSE To review the charging of a fee for pre-planning application advice for site visits and legal agreements 1. 1.1 Introduction Members will recall that the charging for pre-application site visits and for preparing legal agreements was endorsed by the Performance and Recourses Committee in July 2014 and came into effect on the 1st September 2014. 1.2 One of the recommendations endorsed by the Performance and Recourses Committee was:- 1.3 That the scheme be subject to an 18 month trial basis, with a progress review submitted to Members every 6 months. 2. 2.1 Pre-Application Planning Advice service It has long been established that providing quality pre-application advice is an important part of the work of Development Management. Providing timely quality preapplication advice greatly assists officers in determining applications well within the statutory period. 3. 3.1 Current pre-application advice Free pre-application advice is provided for all types of enquiries other than site visits. Therefore officers provide prospective planning applicants with the following service for free: a) b) c) d) Meetings at HQ, Penrhyndeudraeth Written correspondence (a template form for prospective applicants has been prepared to help formalise current practice) Telephone calls – whilst advice will be given for free over the phone, officers will encourage prospective applicants to use the standard form referred to in (b) above; Planning surgeries – the advice currently provided in the freely available planning surgeries will continue to be provided free of charge. Surgeries are now occasionally held at agricultural marts in Bryncir, Dolgellau and Llanrwst. 4. 4.1 How much of a fee is charged? A flat fee of £50 + VAT = £60 is charged to any prospective applicants wishing an officer to visit their site – this will be irrespective of location of the proposed development or the type of development proposed. 4.2 Certain groups or classes of developments are exempt from the fee for preapplication site visits. These are: a) Disabled individuals b) Developments related to Listed Building or Conservation Area Consent c) Community Groups 5.0 5.1 Income The target income during the current financial year is £2500 for pre-application site visits. The income received by mid February is £750. Whilst the target income is lower than predicted this can be attributed that the vast majority of applications that the Authority receive are Householder applications. Pre app advice on householder applications can be provided normally without the need for a site visit. Also there have been improvements both to the Authority’s website and Planning Portal with more information being provided on planning requirements. 5.2 The target income for Legal agreements is also £2500. As yet no income has been received. When the target income was decided this was based on the number of legal agreements over the last 5 years. During the previous financial year the Authority prepared 12 legal agreements. During the current financial there have not been any new applications which would be subject to a legal agreement. The absence of any legal agreement is unusual and could be for a variety of factors, not least the economic downturn. 6.0 6.1 6 Month review These charges were introduced on the 1st September 2014 and prior to this, agents who submit applications were informed of the new process and given guidance on how to request a pre –application site visit. 6.2 Full details are included on the Authority’s recently re-vamped website. 6.3 New internal procedures were introduced including a new module on the Swift planning application processing system, which records all pre-application advice enquiries. 6.4 Since 1st September 122 pre-application enquiries have been received of which 14 were pre-application site visits. 6.5 It is apparent that since the introduction of the charge officers spend more time in the office. It is considered that this more efficient way of working has led to improved performance. This is evident in the from performance statistics in that during the period April 2013 to March 2014 63% of all applications was determined within the statutory 8 weeks. The periods April 2014 to min February 2015 73% of all applications were determined in 8 weeks. 6.6 Feedback from agents and individual who have received a pre-application site visit has been positive. 7. 7.1 Conclusions The introduction of pre-application charging has been widely publisised and accepted by our customers. Our customers accept that changes have to be made at a time of declining budgets and resources. 7.2 Agents acknowledged the need to introduce such changes and value the preapplication service that the Authority provides. 7.3 There are adequate procedures in place to ensure that all pre-application enquiries are recorded and responded to within the agreed timescales. 7.4 The formalisation of the pre-app process has improved the service in that there is better consistency in responses. Pre-application enquiries are discussed every week during officer’s meeting. 7.5 The quality of paid pre-application site visit has improved as a formal written response is sent following such visits. 7.6 There are more enquiries with regards to Deed of release from legal agreements and with the improved economic situation is likely that applications will be submitted for housing, thus generating income. 8. Recommendation (i) To continue the charging of a £60 fee for each pre-application site visit and £300 for Legal agreements and deed of release. (ii) To report a progress review to Members every 6 months. SNOWDONIA NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY SOUTHERN AREA INSPECTION PANEL, 28th JANUARY 2015 NP5/75/126C – USE OF LAND FOR SITING OF 4 BELL TENTS TOGETHER WITH COMPOST TOILET, CEFN CRIB, PENNAL. PRESENT Councillor E. Edwards, T.G. Ellis, E.C. Roberts, J.P. Roberts, Dr. Iolo ap Gwynn, Mr. D.L. Roberts. APOLOGIES Councillor D. Siencyn, Mrs M.W. Jones, Mr. C. Stradling. REPORTED - Details of application. - Planning history (permission for 42 static caravans and 18 touring caravans). - No planning permission for camping but applicant enjoyed Permitted Development Rights for camping for 28 days in any one year. - Letter of objection. - Letter in support (FUW). - Application had been amended to omit 10 tents on exposed part of site. - Officers consider proposal was contrary to policy 23 of the Eryri Local Development Plan which states that within the National Park no new touring or camping sites will be permitted. - Should Committee consider that proposal forms part of an extension to existing touring caravan and camping site the proposal requires the following criteria to be satisfied: “The proposal will significantly improve the internal landscaping of a site and increase the quality of the existing facilities, or develop new high quality facilities.” - Community Council support. - Fire Officers consulted. DISCUSSED - Panel noted the site was relatively well screened. - Concern was expressed that previous landscaping conditions had not been full implemented. - Panel noted the concern of the objector in particular to the location of compost toilet and suggest it should be resited to the eastern boundary of the site. - It was debated whether the application should be treated as an extension to existing touring site rather than a new camping site. - It was observed that a new track had been formulated and officers were requested to seek further information on this point. - The Panel considered a condition should be attached to any planning permission in respect of the colour of the bell tents (not white). - Concern was expressed over prominent siting of parking area shown on application. - Applicant should be invited to enter a legal agreement with the Authority to withdraw its permitted development rights for camping on exposed section of field. CONCLUSION - To support proposal subject to: i) resiting of compost toilet ii) condition on colour of tents iii) omit parking area from application iv) to seek internal improvements (removal of ‘PD’ rights for camping on exposed section of field). PREVIOUS REPORT Snowdonia National Park Authority – Planning & Access Committee Date: 21/01/2015 Date Application Registered: 12/11/14 Application Number: NP5/75/126C Community: Pennal Grid Reference: 268090 299282 Application Type: Full Location: Cefn Crib, Pennal. Applicant: Mrs Delwen Breese Gogarth Hall Farm Pennal Gwynedd Description: Use of land for siting of 10 tents and 4 bell tents together with compost toilet. Consultees: Pennal Community Council Responses: Support Site: Forms part of agricultural land which sits above existing touring caravan site to the east and static site to the south. Mature woodland encloses the area denoted for bell tents to the west and east. A public footpath runs along the perimeter of the caravan park to the north. Proposal: Proposal is to extend existing caravan site to incorporate 10 tents and 4 bell tents together with retrospective permission to retain compost toilet which is finished in timber. Designations: Outside Housing Development Boundary Public footpath to east of site Publicity Undertaken: Site Notice: