Appetizers Firecracker Shrimp Bleu Cheese Chips

Firecracker Shrimp
Light up with these little sparklers! Petite gulf shrimp dusted with seasoned flour
and tossed in our spicy firecracker sauce. 8.99
Bleu Cheese Chips
Send those blues away with the tang of this deep bleu taste! Our homemade
potato chips are smothered in bleu cheese sauce topped with fresh
tomatoes and scallions. 6.99
Wing It!
Try your hand at these crispy chicken wings! They’re tossed with your choice of
hot or mild Buffalo sauce and served with celery and bleu cheese.
10 wings 6.99 • 25 wings 13.99
Homemade Chips, Salsa & Guacamole
Betcha can’t eat just one! Our homemade tri-color tortilla chips are served with
salsa fresca and fresh guacamole. 5.99
Peel and Eat Shrimp
Succulent shrimp so good, they’re worth the effort! Poached in beer and served with
cocktail sauce and lemon. 9.49
Pulled Pork Eggroll Feast
These hearty hand-rolled treats are chock-filled with Sloppy Joe’s famous recipe
pulled pork combined with our mildly spicy BBQ sauce, then stuffed with
cheddar jack cheese. Island decadence! 6.99
Mozzarella Sticks
We use 1/2 pound of mozzarella cheese to make these homemade sticks, served with
our signature marinara sauce. 7.99
Potato Skins
The best in spuds! Idaho Potato skins baked with cheddar jack cheese, topped with
crisp bacon, served with sour cream and chives on the side. 7.99
Chicken Nibblers
Thoughts to nibble on! 1/2 pound of all white meat coated in our signature breading
and fried to a golden brown, then tossed with your choice of mild or hot sauce.
Served with celery and bleu cheese. 7.99
Triple Sliders
For those who can’t decide… Have a trio of our famous Slow-Roasted Pulled Pork
Sandwich, Sloppy Joe and Black Angus Burger with American cheese — mini style.
Three baby feasts in one big meal! 7.99
Sloppy Nachos
Visit some old friends from South of the Border… Our terrific Sloppy Joe mix is
accompanied by our homemade tortilla chips and cheese sauce. We then add
shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, sour cream and salsa. ¡Sabroso! 8.99
Conch Fritters
A true Key West tradition — fresh conch battered with our secret spices, deep
fried and served with our homemade Key West and remoulade sauces. 6.99
Lightly battered and fried to a tender and crisp golden brown — like a sunset on the
briny — served with our homemade marinara. 8.99
Southwest Chicken Quesadilla
Inspired by the spirit of the old west, this giant flour tortilla is stuffed with grilled
chicken, cheddar jack cheese, onions and peppers, served with homemade salsa
and sour cream. 8.59
Artichoke Spinach Dip
Sloppy’s own homemade tri-colored tortilla chips are perfect for dipping into this
warm artichoke spinach dip. 6.99
Boatload Sampler
The very best of the collection — a generous assortment of our Calamari, Mozzarella
Sticks and Chicken Wings, served in our “Large Boat” with bleu cheese and marinara
sauce. 13.99
Divine Desserts
Classic Key Lime Pie
Nothing says “Key West” like fresh key lime pie! This fan
favorite is topped with fresh whipped cream. 4.99
Bimini Brownie Sundae
This family-size dessert feast features vanilla ice cream, fresh
baked brownies, chocolate and raspberry sauces, topped with
whipped cream. 7.99
Chocolate Mountain Cake
It’s worth the climb! We top a jumbo slice of cake with fresh
whipped cream. Serves 2. 7.99
“Need I Say More?” Cheesecake
Sloppy’s creamy cheesy best… served with strawberry sauce. 4.99
Banana Cream Pie
Take the plunge — delight in the marriage of a rich banana custard
in an Oreo cookie crumb crust, topped with fresh bananas, whipped
cream and sweet dark chocolate chips. 4.99
Choco-nutty Peanut Butter Pie
Who could resist this decadence? A rich, creamy blend of chocolate
and peanut butter in a chocolate crust topped with chunks of
Reese’s peanut butter cups. 5.99
Bag of Dough
Fish-shaped fresh dough fried golden brown, tossed with powdered
sugar, and served with a side of caramel and strawberry sauce…
bag that diet! 4.99
Bimini Beverages
Larger than life…
We offer our soft drinks, coffee and tea
in magnificent sizes!
Coke® • Diet Coke® • Sprite® • Root Beer
Orange Soda • Lemonade
Coffee (regular or decaf)
Iced Tea (sweetened or unsweetened)
Complimentary refills on the above SUPER SIZE beverages.
Apple, Cranberry, Grapefruit, Orange, Pineapple, Tomato
Check out our Sloppy Joe’s gift shop for authentic SJ stuff —
shirts so cool, even the locals wear them!