Yes Press Notice: No Reason(s) Application Reported to Committee Scheme of Delegation: Community Council Support Neighbour Letters: Yes Planning History: Application No. Details NP5/42/73 Extension to caravan site NP5/42/288 NP5/42/288A NP5/75/126 NP5/75/126A NP5/75/126B Decision Refuse 10-01-1975 Site for 10 touring caravans and toilet block Refused 06-07-1977, and appeal dismissed Site for 10 touring caravans (Part O.S. Parcel Refused 346) 04-04-1978, but granted on appeal Change of use from touring caravan site to static Refused caravan site for 10 units 30-04-1998 Re-submission of application for change of use Refused from touring caravan site to site for 10 static 26-04-1999 caravans Change of use of land to extend touring caravan Refused site from 10 units to 18 units 11-Jan-2010 Relevant Planning Policies – Eryri Local Development Plan: Policy No. Policy 1 General Development Principles 2 Development and Landscape 23 Touring and Camping Site I Tourism Assessment: Planning permission presently exists for 42 static caravans which abuts the proposed site to the south and 18 touring caravans which are located to the entrance road to the east. The applicant seeks to utilize an elevated section of land immediately above the touring site to provide ten camping pitches and 4 bell tents. Applicant states land has been used informally for camping in the past. It should be noted the land can be operated for camping for 28 days in any one year without the requirement of planning permission (several hook up points have been created on site). Complaints were received that the bell tents had been erected which exceeded the 28 days rule and the applicant was informed accordingly. At time of site visit bell tents had been removed but compost toilet remained in situ together with gravelled access track (which applicant states has always been in place but recently resurfaced). Site for the erection of 10 tents is prominent from adjacent A493 road and also from the nearby footpath. The parking area also shown for bell tents would again be clearly visible from public vantage point. The bell tents location, however, would be relatively well screened when trees are in leaf. Policy 23 – Touring and Camping Sites of the Eryri Local Development Plan states that within the National Park no new touring or camping sites will be permitted. Furthermore it states that extending or upgrading of existing touring caravan and camping sites will be permitted providing the following criteria are satisfied: (i) “The site is already well screened from public vantage points...” (iv) “The proposal will significantly improve the internal landscaping of a site and increase the quality of the existing facilities.” The application fails all the criteria mentioned above. Notwithstanding the above policy Gwynedd Council Licensing Authority have requested further information which may require a reduction in numbers in order to comply with health and safety requirements (letter contained in Committee bundle). One letter of objection has also been received to the application (attached in Committee bundle) which mainly relates to location of compost toilet (overlooking) and noise coming from campsite. As the application is being recommended for refusal, enforcement action would be required to remove the toilet block. Background Papers in Document Bundle No.1: Yes RECOMMENDATION: To refuse for the following reason: 1. The proposal is contrary to Policy 23 of the Eryri Local Development Plan which states that within the National Park no new touring or camping sites will be permitted. Furthermore the proposal is also contrary to points (i) and (iv) of the above mentioned policy which seeks to ensure the site is already well screened from public vantage points and the proposal will significantly improve the internal landscaping of a site and increase the quality of the existing facilities. Rhif Eitem Cyfeirnod / / Item No. Reference No. 1 NP4/32/335 2 NP5/61/333B 3 NP5/61/560B 4 NP5/67/196A Disgrifiad / Description. Cais llawn i adeiladu 8 ty, Tir ger Bryn Derw, Ffordd Crafnant, Trefriw / Full application for construction of 8 dwellings, Land adjacent to Bryn Derw, Crafnant Road, Trefriw. Creu llecyn parcio oddi ar y stryd, Seasons & Reasons, Stryd Fawr, Harlech / Formation of off road parking area, Seasons & Reasons, High Street, Harlech. Adeiladu ty ar wahan (Dyluniad diwgiedig), Tir rhwng Trem Arfor & Hiraethog, Stryd Fawr, Harlech / Construction of detached dwelling (Revised design), Land between Trem Arfor and Hiraethog, High Street, Harlech. Gosod twrbin gwynt 5kw 17.75m i'r brig, Ty Mawr Farm, Bryncrug / Installation of 5kw wind turbine 17.75m to tip, Ty Mawr Farm, Bryncrug. Swyddog Achos / Case Officer Mr Richard Thomas Mr Richard Thomas Mr Richard Thomas Mr Huw Roberts Snowdonia National Park Authority – Planning & Access Committee Date: 04/03/2015 Date Application Registered: 14/11/14 Application Number: NP4/32/335A Community: Trefriw Grid Reference: 277746 363154 Application Type: Full Location: Land adjacent to Bryn Derw, Crafnant Road, Trefriw. Applicant: Mr. John Beardsell Tesni Properties Ltd. 4 Linden House Mold Business Park Wrexham Road Mold Flintshire Description: Full application for construction of 8 dwellings. Consultees: Trefriw Community Council Conwy - Highways Responses: Objection No objection, further details required No observations No objections, conditions suggested No objection No observations Conwy - Planning Dwr Cymru Natural Resources Wales Fire and Rescue Service Site: Land adjacent Bryn Derw, Crafnant Road, Trefriw. Proposal: Erection of 8 dwellings (4 affordable/local occupancy dwellings, 4 market dwellings). Designations: Within housing development boundary Allocated for housing development Publicity Undertaken: Site Notice: Yes Press Notice: No Neighbour Letters: Yes Reason(s) Application Reported to Committee: Scheme of Delegation At the request of the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage and the level of local interest. Planning History: Application No. Details NP4/32/335 Erection of 12 dwellings NP4/32/15 NP16/72/R36 NP16/72/36 Erection of 6 dwellings Renewal of outline permission Outline application for residential development Decision Refused 2014, Appeal dismissed Refused 1975 Approved 1975 Approved 1972 Relevant Planning Policies: Eryri Local Development Plan 2011 Policy No B 1 Ch D 2 6 G 18 Policy Major development General development principles Social and physical infrastructure in new developments Natural environment Development and the landscape Sustainable design and materials Housing Welsh language and the social and cultural fabric of communities National Policies Policy Planning Policy Wales (Edition 7) Relevant Paragraph Background: The site subject to this planning application was identified by this Authority as a reserve housing site during the Eryri Local Development Plan Examination in Public. The Authority estimated a total site capacity of 8 units (4 open market and 4 affordable). This reserve site was subject to public consultation between 8 December 2010 and 27 January 2011. The consultation period was advertised through a notice in the local papers and on the Authority’s website and the Community Council was consulted directly. Following that period of consultation and examination in public the Inspector concluded, in the report into the inquiry, that the site be included as a housing allocation. The Eryri Local Development Plan was adopted in July 2011. The Conwy Rural Housing Enabler carried out a local housing need assessment in Trefriw in June 2009 and 18 individuals were identified as being in housing need. As of June 2013, 20 individuals are on Cartrefi Conwy’s housing register, 4 are on Tai Clwyd’s housing register and 5 are on the First Steps register. In line with the Authority estimate of the site capacity this application proposes the erection of 8 dwellings, 4 affordable/local occupancy and 4 market houses. If permission is forthcoming from this Authority for this development it will be subject to a section 106 agreement securing the occupation of the affordable dwellings to those satisfying ‘local persons’ criteria and are in need of housing. Consultations: Full consultation on the application has been undertaken with site notices and individual letters to local addresses. The community council has been consulted as have other statutory consultees. Statutory Consultees: Conwy Highways Authority: No objections raised subject to conditions and submission of a construction method statement prior to any work commencing. Natural Resources Wales: No objections raised subject to conditions and to schedule tree felling at an appropriate time of the year to avoid bird breeding period. Dwr Cymru Welsh Water: No objections subject to conditions and the submission of a scheme for the comprehensive and integrated drainage of the site showing how foul water, surface water and land drainage will be dealt with. Trefriw Community Council: Objection to the scheme on the basis of: Highways and highway safety: Roads not suitable for construction traffic and subsequent use. Traffic Generation: more traffic will be generated as a result of this development. Highways around this site are single track with no pavement. There will be increased hazard to pedestrians. Public transport: Site is not located ‘in proximity to public transport routes and within easy walking and cycling distance of a number of services and facilities’. Site I located up a very steep hill making walking and cycling very difficult. Infrastructure: The main sewer is already overloaded; more houses would be an unsustainable burden. Biodiversity: Several mature trees used by birds and bats will be removed. Disabled persons access: No level access to plots 5, 6, 7 or 8. Scale of development: 3 storey market houses are out of scale with the character of the surroundings properties. Local Residents One letter generally in favour of the proposal has been received from the immediate neighbour to the site stating that the three storey design utilises the slope of the site and provides for much needed garaging below the dwelling. Reservations are expressed to the loss of a horse chestnut on the eastern boundary. Respondent has recommended a TPO for the two oak trees shown to be retained as part of the development. Forty three (43) letters of objection have been received from local residents with the following general points being made: No demand/No need Would create highway dangers and congestion Adverse impact on trees and hedges/biodiversity loss Would place pressures on sewerage/drainage systems Would result in unacceptable surface run off Adverse effect on adjacent renowned plant nursery A petition signed by 52 individuals has also been received stating general opposition to the scheme. No specific reasons given. Report: The proposed site, with an overall area of approximately 0.36 hectares (0.88 acres), is currently utilised for grazing purposes, it slopes from high ground bordering Crafnant Road down to the south where it borders the Roualeyn plant nursery, the eastern boundary is defined by an unnamed local access road and to the west is a private dwelling, Bryn Derw. There is evidence at the northern end of a site of a concrete slab which formerly had a garage to Bryn Derw sited upon it. There are a number of mature trees on the site predominantly on the eastern boundary. The proposal shows the development of 8 dwellings on the site which gives an overall density of 22 dwellings to the hectare; this would be regarded as low density. In comparison the recently approved and constructed housing association site in Penmachno was developed at a density of 30 to the hectare. As the site has been allocated for residential development in the Eryri Local Development Plan it is to be regarded as an acceptable rounding off and does not unduly extend the village into open countryside. The site was allocated in response to the requirement for additional land for residential development identified during the Eryri Local Development Plan process. In allocating the land this Authority is stating that the site is appropriate for development and will expect 50% affordable/local occupancy dwellings and 50% market housing. At the time of allocating the site it was indicated that the site should provide a minimum of 8 dwellings on a 50-50 basis. Members may recall that this site was subject to an application considered and refused by this Committee in 2013. That application proposed 12 dwellings: 6 affordable/local occupancy dwellings and 6 market dwellings. That application was refused on the basis of two reasons: 1. Overdevelopment of the site 2. Inappropriate highway access for scale of development However, in reaching these conclusions Authority Members were of the opinion that a density of development as experienced in other nearby small housing estates of Trefriw could be viewed as appropriate. With a site area of 0.88 acres the allocated 8 dwellings would achieve a density of 9 to the acre. In comparison, the small housing estate closest to this appeal site, Maes y Pandy, is approximately 1.7 acres with 12 semi-detached houses located on it giving a density of 7 to the acre. Taking this approach Members of the Planning and Access committee concluded that a development of 8 dwellings would make a pleasing transition from built up area to rural area. In addition the Members of the Planning and Access Committee were of the opinion that an increase in the number of dwellings beyond the 8 that have been allocated for the appeal site would place undue additional pressures on this unsuitable access road and would increase the potential for conflict beyond an acceptable level between road users whether on foot or in cars. The applicants appealed to the Inspectorate against that decision. The inspector concluded to dismiss the appeal agreeing with the Authority that ‘the proposal does not strike an appropriate balance between respecting the density, pattern and layout of surrounding development......I conclude that it would constitute overdevelopment of the site....’ On highway safety the Inspector did not agree with the Authority and concluded that the highway network in the vicinity of the site is already heavily used throughout the year by residents and tourist and that the ‘volume of traffic likely to be generated by 12 dwellings ...would be likely to be very small and well within normal daily fluctuations such that there would be no material impact on highway safety.’ The Proposal This application proposes the erection of 4 detached dwellings and 4 semi detached dwellings with a vehicular access shown off the residential street to the east of the site. The detached dwellings utilise the slope of the site to provide for part three storey four bedroomed dwellings with amenity space around. The semi detached dwellings are of conventional two storey design with two being of 2 bedrooms and two larger 3 bedroom dwellings. The 4 semi detached dwellings are shown to be the affordable/local occupancy dwellings and comply with the size criteria for such dwellings. There are 9 trees on the site, 2 oak, 2 horse chestnut, 2 ash, 1 cypress, 1 spruce and 1 holly. It is proposed to retain the 2 oaks as they have ecological interest. The remaining 7 trees are proposed for removal, largely to enable safe visibility splays and a pedestrian walkway to be achieved. No objection to the removal of the trees has been received from this Authority’s ecologist or from Natural Resources Wales on the basis of ecological value. Similarly no objection has been received from this Authority’s tree officer. If members are mindful to approve this application it would be on the basis of a comprehensive landscaping scheme to replace the boundary hedging with appropriate native tree and hedging species. Conclusions: As this site is allocated in the Eryri Local Development Plan for housing purposes this application for 8 dwellings on a 50-50 affordable/market mix of dwellings is in accordance with Eryri Local Development Plan. The Highways Authority has not raised any objections to the increased use of this access road and a Welsh Government Inspector concluded that the previous application for 12 dwellings posed no additional risk to highway safety. No objections have been raised by the Authority’s ecologist Natural Resources Wales or tree officer to the removal of the boundary trees. Dwr Cymru have raised no objection to the proposal subject to appropriate conditions to accommodate surface foul water from the site. The design of the dwellings has utilised the slope of the site to provide for a range of dwelling sizes. Applicant has agreed to enter into a section 106 agreement to secure the affordability and restrict occupancy for 4 of the dwellings. Background Papers in Document Bundle No.1: Yes RECOMMENDATION: To APPROVE this application subject to appropriate conditions and a Section 106 Agreement securing the affordability and restricting the occupancy of 4 of proposed dwellings. Snowdonia National Park Authority – Planning & Access Committee Date: 04/03/2015 Date Application Registered: 12/12/14 Application Number: NP5/61/333B Community: Harlech Grid Reference: 258177 331182 Application Type: Full Location: Seasons & Reasons, High Street, Harlech. Applicant: Mr J. Brookes Seasons and Reasons High Street Harlech Gwynedd Description: Formation of off road parking area. Consultees: Harlech Community Council Gwynedd – Highways Responses: Object No objection, advisory notes requested No response received Cadw Site: Seasons and Reasons, Stryd Fawr, Harlech Proposal: Formation of off road parking area (resubmission) Designations: Within housing development boundary Within conservation area Within essential setting of World Heritage Site Within ELDP retail area Publicity Undertaken: Site Notice: Yes Press Notice: N/A Reason(s) Application Reported to Committee: Scheme of Delegation Community Council objection Neighbour Letters: Yes Planning History: Application No. Details NP5/61/333A Formation of off road parking area Np5/17/47A NP5/17/47 Formation of cellar to bookshop, Gwyndy Stores Replacement of existing timber stair at rear of store with metal stairs, Gwyndy Stores Decision Refused 31.07.2014 Approved 26.08.1976 Approved 12.08.1976 Relevant Planning Policies – Eryri Local Plan: Policy No. Policy 1 General development principles Ff Historic Environment Assessment: Small enclosed site located on Maesgwyn between Seasons and Reasons and Castle Restaurant at the centre of Harlech. Site is currently a yard and is split into two sections by a rendered block wall. Part of the site which fronts the highway is currently fronted by a stone wall and two stone pillars. This is a resubmission of an application that was refused on 31 July 2014 as it was considered by officers that the proposal would not preserve and enhance the Conservation area, would harm the character of the area and would be a danger to highway safety. The applicant has taken on board the suggestions of your officers to improve the application. Consequently the proposal now shows the removal of the block wall within the site and the removal of the stone wall and the two stone pillars on the highway verge, one of which will be rebuilt at a different point on the highway verge. The applicant has shown that the entire area will be sensitively surfaced with cobbles. The intention of the applicant is to utilise this site to facilitate an off road parking area to be created. It is considered that the proposal is now compliant with the aims of conservation area and will preserve and enhance its designation. Whilst the comments of the community council over highway safety are to be appreciated the Highways Authority has raised no objections to the use of this area of land for car parking. Consequently it is difficult to argue a case against its use for parking. Given the above it is considered that this application can now be approved. Background Papers in Document Bundle No.1: Yes RECOMMENDATION: To APPROVE subject to appropriate conditions. Snowdonia National Park Authority – Planning & Access Committee Date: 04/03/2015 Date Application Registered: 01/12/14 Application Number: NP5/61/560B Community: Harlech Grid Reference: 258250 331224 Application Type: Full Location: Land between Trem Arfor and Hiraethog, High Street, Harlech. Applicant: Mr Colin Pugh Llechwedd Du Mawr Harlech Gwynedd Description: Construction of detached dwelling (Revised design). Consultees: Harlech Community Council Responses: Clarification requested over car parking No objections subject to conditions No observations No objections No objections No observations Highways Authority Building Regulations Dwr Cymru Natural Resources Wales Cadw Site: Land adjacent Hiraethog, High Street, Harlech. Proposal: Erection of dwelling. Designations: Adjacent to Conservation Area SSSI & SAC in close proximity Wtihin housing development boundary Scheduled Ancient Monument in close proximity Within World Heritage Site Essential Setting Publicity Undertaken: Site Notice: Yes Press Notice: Yes Neighbour Letters: Yes Reason(s) Application Reported to Committee: Schedule of Delegation At the request of the Director of Planning and Cultural Heritage and the level of local interest. Planning History: Application No. Details NP5/61/560A Erection of dwelling NP5/61/560 Erection of dwelling Decision Refused 2014 Refused 2013 Relevant Planning Policies: Eryri Local Development Plan 2011 Policy No 1 6 G Ff Policy General planning principles Sustainable design and materials Housing Historic environment Assessment: The site subject to this application is located on Harlech High Street in close proximity to the towns centre. It is a vacant area of land which has in the past been utilised as a car park for a restaurant. The restaurant has now been closed permanently and the building in the process of being converted into two ground floor flats, there is also a single flat on the first floor in separate ownership. The provision of four parking spaces on this plot of land are a condition attached to the permission for the two flats adjacent. The site is currently vacant and utilised for car parking. Whilst the site has generally level access to the adjacent highway it does drop very steeply to the north west and when viewed from that direction commands a very elevated and dominant position. It is situated in a largely residential frontage of detached dwellings. The site overlooks and dominates residential properties to the north and west and is in full view of the World Heritage Site of Harlech Castle. The site falls wholly within the World Heritage Site Essential Setting and the Harlech Conservation Area. This application shows a two storey dwelling utilising the topography of the site to show what would appear to be a bungalow facing onto High Street with a lower ground facing towards the World Heritage Site forming two storeys. The design shows gables of natural stone with other walls of painted render. Around the dwelling the plans indicate 4 parking spaces. One of the spaces is allocated for the one of the flats opposite. The other flat has been able to utilise a space to the side for parking purposes. The applicants have indicated that they are not prepared to enter into a Section 106 Agreement on this dwelling to provide for an affordable/local occupancy dwelling and the size of the dwelling exceeds that expected as an affordable dwelling. However, the applicants do own the flats on the opposite side of the High Street and have indicated a willingness to enter into a s.106 agreement to secure the affordability and restrict the occupancy of one of the flats in exchange for an unencumbered dwelling on this application site. The applicants have submitted valuations for one of the two bedroom flat opposite which shows an open market valuation of £125,000.00. This flat has been offered up by the applicant as suitable alternative to restricting the application dwelling as an affordable local occupancy dwelling. Using the Authority’s percentage discount calculation the affordable selling price for this flat brings it down by 43% to £71,250.00. There have been 4 letters of objection to this proposal received from concerned neighbours over the design and harmful effect on loss of amenity that may result from this application if approved. The concerns of the objectors are: Overdevelopment of the site Scale of the new dwelling Loss of amenity to neighbouring dwellings Contaminated land Inadequate parking provision Loss of views to and from the Castle The Harlech Community Council has requested clarification over the car parking for the flats opposite. This information has been passed on to them which shows that one of the spaces within the application site is allocated for one of the flats with the other having provision within its boundaries. This has been agreed with the Highways Authority as acceptable and satisfies their standards. Members may recall a similar application and committee panel visit on this plot of land in late 2013. At that time members resolved to refuse the application on the basis of the applicants unwillingness to secure the affordability of the dwelling, inappropriate design, loss of amenity for neighbouring properties, damaging visual impact on the conservation area and World Heritage Site, cramped and overdevelopment of the site, and lack of off street parking. Members at that time were of the opinion that the site could be utilised for a dwelling but it should not extend any further back than the existing rear elevation of the neighbouring dwelling, should eliminate the overbearing balconies and should have a design better suited to its location. In submitting this application the applicant has addressed these issues. The applicant has clarified the parking arrangements with the flats opposite and has indicated a willingness to offer one of the flats as an affordable/local occupancy dwelling in lieu of the application dwelling. It is considered that in offering one of the flats opposite it does bring a two bedroom flat into an affordable range for occupation by a person in need of housing from the local community. In securing the affordability and restricting the occupancy of the flat it takes the flat out of the open housing market and the short term tourist letting market. Background Papers in Document Bundle No.1: Yes RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE this application subject to appropriate conditions and the applicant entering into a section 106 agreement to secure the affordability and restrict the occupancy of Flat 1, The Bistro, High Street Harlech. Snowdonia National Park Authority – Planning & Access Committee Date: 04/03/2015 Date Application Registered: 09/12/14 Application Number: NP5/67/196A Community: Llanfihangel y Pennant Grid Reference: 264540 305744 Application Type: Full Location: Ty Mawr Farm, Bryncrug. Applicant: Mr Lewis Williams Tŷ Mawr Farm Bryncrug Tywyn Gwynedd Description: Installation of 5kw wind turbine 17.75m to tip. Consultees: Llanfihangel y Pennant Community Council Natural Resources Wales RSPB Ministry of Defence Responses: No objection Views awaited Comments No objection Site: Ty Mawr Farm is located in the hamlet of Abertrinant which in turn is accessed via a minor single track road between Dolgoch and the Dysynni Valley. The turbine would be located on hillside in an exposed open location, presently used for grazing and some 300 metres from Craig yr Aderyn. The