Prices and menu items are subject to change.
An 18% gratuity will be added to parties of 8 or more.
Follow us on FaceBook!
A Restaurant Partners Managed Property.
Illustration © Victor Bokas
Visit us on the web at
Homemade Soups & Chowder
Homemade Soup of the Day
This robust concoction is created daily from our chef’s selection of garden fresh
vegetables, meats, or seafood — for the hale and hearty! 4.99
Golden Lobster Bisque Soup
Our savory signature lobster bisque is generously served in a toasted bread
bowl. 6.59
Sloppy’s Daily Homemade Chowder
The freshest ingredients are featured in this homemade bowl of chowder. 4.99
Big Sloppy Salads
All of the following salads are Titanic in size — enough for an entrée!
Add a cup of Chowder or Soup to any salad for 2.99
The Bilmar
We start with crisp greens and hearts of palm, then add macadamia nuts,
plum tomatoes and mandarin oranges. Cuban-inspired plantain chips
round out this salad, which is served with a zesty raspberry vinaigrette
on the side. 8.99
Classic Caesar Salad
Robust and fresh, this traditional salad features Romaine gently tossed with
creamy Caesar dressing, and topped with garlic croutons and freshly grated
Parmesan cheese. 6.99
Thai Chicken Salad
We start off with Spring mix, then add chopped tomatoes, cucumber, rice
noodles, peanuts and grilled chicken, topped with orange ginger and spicy
peanut dressings. It’s a voyage to the Orient with a trip from our kitchen! 10.99
Gulf Boulevard Salad
Blending the tropical flavors of Cuba with a refreshing Spanish flair,
this abundant salad combines mixed greens, sliced celery, tomatoes,
crumbled bleu cheese and toasted walnuts tossed in our own balsamic
vinaigrette dressing, served in a crispy tortilla shell. 9.99
Retro Cobb Salad
Can’t find that great Cobb salad anymore? We’ve brought it back — in a huge way!
Chopped romaine lettuce with bacon, tomatoes, corn, cheddar jack cheese,
chopped chicken breast and buttermilk ranch dressing on the side. 10.99
El Pollo Taco Salad
The perfect tropical dish... Warm yellow rice and black beans layered in a crispy
tortilla bowl, topped with fresh chopped lettuce, cheddar jack cheese, tomatoes
and chopped chicken breast with buttermilk ranch on the side. 10.59
Treasure Island House Salad
You’ll find nothing fancy here, just a sizeable serving of crisp baby greens,
plum tomatoes, cucumber, Bermuda onion and croutons, dressed to your
liking. 5.99
Add one of these favorites to any of your salads:
Grilled Shrimp 5.99 • Chicken 3.99 • Salmon 4.99
Side Dressings:
Fat-Free Honey Mustard • Raspberry Vinaigrette
Bleu Cheese • Caesar • Buttermilk Ranch
Homemade Balsamic Vinaigrette • Thousand Island
Chef’s Beach Specialties
All entrées are served with a garden salad or Caesar salad.
Add a cup of Chowder or Soup to any entrée for 2.99
Treasure Isle Alfredo
No need to be “alfred-o” how good this pasta is — it’s just our interpretation of a
true classic. We toss linguini in our Sloppy-made Alfredo sauce, fresh broccoli
and diced tomatoes. 10.99 Make it your own by adding chicken or shrimp.
With chicken 13.99
With shrimp 15.99
Fresh Gulf Coast Grouper
Broiled, grilled, blackened or lightly fried — take your pick! We serve
this choice, tender white fish with Cuban rice and steamed seasonal
vegetables. 18.99
We proudly serve only Certified Fresh Grouper — taste the difference!
A Letter of Authenticity is posted in our front lobby.