nearest residential property is located some 140 metres away, (not in the ownership of the applicant). Proposal: The proposal is to erect a wind turbine generator with an installed capacity of 5kw. Works entail a slender 15m tubular tower with 5.5m rotor diameter giving total height to tip of 17.75m. The tubular tower is a slender design finished in the neutral colour of galvanised steel, the turbine and blades would be finished in Dark Admiralty Grey BS18B25. The electrical cable to connect to Ty Mawr Farm would be buried underground (some 400 metres down hillside). Designations: Non Statutory Site Public footpath to the south and east of the site Publicity Undertaken: Site Notice: Yes Press Notice: No Neighbour Letters: Yes Reason(s) Application Reported to Committee: Scheme of Delegation At the Committee’s Request Planning History: No relevant history. Relevant Planning Policies – Eryri Local Development Plan: Policy No. Policy 1 General Development Principles 2 Development and Landscape 3 Energy 8 Protection of Non-Designated Sites A Natural Park Purposes and Sustainable Development D Natural Environment Supplementary Planning Guidance – Renewable and Low Carbon Energy National Policies Planning Policy Wales (Edition 5) Nos. 2012 TAN8 Planning for Renewable Energy Assessment: Proposal is to erect a 17.75 high wind turbine in an exposed upland setting with views looking onto Bird Rock (Craig yr Aderyn) and the Cader Idris Range. The applicant states the electrical energy consumption of the appliance is estimated at 9000kwh and as such the turbine will generate an estimated 100% of the total electrical energy consumption of the applicant’s premises (Ty Mawr Farm) which allows for a reduction in fuel bills and carbon footprint. Any excess generated not used on site will be exported back into the grid and contributing directly towards the Government’s regional and national targets for supplying its electrical energy from sustainable resources. As part of application 6 wire framed photomontages from different viewpoints which the agent states due to its location against a hillside backdrop and its design would render the turbine barely visible from the majority of surrounding directions due to either the distance of the receptor location and the expansive scale of the surrounding backdrop. An ecological and landscaping character assessment has also been carried out which are contained within the Committee bundle. Notwithstanding the above, in my opinion a turbine of this height in such an open landscape (just set back from the ridge) would introduce a vertical man made moving structure into the open countryside currently devoid of such structures. It would not be well related to farm buildings and as such will not conserve or enhance the natural beauty of the National Park. It would be prominent from nearby public footpaths and sections of the minor road. Development Policy 3 of the Eryri Local Development Plan states: Energy would support small scale domestic wind turbines and should read in conjunction with development policy 1 and 2 which seek that the development is not unduly prominent in the landscape and unacceptable impact on the landscape will be restricted and in particular regard will be had to the protection of landscape character based on LANDMAP and as defined in landscape of Eryri Supplementary Planning. The Landscape and Sensitivity Study notes that the area is of High Sensitivity to wind energy development with typically no capacity for wind energy developments with the exception of a limited number of domestic to microscale turbines which should relate well to existing settlements/buildings. In addition the Authority’s SPG on Renewable Energy states wind turbines should avoid the following Exposed hilltops which are visible from public viewpoints where the turbine would result in an intrusive and significantly adverse landscape and visual impact for nearby residents. Sites that break the skyline and have no background landform to provide “backcloth” screening. Isolated locations which are more than 100m from the nearest building in the same ownership or in the control of the proposer. Sites of ecological interest e.g. bird and bat flight lines. In my opinion the proposal would form an incongruous feature in an otherwise open upland landscape and is therefore contrary to policies mentioned in reasons for refusal. Notwithstanding the above, our Ecology Officer also states “the wind turbine is located within 296m of Craig yr Aderyn which is an internationally important population of breeding and non-breeding season choughs. In addition breeding cormorant are a feature of Craig yr Aderyn SSSI and as such the Authority will need to undertaken a Test of Likely Significant Effects (HRA Screening) for the planning application. The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) have also raised concerns that grazing is not compromised by the proposed development because choughs require open grazing areas to forage. (Comments attached in Committee bundle). It is difficult to envisage a wind turbine of this size (area required to install) would affect the grazing, but the Authority is still awaiting Natural Resources Wales’ formal observations in respect of the effect on birds and the wider landscape. A further report will be made the meeting should observations be received. Background Papers in Document Bundle No. 1: Yes RECOMMENDATION: To REFUSE for the following reason: 1. The proposal, by reason of its height and location (close proximity to ridge level), would constitute a prominent and intrusive feature within the landscape, adversely impacting on the local landscape, character and visual amenities of the locality. The proposal is therefore considered to be contrary to Development Policies 1 and 2 of the Eryri Local Development Plan, in addition to the objectives of Planning Policy Wales and Supplementary Planning Guidance for renewable and low carbon energy. SNOWDONIA NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY PLANNING AND ACCESS COMMITTEE, 4TH MARCH 2015 LIST OF COMPLIANCE CASES SECTION 215 NOTICES SERVED UNDER DELEGATED POWERS Reference Date Served Location of Site Details of Planning Breach NP5/57/ENF1030 13/01/2015 The Workshop, Glyndwr Street, Dolgellau, Gwynedd, LL40 1BD Untidy Condition of the Land Date Notice Takes effect 20th February 2015 Period of Compliance 130 days (compliance by the 1st July 2015) SNOWDONIA NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY PLANNING AND ACCESS COMMITTEE, 4TH MARCH 2015 LIST OF COMPLIANCE CASES New cases Reference Date of initial complaint or Date observed by Compliance Officers Location of Site Details of Planning Breach Current Position 1 NP4/12/ENF15 January 2015 Land Opposite Preswylfa, Rowen Creation of Vehicular Access Outside of Dwelling Curtilage Contact made with the owners of the land. They have advised they will be submitting a retrospective planning application in an attempt to regularise the works. 2 NP5/50/ENF300H January 2015 Plot 3, Parc y Llethrau, Aberdyfi Dwelling not in Accordance with the Approved Plans Site visit carried out and measurements undertaken. Dwelling appears to be built in accordance with the approved plans. File closed. 3 NP5/59/ENF709C January 2015 Land to the Rear of Tyn y Maes, Llan Ffestiniog Untidy Condition of the Land Contact made with the occupier. To improve the condition of the land by the end of February 2015. 4 NP5/62/ENF152 December 2014 Ty Isaf, Llanbedr Erection of structures in front garden including polytunnel Site meeting held with the owners. Advised planning permission is required for the polytunnel and shed. 5 NP5/64/ENF51 December 2014 The Old Tannery, Crynllwyn, Bryncrug Possible re-development Site visit carried out where it was noted only clearance of vegetation had taken place. Contact made with the owners to ensure no redevelopment is undertaken without first checking on whether planning consent is required for any re-building. 6 NP5/74/ENF384A October 2014 Land to the South East of Groesllwyd, Cwm Cewydd, Dinas Mawddwy Erection of a Polytunnel & Greenhouse and the siting of a Touring Caravan used for Residential Purposes Contact made with the owner of the land. A retrospective planning application has been submitted in respect to the polytunnel and greenhouse. The touring caravan is currently being used for the storage of tools and equipment but the owner has advised that for the past two years they have been residing in the touring caravan between March and Autumn time. Referred to Legal 7 NP5/71/ENFLB March 2014 Ty’n y Ffridd, Llanuwchllyn Unauthorised Works and Partial Demolition of a Listed Building Appeal dismissed March 2014. Listed Building Enforcement Notice currently being drafted. Matter also referred to the Authority’s Solicitor. Discussions are being held in respect to remedial/alternative works and a meeting is due to take place on the 25th February 2015. 8 NP5/73/ENFAD395A November 2014 Highway Verge Adjoining A470(T) on both approaches to Trawsfynydd Power Station, Trawsfynydd Unauthorised Advertisement All signage has now been removed. Meeting arranged for the 25th February 2015 to discuss proposed alternative signage. File closed. Awaiting the Submission of an Application 9 NP2/11/ENF93 November 2014 Craig Wen, Beddgelert Creation of Pond Site visit carried out. Awaiting the submission of a retrospective planning application. 10 NP2/11/ENFL501A November 2014 Hendre Bach, Beddgelert Erection of Chalet Building Being Used as Residential Accommodation Contact has been made with the owner of the land. Planning Contravention Notice served and replies received confirming the residential use of the chalet has now ceased. Currently assessing the construction of the chalet which appears to differ in size from that which was granted consent. Owners have advised they will be submitting a retrospective planning application in an attempt to regularise matters. Retrospective Application Received 11 NP5/54/ENF40 Sept 2014 Land adjacent to Fronwydd, Rhydymain Erection of Steel Structure and Restoration of Existing Hydro Development Site visit undertaken and meeting held with owner. Advised planning consent required for the turbine house. Meeting held with the owner on the 17th October 2014. Retrospective planning application received and now complete. 12 NP5/74/ENF44B Sept 2014 Conifers, Millyn, Dinas Mawddwy Erection of wall and railings Contact made with the owner. Planning consent was granted for a wall and railings in this location but the development appears higher than what was approved. Site meeting held on the 5th November 2014. Retrospective planning application submitted but currently incomplete. 13 NP5/74/ENF435 July 2014 Camlan Farm, Mallwyd Erection of Mast, Small Agricultural Building & Ponds Contact made with the owner. Site meeting held. Retrospective planning applications received. Appears the mast has been removed. 14 NP5/78/ENFLB412D July 2014 Rhiw Goch Inn, Bronaber, Trawsfynydd Roof Alterations to a Listed Building Contact made with the owner. A Listed Building Consent application has been submitted but currently incomplete. Awaiting further Information or Replies to a Planning Contravention Notice or a Section 330 Notice 15 NP2/11/ENF677 December 2014 Afon Colwyn, Land at Nant Colwyn, Beddgelert Breach of Conditions under NP2/11/677 Joint meeting held with Natural Resources Wales to discuss current ongoing works in respect to the construction of the hydro development. Negotiations ongoing. 16 NP4/11/ENF363 November 2014 Pentre Du Farm, Pentre Du, Betws y Coed Removal of wall & Engineering Works Site visit undertaken and discussions held with the owner. Currently awaiting the receipt of additional information regarding the use of the land before determining whether planning consent is required for the works. 17 NP4/16/ENF130D April 2013 Plas Hall Hotel, Pont y Pant, Dolwyddelan Alleged Change of Use to a House in Multiple Occupation/Hostel Accommodation Expediency report now being drafted with a view of initiating formal action. Study of relevant case law is also currently being undertaken in respect to this type of alleged breach of planning control. 18 NP5/57/ENF1030 June 2013 Workshop, Glyndwr Street, Dolgellau Untidy/Poor Condition of Building Formal action to be initiated under Section 215 for the demolition of the building. Site visit to view the internal arrangement of the building took place on the 11th August 2014. Section 215 Notice has now been served. 19 NP5/58/ENF300 Sept 2014 The Barns, Ffordd Tyddyn y Felin, Talybont Window/Door Details in Barn Conversion not in Accordance with the Approved Plans. Site meeting held with the owners where discussions held regarding the window/door details. Minor amendment application has now been submitted. 20 NP5/58/ENF566 December 2014 17 Bro Enddwyn, Dyffryn Ardudwy Garden Shed Site visit carried out where the development was discussed with the contractor. Appears planning permission is required for the shed. Contact made with the owners of the property who are looking to re-locate the shed in a position where planning permission is not required. 21 NP5/60/ENF87D November 2014 Land South of Dolfrwynog, Llanfachreth, Dolgellau Erection of Timber Building & Associated Engineering Works Retrospective planning application (NP5/60/87C) refused. In the process of initiating formal action and a Requisition for Information under Section 330 has been served. Awaiting replies. 22 NP5/61/ENF23P June 2013 St. Davids Hotel and Coleg Harlech Hall of Residence,Harlech Untidy Condition of Building Negotiations ongoing to reach an acceptable solution. 23 NP5/61/ENFT558A Sept 2014 Former Tabernacl Chapel, High Street, Harlech Breach of Condition 3 of Planning Consent NP5/61/T558A – installation of UPVC windows). Contact made with the owner of the property. Retrospective planning application submitted to vary conditions on planning consent NP5/61/T558A in an attempt to try and retain the UPVC windows. 24 NP5/77/ENF115E March 2014 Land Near Ty Newydd, Llandecwyn, Talsarnau Residential Caravan Owner has made contact. Planning Contravention served on the 18th July 2014. Currently awaiting a response and a further meeting was held on the 12th August 2014. Matter ongoing and being delayed due to the owner being currently out of the country. 25 NP5/77/ENF158C November 2014 Old School Hall, Talsarnau Unauthorised Building Work Site visit carried out and discussions held with the owner of the property. Cases where formal action is being considered/has been taken. 26 NP5/55/ENF110 2012 Former TTP Site, Bryncrug Sub-division of Building and Possible Change of Use for Car Sales/Repairs Awaiting the submission of a certificate of lawfulness in respect to the use of the land. Currently liaising with the owners Solicitors in respect to the proposed application. No significant response received despite sending a reminder. Planning Contravention Notice replies received on the 21st November 2014. 27 NP5/70/ENF117B Feb 2014 Land to the Rear of Plas Onn, Llangower, Bala Engineering Works, Container & Erection of Outbuildings Site meeting held with the owner of the land. Request made for the removal of various structures and remedial works to the land. Works not carried out within the required timescale. Requisition for Information under Section 330 now served and currently awaiting replies. Listed Building Cases 28 NP5/53/ENFLB18 April 2014 Henblas Garage, 26 Y Stryd Fawr, Bala Installation of uPVC Windows in a Listed Building Contact made with the owner. A requisition for information served under Section 330 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 has been served. Owner has intimated that the windows will be changed to timber sash. 29 NP5/71/ENFLB353A August 2014 Gwyndy, Llanuwchllyn Unauthorised Alterations to Dormer Windows Contact made with the owner who has advised they will replace the dormer windows and door to match the originals. Awaiting details prior to replacing. SNOWDONIA NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY PLANNING AND ACCESS COMMITTEE, 4 MARCH 2015 PLANNING, ENFORCEMENT NOTICE, AND CERTIFICATES OF LAWFUL USE APPEALS SUBMITTED AND AWAITING DECISION No. Application No. 1 NP4/16/55B 2 NP5/61/87G 3 NP5/61/LU565 4 NP5/67/311A Description Appeal against Authority’s decision to refuse to remove Section 106 Agreement dated 20/08/2008, 1 & 2 Pentre Bont (Land at Rathbone Terrace), Dolwyddelan. Appeal against Authority’s decision to refuse planning permission for the Change of use of ground floor from shop to flat, Shop 1, Gwyddfor House, High Street, Harlech. Appeal against Authority’s decision to refuse to grant a Certificate of Lawful Use (Proposed Use) for construction of dwelling and garage and the formation of an access road connected to the plot, Plot 24, Land at Ty Canol, Harlech. Appeal against Authority’s decision to refuse to Vary Condition No.4 of Planning Consent NP5/40/74 dated 24/09/1979 to read as 'The dwelling shall not be occupied by any person other than a person solely or mainly employed in agriculture (As defined by Section 290(1) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1971) at Cwmrhwyddfor or a dependant of such a person residing with him or her (but including widow or widower of such a person). Inbetween such occupancies, the dwelling shall only be occupied as short term holiday accommodation', Cysgod Y Mynydd, Talyllyn. Procedure/Status Case Officer Hearing 25/11/2014. Mr Richard Thomas Written representations. Mr Richard Thomas Written representations. Mr Richard Thomas Hearing 15/01/2015. Mrs Rebeca Jones 5 NP5/76/323F Appeal against refusal of planning permission for the construction of new toilet and shower block, retention of temporary reception cabin, increase number of caravans from 49 to 59, extend caravan season from 8 months to 10½ months and extension to site to form tented camping area for 25 new tent pitches, Blaen Cefn, Penrhyndeudraeth Written representations. Mr Aled Lloyd Number of appeals on list = 5 Number of appeals on committee list 21 January 2015 = 5 Number of appeals 01/04/14 – 31/03/15 01/04/13 – 31/03/14 01/04/12 – 31/03/13 01/04/11 – 31/03/12 01/04/10 – 31/03/11 01/04/09 – 31/03/10 01/04/08 – 31/03/09 Determined Granted Dismissed Withdrawn 9 20 17 14 14 22 15 2 6 3 4 3 5 4 7 13 13 9 11 16 10 1 2 1 0 1 1 SNOWDONIA NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY PLANNING AND ACCESS COMMITTEE, 4 MARCH 2015 SECTION 106 AGREEMENTS No. Application No. Date application was received Location Development Present Position 1 NP3/12/94K 07/03/13 Bryn Gloch Caravan & Camping Park, Betws Garmon. Relayout of pitches on existing holiday park (overall reduction in number on field nos. 4, 5 & 6 and reduction of area on field no. 6), removal of 3 rectilinear earth bunds, diversion of Public Footpaths 11 and 18 to allow improved access, location of wi-fi antennae, additional landscaping, planting belts and environmental improvements (revision to planning application NP3/12/94J refused on 01/10/2012) Awaiting for Draft agreement to be returned 2 NP5/50/588B 30/05/14 Apartment 6, Yr Hen Stablau, Plas Panteidal, Aberdyfi Vary Condition No.2 of Planning Awaiting office copies Consent NP5/50/588A dated 12/07/2012 to release Apartment 6 from the 28 day occupancy condition to allow all year occupancy. 