Blackened 8-oz. Top Sirloin Steak
A steak that would satisfy the appetite of any hearty eater, this sirloin is
served with a jumbo baked potato and steamed seasonal vegetables. 15.99
With grilled shrimp 19.99 Topped with crumbled bleu cheese sauce 17.49
Chicken Parmesan
Another nod to Italy — a baked herb breaded chicken breast is topped with our
homemade marinara, mozzarella and parmesan cheeses, served on a bed of
linguine. 14.99
Crab Stuffed Tilapia
Tender and flaky, baked and topped with a lobster cream sauce, served on a bed
of Cuban rice and steamed seasonal vegetables. 18.99
Sloppy’s Tender Ribeye
Don’t let a little summer shower ruin your fun. “Eat up” a little time with our
14 oz. cut of the most flavorful of steaks. We combine our ribeye with a baked
potato and fresh vegetable medley. Trust us — you’ll want to take your time
with this one! 19.99
Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes
Enjoy a fisherman’s love for the sea. We use chunks of jumbo lump crab
to make these crab cakes the best on the beach, served with Cuban rice
and steamed seasonal vegetables. 21.99
Mahi Mahi Madness
The tropical atmosphere of the Keys gives us inspiration for this dish. Grilled to
perfection and served on a bed of yellow rice and steamed seasonal vegetables,
this mild white fish is topped with a golden lobster cream sauce. 15.99
Golden Gulf Shrimp Dinner
Enjoy the Chef’s treasure of succulent shrimp, lightly battered and fried,
served with French fries. Strike gold with this one! 15.99
Herb Crusted Grouper
A pan seared fresh grouper fillet covered with herb bread crumbs, topped with a
balsamic glaze and served with Cuban rice and steamed seasonal vegetables. 18.99
Day Boat Fresh Catch
You don’t have to struggle to reel in this great assortment of fresh seafood
and fish. We serve it right up in a fisherman’s boat with steamed vegetables
and Cuban rice. Ask your server for our daily combination. 16.99
Grilled Honey Glazed Salmon
So fresh, it tastes like it was just pulled from a brisk mountain stream, this salmon
fillet is accompanied by steamed seasonal vegetables and a baked jumbo sweet
potato with brown sugar butter. 14.99
Cravin’ Fish & Chips
We prepare this lusty portion of lightly fried cod, dipped in our homemade batter,
and serve it with French fries and tartar sauce. 13.99
Original Sloppy Joe’s
All sandwiches are served with your choice of: French fries, cole slaw,
field greens salad, sweet potato fries, Cuban yellow rice with black beans,
homemade tortilla chips or fresh potato chips.
Add a cup of Chowder or Soup to any sandwich for 2.99.
The Big Sloppy
We make our Sloppy Joe mix daily by slow cooking lean ground beef with
our special sauce and add diced peppers and onions to give it a little
zing. Piled high on an oversized sesame bun, this is a sandwich of manly
proportions. 7.99 Add cheddar jack cheese for 1.00
Cayo Hueso Chicken Wrap
Our Key West chicken wrap is a work of art, featuring grilled marinated
chicken, Cuban rice and black beans, jack cheese and salsa ranch in a
soft flour tortilla. 8.99
Fish Taco
A Key West favorite! These fried, grilled or blackened fresh grouper tenders are
topped with lettuce, salsa, cheddar jack cheese and avocado tartar sauce,
wrapped in a soft flour tortilla. 9.49
Big Dave’s “Beer Belly” Chicken Sandwich
Brewin’ to try this? Big Dave doesn’t disappoint! A marinated chicken breast,
grilled and topped with mounds of bacon and melted cheddar jack cheese
on a Kaiser bun. 8.99
Crab Cake Sandwich
We broil our famous crab cake until it is golden brown, then place it on a
Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, onion and a side of remoulade sauce. 10.99
Firecracker Shrimp Taco
This is all it’s cracked up to be! Lightly fried petite gulf shrimp are tossed
with our homemade firecracker sauce in a soft flour taco, topped with
cheddar jack cheese and California slaw. 8.99
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Straight from the farm… try our breaded fried chicken, shredded lettuce,
tomatoes and cheddar jack cheese all tossed in a Buffalo bleu cheese sauce,
then wrapped in a flour tortilla. 8.99
Slow-Roasted Pulled Pork Sandwich
The best things take time to develop… Sloppy’s special recipe: pulled pork
combined with our mildly spicy BBQ sauce is served on a toasted bun and
complemented with French fries or a side item of your choice. 8.59
Turkey Club Sandwich
No tall tales here! Savor our generously layered turkey sandwich, piled high
with Swiss cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo. 7.99
Fresh Gulf Coast Grouper
A tribute to the deep blue sea — we prepare this mild fish to your liking
and serve it on a Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, red onions and tartar
sauce. Prepared broiled, blackened, grilled or lightly fried. 11.99
We proudly serve only Certified Fresh Grouper — taste the difference!
A Letter of Authenticity is posted in our front lobby.
Have a Havana Sandwich
Sloppy’s own Cuban made with roasted pork, ham, salami, pickles, onion, Swiss
cheese, mustard and mayo on toasted Cuban bread, served with black beans and
rice, or a side item of your choice. 8.99
Philly Plus Cheese
We let this northern treat slip in! Thinly sliced steak with onions, peppers and
homemade cheese sauce served on a warm hoagie roll. 8.59
Sloppy’s Black Angus Burgers
We grill a half pound of Black Angus beef and add your favorite toppings,
all served up on a toasted Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato and red onions:
Plain 6.99 • Cheese 7.99 • Bacon Cheese 8.99 • Mushroom Jack 8.99