3 NP5/58/427A 22/04/14 Ty’n Llidiart, Dyffryn Ardudwy Change of use from annex to dwelling. Awaiting office copies 4 NP5/61/LB32J 16/01/13 The Plas, High Street, Change of use of part of ground floor Harlech restaurant to dwelling. Awaiting office copies 5 NP5/69/355 11/03/11 Barn near Brynllwyn Farm, Rhoslefain. Conversion of barn into dwelling, construction of garage and installation of septic tank. Awaiting office copies 6 NP5/71/432 05/07/12 Land to rear of Llwyn Onn, Llanuwchllyn. Construction of one affordable dwelling for local need In contact with the applicant’s solicitor 7 NP5/77/L41D 07/10/11 Former Post Office, 5 High Street, Talsarnau. Conversion of existing dwelling and disused shop into two dwellings. Awaiting draft agreement to be returned Number of applications on list = 7 Number of applications on committee list 21 January 2015 = 12 APPLICATIONS SUBJECT TO A SECTION 106 AGREEMENT AND WHICH HAVE BEEN COMPLETED SINCE PLANNING & ACCESS COMMITTEE 21 JANUARY 2015 Application No. NP2/16/127B Location Hen Efail, Golan, Garndolbenmaen. NP4/19/47H Gwern Borter Manor, Rowen, Conwy. NP4/19/47J Gwern Borter Manor, Rowen, Conwy. Gwern Borter Manor, Rowen, Conwy. NP4/19/47K Development Conversion and extension of former smithy into dwelling, construction of detached garage, formation of new vehicular/pedestrian access and installation of new package treatment plant Removal of Section 106 Agreement dated 25/10/1995 in connection with Planning Consent NP4/19/47C for change of use of existing outbuildings into holiday accommodation together with alterations Change of use of from amenity building to dwelling RemovaL of Section 52 Agreement dated 30/01/1991 in connection with Planning Consent NP4/19/47A for conversion of outbuilding into 3 bedroom cottage APPLICATIONS SUBJECT TO A SECTION 106 AGREEMENT WHICH HAVE BEEN WITHDRAWN, OR DISPOSED, OR WHERE A AGREEMENT IS NO LONGER NECESSARY SINCE PLANNING & ACCESS COMMITTEE 10 DECEMBER 2014 Application No. NP5/59/511B Location Land at rear of Penrhiw, Llan Ffestiniog NP5/59/511D Plot 4, land at rear of Penrhiw, Ffestiniog. Development Amended details to site layout and dwelling types to that approved under Planning Consent NP5/59/511A dated 14th February 2005 including additional two plots Change of use from 1 dwelling to 2 dwellings & construction of 2 side extensions and 1 rear extension, construction of detached double garage, and installation of sewage treatment plant SNOWDONIA NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY PLANNING AND ACCESS COMMITTEE 04 MARCH 2015 OUTSTANDING APPLICATIONS WHERE MORE THAN 13 WEEKS HAVE ELAPSED Awaiting Eclology / Tree Survey NP5/62/389 29/05/2014 The Bungalow, Llanbedr. NP5/74/428A 29/05/2014 Coed Cae, Llanymawddwy. Outline Application to demolish existing dwelling and construction of 7 dwellings (4 open market detached houses and 3 bungalows (1 detached and 2 semi-detached) for affordable and local occupation) and formation of new vehicular & pedestrian access. Erection of agricultural building. Awaiting Further Information NP4/16/386 01/05/2014 Ty'n y Coed, Dolwyddelan. Change of use from agricultural to domestic curtilage, widening of gateway, construction of retaining wall and formation of hardstanding parking/turning area & associated landscaping (part retrospective). Other NP5/67/314 22/04/2014 Nant Gwernol, Abergynolwyn. NP5/73/26A 21/05/2014 Utica Buildings, Trawsfynydd. Total applications on list = 5 Total applications on list Committee 21 January 2015 = 9 Proposed hydro-electric scheme including construction of turbine house, weir and installation of underground tailrace, pipe and outfall. Construction of workshop & store, re-modelling of external works to provide storage area, parking and alterations to existing vehicular access. SNOWDONIA NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY PLANNING AND ACCESS COMMITTEE, 4 MARCH 2015 Policy Section Report of Consultations received Consulting Authority Consultation topic/name Welsh Government Subordinate Legislation Relating to Certain Internal Operations (mezzanine floors) Planning committees, delegation and joint planning boards Proposed amendments to legislation on the power to override easements and other rights Consultation on Design in the Planning Process Frontloading the development management system Review of Planning application fees Planning and related decisions of the Welsh Ministers Snowdonia Enterprise Zone and Llanbedr Access Improvements Corridor Improvements of A496 Maentwrog to Blaenau Ffestiniog Draft Managing Gypsy and Traveller sites in Wales guidance Consultation on Local Development Plans Process Review Consultation on Improving the availability of allotments and community gardens Consultation on Draft Technical Advice Note 1 (tan 1); Joint Housing Land Availability Studies (JHLAS) Positive Planning: Proposals to reform the planning system in Wales Welsh Government Welsh Government Welsh Government Welsh Government Welsh Government Welsh Government Gwynedd Consultancy Gwynedd Consultancy Welsh Government Welsh Government Welsh Government Welsh Government Welsh Government Response deadline 13/02/15 Lead Officer Report to NPA / Committee? No Iwan Evans 16/01/15 Iwan Evans 16/01/15 Iwan Evans Planning & Access No 16/01/15 16/01/15 16/01/15 31/01/15 Iwan Evans Iwan Evans Iwan Evans Iwan Evans No No No No Iwan Evans No Iwan Evans No 21/11/14 Iwan Evans No 01/10/14 Iwan Evans No 06/10/14 Rebeca Jones No 10/10/14 Iwan Evans No 26/02/14 Iwan Evans & Elliw Owen Working Group and Planning & Access Consulting Authority Consultation topic/name Response deadline Lead Officer Report to NPA / Committee? The Office for National Statistics (ONS) The Census and future provision of population statistics in England and Wales. (Beyond 2011) 13/12/13 Sion Roberts No Natural Resources Wales Planning our future 10/01/14 Iwan Evans No Natural Resources Wales River Basin Planning ‘Challenges & Choices’ consultation 22/12/13 Gareth Lloyd No Welsh Government Towards the Sustainable Management of Wales’ Natural Resources: Consultation on proposals for an Environment Bill 15/01/14 Iwan Evans Planning & Access Department of Energy & Review of the Siting Process for a Geological Climate Change Disposal Facility 5/12/13 Iwan Evans No Welsh Government Discretionary Powers for Local Authorities to Increase Council Tax on Second Homes 28/10/13 Elliw Owen No Cymdeithas Tai Clwyd a Cymdeithas Tai Eryri Coming Together 30/09/13 Elliw Owen No National Grid Visual Impact Provision for National Parks and AONB 24/09/13 Gareth Lloyd No Welsh Government Taking the long view: draft Policy Statement for Protected Landscapes in Wales 20/09/13 Iwan Evans Authority Darren Millar AM Proposed Holiday Caravan Parks (Wales) Bill 13/09/13 Rebeca Jones & No Jane Jones Consulting Authority Consultation topic/name Response deadline 05/09/13 Lead Officer Welsh Government Draft TAN 23 on Economic Development (explanatory and consultation documents) Dŵr Cymru Welsh Water Your Company, Your Say: Our Plans 2015-2021 30/08/13 Elliw Owen No Welsh Language Commissioner Planning and the Welsh Language 31/07/13 Elliw Owen No Communities, Equality and Local Government Committee Inquiry into barriers to home building in Wales 03/07/13 Elliw Owen No Iwan Evans Report to NPA / Committee? Planning & Access SNOWDONIA NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY PLANNING AND ACCESS COMMITTEE 04 MARCH 2015 DELEGATED DECISIONS Applications Approved Application No. NP3/10/LB33D NP3/16/7N NP4/11/35L NP4/12/162F NP4/13/82H NP4/19/47H NP4/19/47J NP4/19/47K NP4/26/321 NP4/26/LB162F Proposed Form 12m x 12m hardstanding for car parking Location Gatehouse / Barn, Pen y Bryn, Abergwyngregyn. LL33 0LA New external door to provide access to W.C. and Idwal Cottage Youth erection of 2no. timber cycle & storage sheds Hostel, Nant Ffrancon, Bethesda. LL57 3LZ Construction of new ramp to provide disabled The Gallery, Holyhead access Road, Betws-y-Coed. LL24 0BW Conversion of agricultural outbuildings into holiday Cefn Cae, Rowen, Conwy, let units LL328YT Conversion of agricultural building to rural Tal y Braich Isaf, Capel enterprise dwellinghouse Curig. LL24 0EU Removal of Section 106 Agreement dated Gwern Borter Manor, 25/10/1995 in connection with Planning Consent Rowen, Conwy. LL32 8YL NP4/19/47C for change of use of existing outbuildings into holiday accommodation together with alterations Change of use of amenity building to form an Gwern Borter Manor, affordable housing unit Rowen, Conwy. LL32 8YL Removal of Section 52 Agreement dated Gwern Borter Manor, 30/01/1991 in connection with Planning Consent Rowen, Conwy. LL32 8YL NP4/19/47A for conversion of outbuilding into 3 bedroom cottage Construction of first floor extension to side of Llidiart y Godart, Capel dwelling and construction of workshop on footprint Garmon. LL26 0RD of former outbuilding Listed Building Consent for alterations to add new Ty Glan Conwy, Betws-yexternal boiler flue Coed. LL24 0ST Decision Date 10/02/15 Case Officer Mr Gwilym H Jones 20/01/15 Mr Richard Thomas 13/01/15 Mr Richard Thomas 06/02/15 Mr Richard Thomas Mr Richard Thomas Mr Richard Thomas 13/01/15 12/02/15 16/02/15 12/02/15 Mr Richard Thomas Mr Richard Thomas 10/02/15 Ms Sara Roberts 19/01/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones NP4/29/318E NP4/29/LB123C Upgrade to existing telecommunications installation Change of use of annexe to holiday let unit NP5/50/L262 Change of use from shop to shop & café NP5/51/673 Proposed hydro-electric scheme including construction of intake weir, turbine house and installation of underground pipes Conversion of attic, installation of dormer windows, rooflights and solar panels Erection of porch extension NP5/52/313A NP5/52/337C NP5/53/57A NP5/54/18A NP5/55/228 NP5/57/506F NP5/57/901C NP5/57/LB379E NP5/57/LB379F NP5/57/LB379G Erection of rear extension and rooflights on east & west elevations Retrospective application for replacement cladding on rear, proposed construction of replacement balcony Replace 2 windows on front elevation with 2 new doors together with associated ramp for mobility access Lounge extension to rear of property Fedw Deg Forest, Bwlch y Maen, Betws y Coed. Benar, Penmachno. LL24 0PS 8a Sea View Terrace, Aberdyfi. LL35 0EF Afon Dwynant, Bontddu. 03/02/15 18/02/15 Eryl, Friog. LL38 2HX 20/02/15 Plot adjacent to Arthog Hall Farm, Arthog. LL39 1YU Garreg Wen, Arenig Street, Bala. LL23 7AH Gornant, Llanfachreth. LL40 2EA 19/02/15 22/01/15 03/02/15 Mr Richard Thomas Mr Gwilym H Jones Mr R Huw Roberts Mr R Huw Roberts Mr R Huw Roberts Mr R Huw Roberts 24/01/15 Ms Sara Roberts 03/02/15 Ms Iona Thomas Former Bryncrug School, Bryncrug. LL36 9PR 02/02/15 Mr R Huw Roberts Yr Ynys, Penmaenpool. LL40 1YJ Vary Condition Nos. 2 and 4 of Planning Consent Torrent Walk Campsite, NP5/57/901A dated 4th February 2003 to increase Dolgun Uchaf, Dolgellau. number of caravans from 10 to 17 and restrict LL40 2AB number of tents to 43 tents Listed Building Consent to remove door from foot Bwthyn Penbryn, Cader of stair Road, Dolgellau. LL40 1RJ Listed Building Consent to remove modern wall Bwthyn Penbryn, Cader finishes on the middle floor from east gable Road, Dolgellau. LL40 fireplace to stairs to upper floor 1RJ Listed Building Consent to remove modern Bwthyn Penbryn, Cader internal door south of the east gable fireplace on Road, Dolgellau. LL40 the middle floor 1RJ 09/02/15 Mr R Huw Roberts Ms Iona Thomas 23/01/15 16/01/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones 16/01/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones 16/01/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones NP5/57/LB379H Listed Building Consent to remove toilet partitions and fittings on lower ground floor NP5/57/LB464B Listed Building Consent to vary Condition 2 of Listed Building Consent NP5/57/LB464A to amend details of chimney pots, roof verges, add flue, add railings to rear garden wall, remove unstable breasting and alterations to floor finishes Listed Building Consent for alterations and extension to existing residential accommodation NP5/57/LB89M NP5/57/LB89N Alterations and extension to existing residential accommodation NP5/58/564 Restore and convert agricultural building into holiday cottage NP5/58/L2B Construction of porch NP5/59/756 Single storey side extension NP5/61/578 Construction of new garage, extension of existing parking area including construction of retaining wall, construction of terrace to rear of dwelling and insertion of two roof lights to rear elevation Listed Building Consent for alterations to chimneys, renweal of CCTV cameras and external lights, new air brick, installation of two wood burning stoves, alterations to from new kitchen and utility room, alterations to en-suite bathroom and landing screen Alterations to chimneys, renweal of CCTV cameras and external lights, new air brick Section 73 Application for removal of Conditions Nos. 19, 20, 21 of Planning Consent NP5/62/126D dated 22/10/2013 relating to 'Code for Sustainable Home' requirements NP5/61/LB449B NP5/61/LB449C NP5/62/126F Bwthyn Penbryn, Cader Road, Dolgellau. LL40 1RJ Penafon, South Street, Dolgellau. LL40 1NE 06/02/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones 19/01/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones Former Dutch Barn, Llwyn, Bala Road, Dolgellau. LL40 2YF Former Dutch Barn, Llwyn, Bala Road, Dolgellau. LL40 2YF Y Ddol, Ffordd yr Efail, Dyffryn Ardudwy. LL44 2BE Ger y Neuadd, Dyffryn Ardudwy. LL44 2BE 2 Bryn Coed, Llan Ffestiniog. LL41 4LN Kiltan, Harlech. LL46 2SS 13/01/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones 13/01/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones 02/02/15 Mr R Huw Roberts 22/01/15 19/01/15 Mr R Huw Roberts Ms Sara Roberts 27/01/15 Ms Sara Roberts Crown Lodge, Ffordd Isaf, Harlech, LL46 2PR 20/01/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones Crown Lodge, Ffordd Isaf, Harlech, LL46 2PR Former Youth Hostel Site, Plas Newydd, Llanbedr. LL45 2LE 19/01/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones Mr Richard Thomas 09/02/15 NP5/62/380A NP5/67/LB227A NP5/70/123C NP5/70/L106C NP5/72/LB142A NP5/73/107A NP5/73/383A NP5/73/AD197G NP5/75/156E NP5/77/305 NP5/77/LB238 Extend curtilage, construction of amenity building and retrospective application to retain terraces Listed Building Consent to remove corrugated roof over rear lean to extension, replace with steeper slate roof and replace window, Erection of new garage Construction of single storey side extension, retention of existing lean to covered roof above rear door & retention of detached garage/workshop Listed Building Consent to retain internal & external alterations executed without consent Removal of Section 52 Agreement dated 30/07/1990 relating to planning application NP5/73/107 Formation of canoe launching area and formation of off road parking area Advertisement Consent to display 1 free standing advanced directional sign for Waterfall Inn, Gellilydan Erection of agricultural building Change use of chapel room to form two storey extension to dwelling Retrospective application to install an array of 12 ground mounted photovoltaic panels and inverter within curtilage of Listed Building Ty'n Ddol, Llanbedr. LL45 2NU 10 Tan y Bryn Street, Abergynolwyn. LL36 9UY 03/02/15 20/01/15 Garth Lwyd, 13/02/15 Rhosygwaliau. LL23 7PL Beudy Isaf, Rhosygwaliau. 12/01/15 LL23 7EW Rafel, Parc, Bala. LL23 7YU Hafod y Llyn, Tan-yBwlch, Maentwrog, LL41 3AQ Land near A487(T), opposite Bryn Mawr, Maentwrog. LL41 3YY Land near A487(T), Gellilydan. 27/01/15 Gwerniago, Pennal. SY20 9JX Ty Capel Graig, Talsarnau. LL47 6UG Glanllyn, Llandecwyn. LL47 6YS 13/02/15 Mr Richard Thomas Mr Gwilym H Jones Ms Sara Roberts Mr Richard Thomas Mr Gwilym H Jones Mr Richard Thomas 13/02/15 Mr Richard Thomas 10/02/15 Ms Iona Thomas 12/01/15 Mr R Huw Roberts Ms Sara Roberts 02/02/15 02/02/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones Llyndy Isaf, Beddgelert. LL55 4NL 03/02/15 Mr Richard Thomas Gadlys, Abergwyngregyn. LL33 0LE 30/01/15 Ms Sara Roberts Applications Refused NP2/11/692 NP3/10/50B Proposed hydro-electric scheme including construction of intake weir, part overground, part underground pipe and turbine house Construction of balcony NP4/11/10Q Erection of dwelling NP4/12/T182E Conversion of barn to dwelling and formation of new vehicular access Removal of Section 106 Agreement dated 3rd March 1992 ref: NP4/32/6D Vary Condition Nos. 3 of Planning Consent NP5/57/901A dated 04/02/2003 to allow 7 tents over winter period (31st October to 1st March) Listed Building Consent to remove brick partition on lower floor NP4/32/6G NP5/57/901D NP5/57/LB379J NP5/57/LB379L NP5/66/189A Listed Building Consent to build brick pillars and insert a supporting beam betweenn the western and central rooms of the lower ground floor Engineering works to stabalise eroded dunes Plot 4, Parc Trawsafon, Betws-y-Coed. LL24 0AF Llwyn Onn, Rowen, Conwy, LL328YN Pernant, Jubilee Road, Trefriw, LL270SQ Torrent Walk Campsite, Dolgun Uchaf, Dolgellau. LL40 2AB Bwthyn Penbryn, Cader Road, Dolgellau. LL40 1RJ Bwthyn Penbryn, Cader Road, Dolgellau. LL40 1RJ Southern end of Llandanwg Beach. 09/02/15 12/01/15 12/01/15 23/01/15 Mr Richard Thomas Mr Richard Thomas Mr Richard Thomas Ms Iona Thomas 06/02/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones 06/02/15 Mr Gwilym H Jones 05/02/15 Mr Richard Thomas
© Copyright 2024